Hearth--did I make a mistake?

  • Active since 1995, Hearth.com is THE place on the internet for free information and advice about wood stoves, pellet stoves and other energy saving equipment.

    We strive to provide opinions, articles, discussions and history related to Hearth Products and in a more general sense, energy issues.

    We promote the EFFICIENT, RESPONSIBLE, CLEAN and SAFE use of all fuels, whether renewable or fossil.
Status
Not open for further replies.

holg

Member
Feb 4, 2011
58
northern WI
O.K. Let's start with 2 facts. #1. I over-think everything. #2. I have received excellent advice here, both thru reading other threads and in response to my post questions.

So here's my question. I have a Hearthstone Heritage, not yet installed or used, but built before Hearthstone started putting the longer legs on it. I have an almost complete Hearth. Construction of the hearth is:
1. ~ 5' by 5' hearth
1. 2x 4 framing, 2 x 4s ripped to 2 3/4" height.
2. 3/4" underlayment on top of 2x 4 framing--super flat, with out dips or high spots.
3. one layer of 1/2" New Generation Durock, screwed to 3/4" underlayment, Durock screws, no thinset.
4. layer of thin set.
5. 2nd layer of Durock, screwed thru first layer of Durock and into underlayment.
6. Next will be added another layer of thinset and 3rd layer of Durock, screwed thru first 2 layers with 2 1/4" Cement Board screws, again into the underlayment.
7. Final layer will be Bluestone, in a mortar bed.

Being concerned about the possible heat transfer from the stove thru the Durock screws to the underlayment, I made a pattern of the footprint of the stove on each layer of Durock. As I have applied the Durock, I did not put any screws in the footprint of the stove. I started the screw pattern along the periphery of the footprint of the stove, working out from the stove footprint, to keep the Durock flat. Put the screws 6" on center at edges and along the periphery of the footprint, and 8" spacing in the field of the Durock. I staggered the spacing of the screws on each layer thus far. As I go to put on the last layer, I realize I will have a lot of metal screws along the periphery of the footprint of the stove, within 1 and a half inches of the periphery of the footprint of the stove, and again am worried about heat transfer.

Yes, I should have thinset both of the last 2 layers simultaneously and that would have cut down on the number of screws, but foolishly didn't do that.

So, concerned re: heat transfer, should I:
1. Quit worrying
2. Tear it all up and screw it different or start over.
3. See if I can get the longer legs for the Heritage and raise the height of the stove.
4. Or do some other thing I am not thinking about.

Thanks in advance for responses.
 
LOL. Be sure to put the next cement board layer at right angles to the underlying layers.
 
  • Like
Reactions: PapaDave and jeff_t
+1 on #1. Those screws are barely going to get warm.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Seanm
I'd rip it apart, use thinset this time and add two more layers of durock, :p



nah, your alright.
 
Most stoves throw very little heat out their bottoms. Sometimes our cat goes under out stove to sleep!
 
Ohhh you and I could have some neurotic conversations lol..........while stirring more thinset. ==c
 
Is his name Mr Bigglesworth ?
Thanks for all the responses. I think I too will go with option 1 and quit worrying about it. And yes, I do drive myself, and my wife, quite nuts at times. Just to be sure that I won't be banned from the forum for being overly crazy, I will not enlighten you all with what I went thru "just to be sure" the floor joists would support my hearth and stove.
 
Thanks for all the responses. I think I too will go with option 1 and quit worrying about it. And yes, I do drive myself, and my wife, quite nuts at times. Just to be sure that I won't be banned from the forum for being overly crazy, I will not enlighten you all with what I went thru "just to be sure" the floor joists would support my hearth and stove.
LOL. I'm sure you'll have the best built hearth in history. Which is much better than having the worst.
 
There ain't no such thing as being too safe. Contrary to popular thinking there actually is such a thing as a silly question.

Your question wasn't.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Sprinter
Status
Not open for further replies.