another wood ID
- Thread starter iron
- Start date
-
Active since 1995, Hearth.com is THE place on the internet for free information and advice about wood stoves, pellet stoves and other energy saving equipment.
We strive to provide opinions, articles, discussions and history related to Hearth Products and in a more general sense, energy issues.
We promote the EFFICIENT, RESPONSIBLE, CLEAN and SAFE use of all fuels, whether renewable or fossil.
- Status
CenterTree
Minister of Fire
Ctwoodtick
Minister of Fire
Oldman47
Minister of Fire
Which is more likely north of Seattle?Piss found near the border?
Mexico or Canada?
I think cottonwood or poplar. They're relatives that I have trouble telling apart after cut. I think poplar smells worse green, and cottonwood smells worse burning.
They're low BTU, high ash content woods, but I'm not above scrounging them. Fortunately, both are usually pretty easy to split, although I once ran into some dry cottonwood rounds with lots of small branches, the knots of which held the rounds together like nails.
They're low BTU, high ash content woods, but I'm not above scrounging them. Fortunately, both are usually pretty easy to split, although I once ran into some dry cottonwood rounds with lots of small branches, the knots of which held the rounds together like nails.
hmm. my buddy, who generally knows his trees, didn't think it was a cottonwood. i guess we'll see when it comes time to burn. yes, it's a very easy wood to split (though not as nice as the red alder he gave me!)
claydogg84
Minister of Fire
CincyBurner
Minister of Fire
How about a species of alder (Alnus). http://oregonstate.edu/trees/broadleaf_genera/species/alder_spp.html
Alder grows big out West. Don't have much in Ohio, but what little I've split had a range of color with yellow & orange.
Did you notice any alder cones ? If so, it's a tell-tale, dead give-away for alder.
* If alder set some aside for smoking fish on the grill. Nice smoke. Good for fish, not as heavy as hickory.
Alder grows big out West. Don't have much in Ohio, but what little I've split had a range of color with yellow & orange.
Did you notice any alder cones ? If so, it's a tell-tale, dead give-away for alder.
* If alder set some aside for smoking fish on the grill. Nice smoke. Good for fish, not as heavy as hickory.
The wood color fits alder, but the bark doesn't look right, and I wouldn't compare the smell of alder to piss.
mark cline
Minister of Fire
planner steve
Burning Hunk
My guess is white alder. I cut one down last year, bark looks the same and it had that orange coloration also. Do smaller branches have smoother bark with a mottled appearance? I'm not sure I would describe the odor that way. But I do remember thinking it didn't smell as good as red alder.
lost in the woods
Burning Hunk
yeah my 1st guess was hard maple aka sugar maple aka acer saccherum? then I realized not everyone on this msg board is in PA hahahah
I would def. guess some sort of maple species
I would def. guess some sort of maple species
my buddy took a picture of the new growth coming out of the stump of this tree. any thoughts with the additional leaves to ID?
Last edited by a moderator:
Lake Girl
Moderator
Definitely not a maple from those leaves - black cottonwood? http://forestry.about.com/od/hardwoods/tp/Populus_balsamifera.htm
The secondary leaf-like bits at the base of the main leaf are called stipules and are common in willows, but I don't think cottonwoods have them. Also, cottonwood twigs are usually very angular.
Pacific willow is very common, sprouts aggressively from stumps, and the leaves look a bit like that, but the twigs are usually yellow, so I'm thinking some other willow. There's numerous species native to the Pacific NW.
Pacific willow is very common, sprouts aggressively from stumps, and the leaves look a bit like that, but the twigs are usually yellow, so I'm thinking some other willow. There's numerous species native to the Pacific NW.
- Status
