Heating workshop: Boiler vs mini-split vs ???

  • Active since 1995, Hearth.com is THE place on the internet for free information and advice about wood stoves, pellet stoves and other energy saving equipment.

    We strive to provide opinions, articles, discussions and history related to Hearth Products and in a more general sense, energy issues.

    We promote the EFFICIENT, RESPONSIBLE, CLEAN and SAFE use of all fuels, whether renewable or fossil.
Status
Not open for further replies.

paulm81

New Member
Feb 15, 2012
29
Lucknow Ontario
I built a new workshop over the last several months and am now considering options to heat it. It is 960 sq. ft. with a 12 foot ceiling. I would only work out there on weekends likely, but I would like to keep it at 5 to 10 *C with the option to bring it up a bit if I know I'm going to be working out there.

I found a spreadsheet online to calculate heat loads and to keep it at 15*C inside with -15*C outside would take about 15000 BTU/hr, but we rarely see temps that cold. I found average temps for this area (the coldest average daily temp is only -3*C) and calculated the annual total heat load for every day under 10*C and came up with 27.5 million BTU.

The first option I am considering is a mini-split heat pump. Mitsubishi has some models that provide rated heat output down to -15*C. The main advantages are no user effort and no floor space lost. The disadvantages are cost of the unit, although I would likely buy from ebay and do as much of the install myself as possible, and complexity. If anything ever goes wrong with the unit, there is very little I can fix myself. I am also concerned with under-performance in case my calculations are off. Electricity costs to cover my annual heat load would be about $400, although who knows where this will go.

My second option is some kind of wood fired boiler. I put 2" insulation under the floating slab foundation and I have pex in the floor, just in case I ever wanted to use this option. We are set up to handle wood as we have an insert in the house and I don't mind the work or mess. I don't have a source of wood though, so I would have to buy it. My biggest concern is the initial cost of the boiler, does anyone know of a smaller, low cost, simple boiler that is still CSA or UL approved? I would build one, but don't want to void my insurance if anything ever happens. I would also like to incorporate storage, but maybe with the thermal mass of the concrete this isn't as important? The wood system appeals to me as I enjoy tinkering and it is simple enough to tweak and repair if necessary. If it gets really cold, it's not too hard to burn a bit more wood, whereas the heat pump may be in trouble, but with a heat pump, I could just turn on some electric heat if I really need it.

Thoughts, concerns, and opinions are much appreciated!!
 
A fullsize boiler is out of the question price-wise just for the shop. For that much money, I could install the heat pump and enough solar panels to run it > no work and no fuel cost!! Are there any simple low-cost wood boilers available? Basically a firebox inside a tank?

I would have no problem building something like this with all the proper safeties, but my insurance company will have a problem with it!!!
 
A fullsize boiler is out of the question price-wise just for the shop. For that much money, I could install the heat pump and enough solar panels to run it > no work and no fuel cost!! Are there any simple low-cost wood boilers available? Basically a firebox inside a tank?

I would have no problem building something like this with all the proper safeties, but my insurance company will have a problem with it!!!

i have seen a bunch of gassers for sale used for 1-2k.
 
I've been checking the classifieds around here and haven't seen anything even remotely suitable. I don't really know of many indoor boilers around here period, the outdoor ones seem more popular.

Anyone have experience or opinions on the mini-split heat pumps?
 
Anyone have experience or opinions on the mini-split heat pumps?​
I have two mini-splits installed. One 9000 btu in the master bedroom and a 12000 btu unit in the main open living space. They are mainly used for cooling. I only use them for heat very early in the fall or very late in the spring to warm up on a chilly morning. They are useless when outside temperatures drop into the forties and the efficiency also diminishes as the outside temperature drops. They are about three years old and I have not kept up with what the latest and greatest advancements are in engineering of these units so you may find different numbers in your searches.
I also have dual heat pumps in my RV that are tied in with the propane furnaces. When the outside temperatures drop to about +-45, the propane furnaces are activated.
 
They are useless when outside temperatures drop into the forties and the efficiency also diminishes as the outside temperature drops.
I think this is my biggest concern, some of the new ones claim pretty impressive numbers, but how that translates into the real world is an expensive gamble.

I think I'm pretty much set on using wood to heat the slab, but I still haven't found a simple low cost boiler.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.