Update: How would you handle this?

  • Active since 1995, Hearth.com is THE place on the internet for free information and advice about wood stoves, pellet stoves and other energy saving equipment.

    We strive to provide opinions, articles, discussions and history related to Hearth Products and in a more general sense, energy issues.

    We promote the EFFICIENT, RESPONSIBLE, CLEAN and SAFE use of all fuels, whether renewable or fossil.
Status
Not open for further replies.

ZBrooks

Burning Hunk
Nov 30, 2013
155
Caldwell, Idaho
Yesterday was the big day. I had the day off and my brand new Harman P61A was at the dealer, so I made the 30 minute drive to get return the older stove in exchange for the new one. When I got there, the dealer 'thought I had already come and picked it up'. What?! When we got to where the new stove was, I asked him how old the other was and he didn't think it could be more than a year or two old. This is where things started to warm up and get interesting. I told him that Harman said it is a month shy of 5 years old and he blew it off and he reply was that age didn't matter because it was only a demo stove and was still considered new, in his opinion. I then pointed out that I don't know anyone that would show up at the car dealership and pay top dollar for a car that had been sitting there for the past 5 years; it doesn't make sense. At this point, he's starting to get irritated with me, but I'm keeping my cool. He mentioned that it doesn't matter if the stove sits in Harman's warehouse or his for years, it's still a new stove. At this point, I told him I was feeling uneasy about the prospect that some form of fraud was involved here. "I can get you the number to the state attorney general if you'd like!" I told him that I already had the number in my pocket (along with the local PD, BBB and newspaper), so that wasn't necessary. "Then file the claim!" I just want to swap stoves and avoid those measures.

We then got into a discussion of how the age of the stove was unknown until I contacted Harman because I noticed that the label didn't match the one pictured in the manual that shows a mfg date. He tried telling me that date was on the label of the stove I initially purchased and that the label has been the same for the past 20 years. It obviously wasn't and I told him that he can just look at the one on the stove in the back of my truck to verify. That just tee'd him off and he started huffing about let's just get this over with. I agreed, but not before finding out how old the new stove was. He guaranteed that it was probably a couple years old, as well, because they make these things in advance. I mentioned that if it was, I'll ask for my money back. "Fine, I'll just give you your money back now!" Can I open the box first? Shortly after this, he discovered that the tag on the box stated a mfg date of Aug 2013. Great, I'll take it.

We went inside and he double checked all of my information, along with informing me that the stove would be registered electronically. After one of his employees loaded the new stove with the fork lift, I went back inside to make sure we were all square. The dealer walked over to me, shook my hand and sincerely apologized for the whole ordeal in front of his employee and another customer. I appreciated that and told him that if he's interested in selling the stove that I brought back at a much discounted price, let me know because I'm interested. The free ton of pellets stayed free, as well.

My take: I went to a platinum dealer that has a pretty busy stove department in his True Value branded store. He's an older guy that probably needs a couple more employees running around to help him out. I've employed over 60 15-22 year old individuals in my business, so I'd like to believe that I'm pretty good at reading people and deciphering whether or not they're lying to me. In my opinion, this dealer really didn't know how old this stove was and wasn't trying to outright hose me in the deal. I believe that he is so busy that he isn't keeping track of details very well AT ALL. He didn't even check to make sure I brought the old stove back (!!!), for instance.

This really makes me question the qualification requirements for becoming the second highest level of a Harman dealership. This dealer gave me advice and opinions that were in direct contradiction to the owners manual. I hope that this dealer is a reflection of the minority of dealers out there.

Hopefully, my experience helps my fellow pellet stove newbies in their future dealings with dealers for what to look out for, questions to ask, etc.
 
I got the new stove fired up for the burn in. I let it run for 3 hours. I can't wait to hook it up, but will have to for a few days until I get the tile laid for the renovated hearth. This project took on a life of its own while we were waiting for the new stove to arrive.

Here's a picture of it before I unloaded it.
 

Attachments

  • NewP61A.jpg
    NewP61A.jpg
    163.6 KB · Views: 320
  • Like
Reactions: IHATEPROPANE
WOW.

You, sir, are an extremely patient man.

Glad you got a new stove and the ordeal is over. I'll keep any negative comments towards your dealer (DINK! :mad:) to myself, but I would double check with Harman and make sure the stove was in fact registered properly, which it probably was.

Now, let's see some install pics!

Happy New Year
 
  • Like
Reactions: ZBrooks
Are the kids & the dog trying to rush that install?
 
You're a very reasonable guy. Nicely done. Congrats!

Now let's get burning!
 
  • Like
Reactions: ZBrooks
Good on you for having the patience to turn a potential urination competition into a satisfactory outcome.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ZBrooks
Yesterday was the big day. I had the day off and my brand new Harman P61A was at the dealer, so I made the 30 minute drive to get return the older stove in exchange for the new one. When I got there, the dealer 'thought I had already come and picked it up'. What?! When we got to where the new stove was, I asked him how old the other was and he didn't think it could be more than a year or two old. This is where things started to warm up and get interesting. I told him that Harman said it is a month shy of 5 years old and he blew it off and he reply was that age didn't matter because it was only a demo stove and was still considered new, in his opinion. I then pointed out that I don't know anyone that would show up at the car dealership and pay top dollar for a car that had been sitting there for the past 5 years; it doesn't make sense. At this point, he's starting to get irritated with me, but I'm keeping my cool. He mentioned that it doesn't matter if the stove sits in Harman's warehouse or his for years, it's still a new stove. At this point, I told him I was feeling uneasy about the prospect that some form of fraud was involved here. "I can get you the number to the state attorney general if you'd like!" I told him that I already had the number in my pocket (along with the local PD, BBB and newspaper), so that wasn't necessary. "Then file the claim!" I just want to swap stoves and avoid those measures.

We then got into a discussion of how the age of the stove was unknown until I contacted Harman because I noticed that the label didn't match the one pictured in the manual that shows a mfg date. He tried telling me that date was on the label of the stove I initially purchased and that the label has been the same for the past 20 years. It obviously wasn't and I told him that he can just look at the one on the stove in the back of my truck to verify. That just tee'd him off and he started huffing about let's just get this over with. I agreed, but not before finding out how old the new stove was. He guaranteed that it was probably a couple years old, as well, because they make these things in advance. I mentioned that if it was, I'll ask for my money back. "Fine, I'll just give you your money back now!" Can I open the box first? Shortly after this, he discovered that the tag on the box stated a mfg date of Aug 2013. Great, I'll take it.
Wow, you did great, but the dealer, not so much. While you gave this whole exchange a great deal of thought, the dealer didn't think anything of it. His manner towards customers is a bit shocking, confrontational, not caring about things that obviously matter to the customer. Hard to believe he's been in business long with that attitude.
 
Are the kids & the dog trying to rush that install?

No one more than me. The 20 year old house has a 20 year old electric furnace for heat. The fan runs constantly, blowing cold air much of the time. My electric bill last month without the pellet stove was just short of $500. I have a separate meter for my shop, but it doesn't draw much power right now. With the crappy Fabco pellet stove that was in the house before it went TU, my bill was about half that much.

Since I am in a bit of a rush to install the stove, will any damage occur to it if I keep the 3" vent in place until warmer weather arrives and run the stove? The vent will be about 25' straight up. I'll upgrade to 4" at the end of the season. My main issue with running the vent straight out the wall and then up is that I have a ventilated soffit separating the 1st and 2nd floor. See pictures. The vent that is taped shut is where the OAK will be. It is 6" in diameter.
 

Attachments

  • pellet.vent1.jpg
    pellet.vent1.jpg
    160.4 KB · Views: 221
  • pellet.vent.2.jpg
    pellet.vent.2.jpg
    100.2 KB · Views: 206
No one more than me. The 20 year old house has a 20 year old electric furnace for heat. The fan runs constantly, blowing cold air much of the time. My electric bill last month without the pellet stove was just short of $500. I have a separate meter for my shop, but it doesn't draw much power right now. With the crappy Fabco pellet stove that was in the house before it went TU, my bill was about half that much.

Since I am in a bit of a rush to install the stove, will any damage occur to it if I keep the 3" vent in place until warmer weather arrives and run the stove? The vent will be about 25' straight up. I'll upgrade to 4" at the end of the season. My main issue with running the vent straight out the wall and then up is that I have a ventilated soffit separating the 1st and 2nd floor. See pictures. The vent that is taped shut is where the OAK will be. It is 6" in diameter.
I think you will far exceed the EVL limit with 25' of 3" pipe. I wouldn't chance it...JMHO
 
I think you will far exceed the EVL limit with 25' of 3" pipe. I wouldn't chance it...JMHO

Alright, that's what I figured, especially since the manual says to go to 4" for anything over 15'.

What is stressed in this situation, the distribution blower?

Why would a natural draft pellet stove function with 25' of pipe, but a stove with a blower should have a larger vent? I thought that the lack of efficiency in my old stove was because it did not have a combustion fan.
 
Alright, that's what I figured, especially since the manual says to go to 4" for anything over 15'.

What is stressed in this situation, the distribution blower?

Why would a natural draft pellet stove function with 25' of pipe, but a stove with a blower should have a larger vent? I thought that the lack of efficiency in my old stove was because it did not have a combustion fan.
Today's pellet stoves are not natural draft. They actually work in a vacuum/negative pressure situation. 3" exhaust at 25 ' in length is too far to "push"
 
If you were to come straight out 12" or so, and then up 24", I cant imagine a problem. You'd have to fab some kind of pipe support...since standard are designed to hold the pipe 3" or so from the house. Just a thought.
 
I applaud keeping your cool! (I would have done the opposite.. lol) I would have lowballed him on the spot hard for the floor model... He would never be able to move that thing, but then again a sucker is born every minute.

What is stressed in this situation, the distribution blower?
.

Today's pellet stoves are not natural draft. They actually work in a vacuum/negative pressure situation. 3" exhaust at 25 ' in length is too far to "push"

With that said... because it combustion fan wouldn't be able to evacuate the exhaust gas fast enough it could whack out ESP readings.
 
Good job, I've dealt with car dealers and their " Fuzzy Math " before .. it is not fun ...
 
No one more than me. The 20 year old house has a 20 year old electric furnace for heat. The fan runs constantly, blowing cold air much of the time. My electric bill last month without the pellet stove was just short of $500. I have a separate meter for my shop, but it doesn't draw much power right now. With the crappy Fabco pellet stove that was in the house before it went TU, my bill was about half that much.

Since I am in a bit of a rush to install the stove, will any damage occur to it if I keep the 3" vent in place until warmer weather arrives and run the stove? The vent will be about 25' straight up. I'll upgrade to 4" at the end of the season. My main issue with running the vent straight out the wall and then up is that I have a ventilated soffit separating the 1st and 2nd floor. See pictures. The vent that is taped shut is where the OAK will be. It is 6" in diameter.
Just my thoughts,your old pipe is old and dirty and too small.Your 6" hole already there is a quick no brainer,use it.Clearance to vented soffit is 2 foot per your stove book.Also if those vents are open to the inside of the house in any way it would be very hard to heat.They are there to vent the overhang only,not the attic.If you had any worries block off the vent right above it,and/or run oak.
 
If you were to come straight out 12" or so, and then up 24", I cant imagine a problem. You'd have to fab some kind of pipe support...since standard are designed to hold the pipe 3" or so from the house. Just a thought.

Just my thoughts,your old pipe is old and dirty and too small.Your 6" hole already there is a quick no brainer,use it.Clearance to vented soffit is 2 foot per your stove book.Also if those vents are open to the inside of the house in any way it would be very hard to heat.They are there to vent the overhang only,not the attic.If you had any worries block off the vent right above it,and/or run oak.

Thanks for the input. The vents are not open to the inside of the house, so no worries there. Venting this way is going to be much cheaper than replacing the entire chimney chase with 4" vent, so that is a plus, even when I include the cost of the thimble and supports.

Are Harman thimbles only available via Harman dealers?
 
I am impressed with your patience and happy with your results. You did well my friend. Reading what you wrote carefully, I think you're right...he is just clueless in his business dealings. I just have to wonder how many people were (perhaps unintentionally) the recipients of some dubious deals and just didn't know it?

Glad you kept the pellets too!

Looking forward to seeing that beast installed and pumping out some heat!
 
Glad to see this finally worked out to your satisfaction. Happy burning on your new stove
 
Status
Not open for further replies.