Walmart & Penningtons

  • Active since 1995, Hearth.com is THE place on the internet for free information and advice about wood stoves, pellet stoves and other energy saving equipment.

    We strive to provide opinions, articles, discussions and history related to Hearth Products and in a more general sense, energy issues.

    We promote the EFFICIENT, RESPONSIBLE, CLEAN and SAFE use of all fuels, whether renewable or fossil.
Status
Not open for further replies.

DAKSY

Full Time RVer
Staff member
Dec 2, 2008
9,966
Wherever we're parked
I helped a bud a couple of weeks ago with the install of an old Whitfield pellet stove that he picked up for nothing. Hadda core thru a poured foundation & install the vent for him, since he'd never done it. He told me that he'd bought some Pennington "Oak Hardwood" pellets at Walmart & that's what he was gonna burn. He managed to fry the original auger motor & then the replacement, before he decided that "FREE" didn't mean much. So he went to Lowe's - because he had a card with zero balance - & grabbed a floor model Englander for $1600 less 10% & asked me to stop back & hook THAT up. He said the vent didn't line up & didn't know what he needed to make it work. I asked him to grab another 12" adjustable & I thought that I could get him back in business with only that one piece. He didn't understand how, because his new stove exited higher than the Whitfield, but I told him to trust me, & we'd get it up & running. Well, he decided to play around & he managed to get the vent hooked up correctly with that adjustable in the place of a solid piece. He called me to say that he got the vent connected, but now his new stove didn't work. I grabbed a bag of Cleanfires & I met him after he got out of work yesterday. I noticed 5 bags of Penningtons sitting in the basement. I had him turn the unit on & no auger turning. He took the back off the unit & we could see the motor TRYING to turn, so I had him turn it off & grab his shop vac & empty the hopper. Didn't have a whole lot of pellets in there & after a bout 15 seconds he exposed the auger...I could see that there was a pellet caught between the top of the auger flight & the auger housing & asked him to get a screw driver. I got the pellet out & I don't know what it was made of, but MOST of it wasn't sawdust. It was more like a hardwood stick match with a saw dust coating on it... Once that was removed, the auger motor turned the auger freely. I dumped the Cleanfires into his hopper & let er rip. It took a little while since he neglected to prime the burnpot, but once it lit it burned fine. I asked him what kind of pellets he was planning to burn now & he was gonna go to the hearth shop I used to work at & grab some of their stuff...I'm willing to bet that his FREE Whitfield had the same jam with a pellet & that it'll work fine...Moral? Don't know. Maybe that the quality of Pennington pellets is questionable, or at LEAST arguable...The Englander unit seems like it was pretty well built, but I'm glad I'm burning underfeed Harmans, instead of some other manufacturer's drop feed units...
 
I'm glad I'm burning underfeed Harmans, instead of some other manufacturer's drop feed units...

I'll second that.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DAKSY
I have never burned them thanks to this forum. I see so many posts saying to stay away from them. Id bet the harman would feed them so you can help your buddy out by disposing of them for him.
 
Burned pennington's for many years, before i knew of this forum and what pellet's meant, never had a issue with them in my whitfield, shame you gave up on the Whit
 
Burned pennington's for many years, before i knew of this forum and what pellet's meant, never had a issue with them in my whitfield, shame you gave up on the Whit

I didn't give up on it & neither did my bud. Now that he knows what caused his issues, he's gonna clean it, repair it & install it in his garage. He definitely WON'T be burning any Penningtons in it...
 
Auger bushing worn?
 
I carry Pennington in my store, or at least what I can get-- they've stopped making them at my local plant (Missouri) I have had nothing but great luck with them. However, I did purchase a bag from Wal-Mart for comparison and they are night and day. The Wal-Mart pellets were bigger, dirtier, and not anywhere neat the quality. It was apparent that what goes to the big boxes (made in Georgia), at least in my area, are different than what they send elsewhere.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.