recommendations for a hearthstone woodstove

  • Active since 1995, Hearth.com is THE place on the internet for free information and advice about wood stoves, pellet stoves and other energy saving equipment.

    We strive to provide opinions, articles, discussions and history related to Hearth Products and in a more general sense, energy issues.

    We promote the EFFICIENT, RESPONSIBLE, CLEAN and SAFE use of all fuels, whether renewable or fossil.
Status
Not open for further replies.

mark cline

Minister of Fire
Dec 20, 2012
795
Cattaraugus, NY
I am building a custom log home that is about 2100 sq ft. with cathedral ceilings at 26 ft at the peak. The floor plan is all open , so I will have about 5 ceiling fans to circulate the warm air away from the ceiling. . I want to put in a Hearthstone soapstone stove with a large front opening so it can be used as a fireplace to satisfy my wife's desire for a fireplace and then to be able to heat the loghome.. I'm currently heating my 1100 sq ft ranch with a Fisher Momma Bear stove and have been for 25 years, so heating with wood is nothing new. I want to size the Hearthstone to provide enough heat but not have it too big to where I end up with creosote problems.I'm leaning towards the Mansfield at 2500 sqft heating ability or an older 2 front door Hearthstone stove . Anybody know the name of the older 2 front door Hearthstone stove . Give me your feed back, thanks
 
If this is all new, and you are used to working with seasoned wood (cut, split, stacked for 1 to 2 years depending on the species) then there's no way I'd be looking at an older unit. A new one will serve you much better with longer / cleaner burns.

The fireplace is a must? A heck of a lot cheaper to build a stone or similar wall behind a freestanding stove than to build a fireplace just to put a stove in it. But, that of course depends on what it takes to keep the lady happy.

Welcome to the site.

pen
 
depends on were your located in northern canada i would use a equinox in say massachusetts i would use a mansfield. the mansfield throughs excellent heat although i always have thought bigger is better. if your wood is dry go big youll need it on the coldest nights all depends on location and winter severity i guess
 
  • Like
Reactions: jeff_t
To use the stove as a fireplace is a compromise that took a long time to convince my wife that a fireplace is inefficient. I have 175 acres of hardwoods , so 2-4 years of dry seasoned wood is the norm . I'm building in Western New York near the PA border, so not as cold as northern Canada but colder than Mass.
 
A few days in winter without the stove running will convince your wife that you have made a good decision. Focus on the primary functions you need from the stove. You might want to consider however, a high-efficiency, EPA, zero-clearance fireplace that would make your wife happy, yet would be a good home heater.
 
With 26 ft high ceilings in a cold climate in a log home, I'm tempted to say Equinox. A log home isn't the greatest in terms of insulation if I recall.

Also:
I want to size the Hearthstone to provide enough heat but not have it too big to where I end up with creosote problems.
That is an incorrect statement. With dry fuel you can absolutely oversize a stove for your area without worrying about creosote. Just build smaller fires when it is called for.
 
If you aren't sold on building a fireplace just to put an insert in it, I'd consider going through the gallery here https://www.hearth.com/gall/main.php and/or do some google image searches to find installs that are beautiful without being inside a fireplace.

My problem with an insert is they aren't worth poo w/out the blower running. The blower running means sound / moving air on a constant basis not to mention a no/low heat situation when / if the power goes out.

pen
 
To use the stove as a fireplace is a compromise that took a long time to convince my wife that a fireplace is inefficient.
My wife felt that way too. In the five years since we started using wood, she's done it once. I have four stove screens sitting in the attic.

Right now the wife is dead asleep in a toasty living room completely oblivious to the fact that I was right and her requirements were irrational. My victory dance is done quietly in the middle of the night with only the cat as my witness, but it is a victory none the less.
 
Insulation in the roof is R 65 and the log walls are about R15. Energy efficient doors and windows throughout , so the Mansfield seems a better fit. I will have another woodstove in the basement with an open stair well above the stove to allow heat to move up into the house. If that doesn't provide enough heat , I can also fire up my antique wood fired cookstove in the kitchen .
 
The Mansfield is a good stove. Sounds like you have a plan.
 
I have a equinox and it burns good .
plenty of heat and a long burn time the stove stays hot for 24hrs .
I heat 3000 sq feet +
I had the 2 door stove it was a heritage i think .
I would go with the EQ It has a large glass door no need to leave it open .
If its 30o out side we lite a fire at 500pm feed the stove at bed time and let it burn out .
start over the next day .
No creasolt at all.
If its cold i stuff it with 13/ 14 logs and let it rip
5 log burn nice at 350o not to hot with a long burn i sit 5' from the stove and its not to hot .
John
 
Status
Not open for further replies.