Insert "top" temperature?

  • Active since 1995, Hearth.com is THE place on the internet for free information and advice about wood stoves, pellet stoves and other energy saving equipment.

    We strive to provide opinions, articles, discussions and history related to Hearth Products and in a more general sense, energy issues.

    We promote the EFFICIENT, RESPONSIBLE, CLEAN and SAFE use of all fuels, whether renewable or fossil.
Status
Not open for further replies.
Mar 21, 2006
184
North of Boston
OK, so I know all you woodstove owners can measure your stove top temp to get an idea of how well she's burning.. What about for us insert types?

The Clydesdale insert has a small air gap between the cast iron insert and the enameled trim cover "warming shelf" that surrounds the door. That gap has to provide some insulative value right? so does a stove top thermo have any value?

I use one of those infrared thermometers, and I've learned that the secondary burn tube temp doesn't really tell me all that much - particularly at startup. The burn tubes can be 600 degrees or so and have a nice secondary burn going, but if the rest of the stove is still cold... the secondary burn might go away if I damper down too soon. I think all that soapstone and cast iron sucks up the heat. I find I don't get a real stable secondary burn if the "warming shelf" is much under 300 degrees. And the burn gets better and better, the hotter the top gets.

This morning the top hit a new high... I was getting ready for work and caught the scent of outgassing enamel (like I have each time the insert has reached a new high temp since the breakin) I ran over to the insert and nothing looked amiss.. in fact, it looked like a perfect fire. Nice bed of coals, several large splits charred over, and the Aurora Borealis dancing above them. (Door closed and damper was about 1/3rd open I think)

I grabbed my trusty ray gun and measured the "warming shelf" - 520 in the center!!!

So I dampered down some more and turned on the blowers to suck off some of the heat.

So how high can I go? and would a stove top thermometer be worthwhile? I was thinking that they wouldn't be much use on an insert...

-TNB
 
I will chime in and provide almost no help at all. How's that for an intro.

The reason I say I will not be of much help is that I have been wondering the same thing with mine. I have a magnetic thermometer sitting (laying) on the top of my insert. I too am sure that this registers a lower temperature than the actual top of the insert.

I have had mine as high as 600* on the top. Usually I burn a bit lower, around 400* - 450*.

I know I can look in the firebox and see what's going on and hear and feel quite a bit as well. I would still like to have some temperature range to use as a benchmark.

Hope this helps or starts some 'real info' flowing.
 
I put the Rutland magnetic thermometer on the actual top of my insert, in the air channel itself. That way I am getting a direct temperature reading of the stove itself. The only thing that could impact it is the air flow from the fan, however I always keep the fan on low, and the back side of the thermometer has a 3 sided metal shield around the bimetallic coil, so I don't think the air impacts the readings much. The photo below shows my setup, except for one difference... I have rotated the thermometer 180 degrees, so the rounded edge faces out. The reason for this is that I can see the 300-700 degree temperature range easier, even though the numbers are upside-down. Normal operating temperature is around 650, regular highs of 800, maximim high of over 900, lows with secondary of about 450 or so.

-- Mike
 

Attachments

  • P2230010.JPG
    P2230010.JPG
    38.1 KB · Views: 359
I have the same insert, and I asked my dealer where a good place to stick a thermometer on it would be, and he told me nowhere....Maybe a better solution for this type would be a flue thermometer, and run it off the flue temps. I see a lot of good information on the boards about flue temps, and they dont seem equipment specific. Good luck, we are really enjoying our Clydesdale.
 
Take a look at these threads:

https://www.hearth.com/econtent/index.php/forums/viewthread/5614/

https://www.hearth.com/econtent/index.php/forums/viewthread/5506/

As a seminewbie with an insert, what I think I've learned here is that:
- Comparing flue temps on a wood stove to box temps on an insert will always be apples-to-oranges
- The longer you have a stove / insert the less attention you pay to a thermometer reading
- With an insert you're better off placing the thermometer on the stove front, off to one side, than on the stove top
- A thermometer CAN be useful to diagnose leaky doors or other sources of air infiltration
- and probably some other stuff that I've already forgotten. At my age for every new thing you need to remember you have to forget something else, kinda like a full hard disk.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.