Hearthstone Homestead Review after three seasons

  • Active since 1995, Hearth.com is THE place on the internet for free information and advice about wood stoves, pellet stoves and other energy saving equipment.

    We strive to provide opinions, articles, discussions and history related to Hearth Products and in a more general sense, energy issues.

    We promote the EFFICIENT, RESPONSIBLE, CLEAN and SAFE use of all fuels, whether renewable or fossil.
Status
Not open for further replies.

SDWoodburner

New Member
Jan 4, 2014
14
South Dakota
Hello all I'm new here but have read stuff from these forums numerous times. Very good information here.

Thought I would take some time to review my woodstove. I purchased a freestanding Hearthstone Homestead three years ago after deciding that having some sort of alternative heat would be wise. After much searching and looking at various stoves I absolutely fell in love with the Hearthstone line of stoves. I felt the Homestead would be the best fit for our 2100 sq. ft. split entry home as it wasn't too big and should, I felt, keep the basement (always cold) warm. Well I've now had some experience with this stove and while it's not perfect, it's darn good and when we leave this home it will go with us.

As I said I live in a split entry home built in 2001 and I placed my stove on a homebuilt hearth pad in the basement living room. After installation and acquiring my first load of Ash I assumed that the stove would just be able to provide supplemental heat and that I would still have to heat primarily with my NG furnace. My first winter, though mild, proved otherwise. When the stove is running I do not need the furnace at all and all rooms in the house are cozy both up and down. Obviously the basement living room is the warmest, but I can even out the temperature even more by running just the furnace fan and option I rarely do. There was some learning that had to occur on my part before I really started burning right. I grew up with old inefficient stoves so I was shocked that when the stove was burning correctly there was no visible smoke from the stove pipe. When I first noticed this I ran back inside quickly because I thought something had gone wrong. The second thing I learned is that this stove likes to get good and hot (that is hot for a soapstone) before you turn it down to low before bed. After a few blacked glass episodes I got wise to this, kind of embarrassing looking back. Also this stove will puff smoke when opening the door, it just does and I think it is because of the path the smoke has to take to go out of the stove. I learned to obviously burn only seasoned wood, properly kindle and only load the stove when the fire has burned down to bright red coals. Doing this has taken care of 90% of the puffing. The simple and reliable "reburn" system works as advertised and I prefer it over the catalytic models as I think simple is better and I don't want to buy replacements even if it is only every 10 years. The ash pan is, well, a joke. Anyone seriously heating with this stove as I am will simply ignore it and shovel ash once a week or so.

As stated this little stove easily heats our entire home even when it is well below zero out. This winter is hardly mild so I am burning more than I have in the past, still I believe I will be just shy of a 3 cord year. I'm quite happy with that consumption. All and all I would highly recommend Hearthstone for their beauty, efficiency and build quality. Soapstone really is something to behold. Additionally the Homestead is their cleanest burning 1.9 grams/hr and most efficient model 83.5%. I fully realize that these numbers aren't achieved every time you stoke a fire but it is reassuring that I am being as responsible with my fuel as possible. Having beautiful alternative heat that is independent from the grid and that we can cook on makes me very comfortable and it has become my families favorite spot to gather.
 

Attachments

  • WP_20140104_004.jpg
    WP_20140104_004.jpg
    135.9 KB · Views: 1,849
Last edited by a moderator:
Welcome and thanks for the very helpful review. What stove top temps are you normally seeing?

FYI If you haven't already submitted a review to the database, please add it here:
https://www.hearth.com/talk/ratings.php
 
  • Like
Reactions: PapaDave
I can't resolve what I'm seeing in the pic with what I think I'm reading in the manual about 8" hearth protection on both sides. Maybe it's just the angle of the pic, dunno.
 
  • Like
Reactions: PapaDave
begreen, thanks for the heads up. I did so after your post and I am really not sure what I have for surface temps, never have put a thermometer to it. I know better than to let it roar like a freight train. Just have learned it sweet spots through experience I guess. fossil, I know it really looks like I dont have it, but it is 8" to the door opening not the unit itself, unless I completely misunderstood. As I understand it I have 8" on the button to the side and if it ever became an issue I'd simply slide it over a bit (with the help of two men and a boy!).
 
Welcome to the forum SDWoodburner.

You gave a good review of the stove and we're happy for you. On the puffing, not sure if you've tried it but usually opening the draft full open a minute or 2 or 3 before opening that firebox door and then opening that door slowly will usually take care of the problem. The only flaw I saw in your review is on that clean burn. Although it is great, it is not the cleanest but don't get excited as it is not that big of a margin.
 
  • Like
Reactions: gyrfalcon
Welcome to the forum SDWoodburner.
The only flaw I saw in your review is on that clean burn. Although it is great, it is not the cleanest but don't get excited as it is not that big of a margin.

SDW said that the Homestead is Hearthstone's cleanest burning model. If not, which Hearthstone stove is?
 
Sorry, my error. I missed that point. The difference between the and their. Please don't hang me for this....
 
No problem, I just didn't want the OP to be confused. His review is very helpful.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Backwoods Savage
Ya know...I'll bet that any stove on the planet will produce a range of particulate emissions depending on wood type and a zillion other variables. I'll bet it even changes during the course of a burn cycle. So stove A might be the cleanest burning stove at 9:00 AM, and stove B the cleanest burning stove at 10:00 AM. This ain't a precision business.
 
True indeed. For example, cat stoves only meet their spec when the cat is new. The emissions increase as the cat ages. The Klamath OR tests also showed a major influence of maintenance on a stove meeting it's specs.
 
Hahaha, thanks begreen! Was just checking their site to see if maybe I was mixed up. Backwoods Savage, thanks, I agree that is the right way to deal with the puffing, still I've noticed the draw is not nearly the same as say my father in laws older Vermont Defiance. That thing pulls a draft! Exiting out the back helps that alot.

Tommorow is going to be epically cold and I plan on posting my results on another post regarding my wood stoves ability to heat the entire house without the furnace fan running. Maybe we're lucky but I've just been amazed at it's heating ability albeit, not exactly a big house.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Backwoods Savage
Nice review thx for taking the time to write it up.
I'd like to see you throw a thermostat on the stove somewhere or shoot it with an IR temp gun. How long of a burn are you getting out of it if you fill it to the max with good solid splits ? The charts they show for the soapstone's are impressive - where the heat just radiates for a longer period of time than other stove variants.
 
fossil I've thought the same thing. Because of the dynamic nature of solid fuel there is no way to be precise and it's of little concern. I think it could be said though that stove A tested less grams/hour than stove B meaning that stove A will generally emit less grams an hour all other factors being the same.
 
jjs777, Hearthstones claim of heating your house all day on a single load may be optimistic still last night was cold here in southeast SD. I loaded it at 10 pm. The NG furnace did not run all night, I got up at 6 am, upstairs 71. Downstairs 70. Stove was too hot to touch, don't know how hot though. I loaded it again and it lit off from coals. This has pretty much been my experience with this stove. I have come to appreciate the differences in fuel however. I'll take all the Ash I can get. We have alot of Maple and Elm around here as well but to my mind nothing even comes close to the heat output and efficiency of Ash. Not to mention I have to empty my stove about half as much when I burn Ash. I know some people love Elm but I'd rather not even cut it.
 
During this cold weather it won't hurt to cycle the furnace a few times a day as insurance protection for pipes.
 
  • Like
Reactions: robbydanilow
Oh, I have no doubt whatever that the industry has achieved significant improvements in emissions...driven by EPA requirements. Some are incrementally "better" than others (at least they're advertised to be so). Of course, those advertised numbers come from some optimum and tightly controlled operating conditions. Here's the deal, though, this (below) will never, ever happen:

...all other factors being the same.

Most of the new stoves on the market today are pretty clean and pretty efficient burners...they have to be, or they wouldn't be on the market. In any case, I think you made a fine choice of appliance, and I really liked your review you posted here for us. Thanks! Rick
 
  • Like
Reactions: PapaDave
I hear ya, but no distal pipes so to speak in my home. The NG furnace is forced air and my woodstove keeps my home warmer than I would set my thermostat. I would never choose the layout of my home again...but for this it seems to be ideally suited. Depending on house layout however this is excellent advice. I sure do enjoy not running that thing though! As I told my wife yesterday no one will ever say about their NG furnace that they love it so much they want to take it with them upon the sale of their home!
 
SD, that's pretty impressive only having a 1 degree temp difference from basement to main....how are you moving the warm air from the basement to main?The reason I am asking is I have the Homesteads grandfather(H1) which is a huge beast heating from my basement and my temp difference averages 10 degrees(80 right now in basement, 72 on main).
 
Motor 7 the one degree difference is not typical just what it happened to be at 0600. When I went to bed at 10 the downstairs was 77 and up was 73 if I remember correctly. That is pretty typical for my setup. Once in awhile the downstairs will be 80 and up about 75 but that's with the fire rolling. Of course through the night it evens out and when I checked it in the morning it just happened to be close. The movement of air is largely based on the fact that I live in a split entry and the heat chimneys up the stairs. It has worked very well for me and I guess the pieces just fell together. When it is ultra cold...like right now I will turn on the furnace fan only and it really cycles air through the house nicely and evens the temp even more. I just got home from work and the furnace is running right now but there are coals in my stove. Had I been here last night I would have loaded it up earlier but my wife didn't. I do need to empty the ash anyway so I think I am going to run a test today and post my hour by hour results here and on Midwest test thread. The Weather Channel says it is now -19 and with windchill around -45...I believe it I just got done fighting fire in it! I have no doubts about this stove keeping my home toasty, even today.
 
Well I thought I'd wait until tonight to write this but it's pretty clear how this is going to go. Anyone who isn't a bit of a geek may want to just skip.

As I stated it is brutally cold here today. High was -9 with a -33 wind chill. I wanted to track my up and downstairs temperatures today while running my Hearthstone Homestead with the furnace fan only funning (not providing additional heat). Here are my results, I am pleased to say the least:

Time Outside temperature/windchill Inside temperature basement/upstairs Notes
0800 -19/-41 67/71 Coals-loaded stove at 0806. NG furnace running
0900 -17/-42 71/72 NG furnace no longer running fan on only. Stove set to low
1000 -15/-38 73/72 stove on low fan running
1100 -14/-38 72/72 stove on low fan running
1200 -12/-37 74/73 stove on low fan running
1300 -12/-37 74/74 stove on low fan running
1400 -9/-33 74/75 stove on low fan running
1500 -10/-32 73/75 loaded stove and air control wide open
1600 -10/-33 74/75 stove back on low fan on NG furnace running still not providing any heat
1700 -10/-31 74/75 stove on low fan running.

I'm sitting next to it right now and we are slow cooking a pork roast on it. I have lived with this stove 3 years but this is the first time I've been this scientific in gathering data for how it heats our home. It is more even than I expected and obviously the squirrel cage on my furnace helps move the air. This is officially the coldest conditions I've run it in and suffice it to say this stove does what I need it to and more. Had I wanted to I could have made it too hot in here today.
 
fossil I've thought the same thing. Because of the dynamic nature of solid fuel there is no way to be precise and it's of little concern. I think it could be said though that stove A tested less grams/hour than stove B meaning that stove A will generally emit less grams an hour all other factors being the same.

One good reason why we need more things like the Green Heat contest in Washington DC. I'd like to see more stoves involved and in addition to or rather than all new stoves, why not check some of the present designs that are already on the market? Methinks that could help many, or at least confuse a few. ;)
 
The point of the decathlon was to test for the leading edge, not the middle or back of the pack. It would be too big a task to test dozens of stoves in a few days. I think it's good they are testing what will be the next gen of stoves if the new regs go into effect. It was impressive to see all the clean stacks from burning stoves in the tent. I look forward to future developments here.

FYI, to my knowledge, Green Heat Alliance still hasn't released the actual data per stove. So far we just have subjective appraisals by the judges. Has anyone seen the actual results per stove?
 
Last edited:
I agree begreen. My point is that I'd like to see this expanded in the future. They do also have some numbers, otherwise all that testing that was done over many days would have been pointless. I think the Alliance for Green Heat needs some big time sponsorship but the trouble with that is it could tend to sway some folks. Money does talk.
 
I too hope and expect it will expand as more companies develop stoves to meet the new regs. Travis and Woodstock are just the first two of many companies in the stove market. I hope to see exciting cleaner stove developments from Jotul, Morso, Regency, Quadrafire, PE, etc. in the next couple years.

PS: They can post the numbers on their Facebook page at no cost I hope.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.