Adding a Cat

Methinks it would be a lot of redesigning the stove. You need a bypass with a cat stove. The reason is when you first start wood to burning you get the moisture evaporated. Moisture is the cat's enemy. That is why we bypass the cat for 10-15 minutes on every reload.

Backwoods Savage said:

Methinks it would be a lot of redesigning the stove. You need a bypass with a cat stove. The reason is when you first start wood to burning you get the moisture evaporated. Moisture is the cat's enemy. That is why we bypass the cat for 10-15 minutes on every reload.

Click to expand...

Wonder how that would work out in a Lopi? Some of their models have a bypass damper which bypasses the baffle for starts and reloads. Again, I'm sure it would involve much redesigning.

Why add a CAT to an EPA NON-CAT? The cat would need smoke to function properly and so would the burn tubes. There would be no benefit unless you do away with the tubes and baffle of the non-cat and like Backwoods said you would need to add some type of bypass for the cat.

WidowMaker said:

Had anybody tried adding a Cat to an EPA non cat stove. Would there be any advantage to it???

Click to expand...

Quite honestly, you're asking for trouble. You're making a seriously simple device greatly complicated, more expensive to operate, and even possibly operate outside of it's designed limits. A CAT can light off quite a bit hotter than you think. It's no wonder that the most reputable manufacturers are using burn tubes for secondary rather than CATs these days.

My 2 cents for what it's worth (My Encore CAT is currently sitting around 595 on this chilly day)....
AGE

You guys have got to look at the add -on cats. It just sits up in the flue above the stove and has it's own"bypass" which is roatating the cat element sideways like a key damper in teh stove pipe. No reengineering, no adding a bypass, no risk of too much heat since the cat is designed to burn in the pipe. We would all like to thnk that our non-cat stoves burn cleanly but there is some smoke. The cat could be used to clean up the smoke. I don't know if there would be enough smoke to keep the cat active but this would be an experiment.

I don't see how those stove pipe cat add ons can work without some kind of secondary air supply to help ignite the smoke?

Backwoods Savage said:

Moisture is the cat's enemy. That is why we bypass the cat for 10-15 minutes on every reload.

Click to expand...

BackWoods Savage, you bypass the Cat on every reload? So if you have a established fire and the Cat is engaged, litoff, and you need to add a few extra logs, do you bypas the Cat for 10 to 15 minutes then too?

Todd said:

I don't see how those stove pipe cat add ons can work without some kind of secondary air supply to help ignite the smoke?

Click to expand...

Do you think they need an air supply? Why? Your car's catalyst doesn't have an air supply, at least not the modern ones. These flue cats never took off but they haven't died either so they, not unlike the magic heat, must do something other than just look pretty.

Highbeam said:

Todd said:

I don't see how those stove pipe cat add ons can work without some kind of secondary air supply to help ignite the smoke?

Click to expand...

Do you think they need an air supply? Why? Your car's catalyst doesn't have an air supply, at least not the modern ones. These flue cats never took off but they haven't died either so they, not unlike the magic heat, must do something other than just look pretty.

Click to expand...

I don't know for sure but most everything I've read about cat stoves say there is a secondary air supply near the cat to help ignition, mine does.

that blaze king video is so awesome!

KatWill said:

Backwoods Savage said:

Moisture is the cat's enemy. That is why we bypass the cat for 10-15 minutes on every reload.

Click to expand...

BackWoods Savage, you bypass the Cat on every reload? So if you have a established fire and the Cat is engaged, litoff, and you need to add a few extra logs, do you bypas the Cat for 10 to 15 minutes then too?

Click to expand...

You didn't address me but on my CAT, you have to. If you don't, the path of least resistance is for all heat and flue gas is in your face either via the top loading door or the double front doors. You have to bypass the CAT every time you open your stove. If it's just reloading, I bypass, reload, and re-engage. If your temps are too low, you have to let it get back to operating temps again.

AGE

bluefrier said:

Why add a CAT to an EPA NON-CAT? The cat would need smoke to function properly and so would the burn tubes. There would be no benefit unless you do away with the tubes and baffle of the non-cat and like Backwoods said you would need to add some type of bypass for the cat.

Click to expand...

I know in my non-Epa stove,,,there is no baffle,,,the top plate serves as a top plate , and i guess you could say the baffle also,,,the exhaust comes directly off it in the back,,,there are no tubes,,or firebrick for that matter,,,i guess im lucky it has c-channel serving as ducting for the hot air and blower :roll:

just a steel box you could get heat with a bic lighter from,,,gonna be an adjustment when i replace it next year

I think that pipe cat would be more effective if you took it out of the pipe and rigged it into the stove exhaust collar somehow, then it would keep more of the heat in the stove and not just heat up the pipe cherry red?