Stupid idea for a chimney fire extinguisher?

  • Active since 1995, Hearth.com is THE place on the internet for free information and advice about wood stoves, pellet stoves and other energy saving equipment.

    We strive to provide opinions, articles, discussions and history related to Hearth Products and in a more general sense, energy issues.

    We promote the EFFICIENT, RESPONSIBLE, CLEAN and SAFE use of all fuels, whether renewable or fossil.
Status
Not open for further replies.

FORCE FAB

New Member
Oct 30, 2008
77
SOUTH JERSEY
So i have one of those food saver vacume sealer things...what about filling one of the bags with ice,vacume seal it then leave it out so it thaws...Now u got a handy bag of sealed water to toss in the stove....Bad idea?
 
saftey is your best prevention - dry wood , clean chimney and sweep when needed and you should never need your FS bags ;) but i guess it might work
 
Stevebass4 said:
saftey is your best prevention - dry wood , clean chimney and sweep when needed and you should never need your FS bags ;) but i guess it might work
Yea i know,id like to have somthin around that the wife could toss in the stove without doin much thinkin
 
Two words for ya to ponder...



Steam Explosion.
 
FORCE FAB said:
So i have one of those food saver vacume sealer things...what about filling one of the bags with ice,vacume seal it then leave it out so it thaws...Now u got a handy bag of sealed water to toss in the stove....Bad idea?
Yes, bad idea; open the door on a heavy fired stove leaves in fresh air which could spew out sparks and flames into her face, on her clothing and/or on the floor. Now you have what we call a house fire with at least one person injured. Teach her how to safely close down all the air and call the fire dept. as a good plan "B". Evacuate the house if any doubt. With all of the petrochemicals in today's homes fires will double in size every minute which leaves only seconds to get out. Leave fire fighting to those who are trained. No house is worth a life. Be safe.
Ed
 
If you want to throw something into your stove, go to your fire department and fill a baggie with dry chemical fire extinguisher. If you think it is running away, open the door and toss the bag in.

After you get your family out of the house and call the fire department.
 
I'd be afraid of the stove cracking or splitting a seam as soon as the water hits hot metal. Rapid, uneven metal contraction could me more dangerous.

Matt
 
Ever out out a campfire with a garden hose? It takes a suprising amount of water to extinguish a fire. A few bags of ice would be ineffective at best. I think the best thing to do is fill your bags with dry chemical extinguisher or baking powder...smother the fire with an inert powder that displaces the oxygen in there and kills the fire with minimal risk of exposure to you and minimal risk of explosion that might hurt your stove or injure someone.
 
Ace hardware sells a product about the size of a road flare you can toss in if you have a problem and it smoothers the fire
 
Bad Idea. Just shut the stove down as tight as possible. If anything starts going bad, GET OUT. Opening the door on an out of control stove is very dangerous to begin with.

9999 times out of 10000 the stove and pipe will withstand the fire. It may need to be replaced, but it will take it. All I can tell you on this is "trust me" when I say--humans do not take to being on fire very well.

Burns suck.
 
Jags said:
Bad Idea. Just shut the stove down as tight as possible. If anything starts going bad, GET OUT. Opening the door on an out of control stove is very dangerous to begin with.

9999 times out of 10000 the stove and pipe will withstand the fire. It may need to be replaced, but it will take it. All I can tell you on this is "trust me" when I say--humans do not take to being on fire very well.

Burns suck.

+1

If you're looking for simple . . . learning how to shut things down as much as possible is the simplest and safest way.

Water/ice in a bag . . . bad idea . . . very bad idea.
 
And should only be done after uttering the following..."here, hold my beer, watch this..." :lol:
 
burntime said:
And should only be done after uttering the following..."here, hold my beer, watch this..." :lol:

LOL...and only performed in Ala-bamer.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.