UPDATE: Lopi Freedom Bay has a "Whoomp" sound and then a "Whistling" Sound

  • Active since 1995, Hearth.com is THE place on the internet for free information and advice about wood stoves, pellet stoves and other energy saving equipment.

    We strive to provide opinions, articles, discussions and history related to Hearth Products and in a more general sense, energy issues.

    We promote the EFFICIENT, RESPONSIBLE, CLEAN and SAFE use of all fuels, whether renewable or fossil.
Status
Not open for further replies.

billjustbill

Member
Dec 26, 2008
131
Texas
Eleven months ago, I had a Lopi Freedom Bay installed. It has sounds...

Before firing up this late start due to a late November first freeze, I brushed and cleaned the flue. The Whistling sound happened all year long. When the wind is at least 15mph or higher, it sounds like air is being drawn out of the house. In the cold, but no wind, it sounds exactly the same when it has a good and rolling fire going. When Lopi's top damper is closed the whistle is the loudest as the fire burns. It stops if the damper is pulled open. The sliding damper has NO affect on stopping the whistling sound anytime when the Wind is blowing.

Background:

The fireplace was built with the house in 1958. The chimney has brick and mortar inside, not smooth flue sections, and flat stone matching the house on the outside of it. It extends about 4ft higher than the top ridge of the roof. When the installer tried to get the 6" elbows and 3 to 4 ft of flex pipe attached to single wall solid pipe, he couldn't get ti through the old damper opening. When he couldn't, he hammered out 4 or 5 bricks in front of the old damper shelf to make room. All the flue pipe is Stainless and the flex section lays somewhat sidewise then curves up and attaches to the solid pipe as if it was pushed down because it was too long. The stove department manager said single wall pipe was fine as it heats up the dead air in the chimney to keep the flue hot enough from building up creosote. When I brushed the flue before this year's first burn, I got out enough coarse creosote flakes that would 3/4 fill a one pound coffee can.

The chimney opening has a 1/4" thick rectangular piece of flat steel with a 6" hole cut into it for the pipe. The plate and the pipe are sealed and waterproof so far. A stainless steel diamond-wire chimney cap has four nuts that allows removal of the top for brushing and cleaning. It is held on with TapCon screws into the domed cement of the chimney as the flue pipe extends into it about 3" with a clamping collar. The firebox and the whole chimney is open all the way up to the top sealer plate. There is no sealer plate at the bottom, nor is there any insulation around the flue or behind the wide metal trim around the insert.

The "Whoomp" sound happens when the insert is fired from a cold start and when fired from a bed of red embers. After a good rolling fire has started about 20 minutes, a deep "Whoomp" sound lasts about a second or two. The somewhat loud, deep "Whoomp" sound occurs again as the insert settles into a bed of red coals. It sounds like the flue is expanding, and then later contracts.

Should there be a sideways laying of the flex flue or should it run as straight as possible out the chimney top? The wood stove department's manager is coming back to hear and try to fix these sounds. What should I know and point out to him?

Your input and experience is appreciated.

Bill
 

Attachments

  • Copy of P1000317.jpg
    Copy of P1000317.jpg
    55.5 KB · Views: 784
By chance is the "whoomp" and then the "whistle" followed by a chitty chitty bang bang? Sorry, I couldn't resist. :)

Can't help with your question but I'm sure you'll solve the noises.
 
Almost sounds like a build up of wood gas or creosote lighting off - the whoompf sound. Whistling - from your description not a clue. I know that if I shut my stove down to low before the secondaries are rolling, I will get a mini explosion when they light off and ignite the build up of wood gases ( like a giant back puff). It can scare the ............ out of you if you aren't careful, also not good for your equipment.
 
Yup. It's a backpuff caused by lack of air for what's burning at the time. (search "backpuff")
It usually happens when lots of air gets a lot of the wood going and then you reduce the air supply too quickly
and the burn is sucking for air that it needs to keep going at that level. This sucking is probably what's causing the whistle.
Try to reduce the air sooner or more gradually.
There's also a chance that your house may be too tight and the air drawn through the stove isn't being replaced quickly enough.
Some try to solve this by installing an outdoor air kit. Cracking open a nearby window will give the same effect, if you want to experiment with that.
 
I wanted to bump this again to see if there could be more response to the installation quality and sounds it's making.

I have a ceiling mounted combo fire/CO detector within 15' of the insert and it hasn't sounded at all. I'd just like input on all or any one of the points I've tried to describe.

Got a call from the company/store that I bought from. and also did the installation. The phone rang about 3:00pm on New Year's Eve, after leaving a followup message three days before. He promised to get back with me that day either way if he did/didn't contact the Lopi rep. No call came. So, with New Year's a holiday, Saturday??, and normally closed on Monday's, I hope to talk with them in the coming week.

Observations or experience to share?

Thanks,
Bill
 
I doubt the installation or the appliance is at fault, but certainly have them check it out.
Dry wood, a decent draft, and having a feel for your wood supply (split size/species) and your stove's "personality" should alleviate the back puffs.
I had them quite often during my 1st few months of operation last year. (I bought that wood and I don't think it was quite dry.)
Burning wood takes some learning and some baby-sitting. That's why they invented gas/oil burners.
 
UPDATE: While doing the weekly checks on the smoke and Carbon Monoxide detectors, I found that the CO detector listed it as 172 ppm.... I called the store that I purchased the Lopi from and that did the install last January as the air whistle increased when the North winds hit and after hearing the detector reading....

The air whistle is on the right side behind the metal surround as if there is a cracked weld or worse. The Lopi rep. was contacted with the symptoms and the possible CO problem.

They are coming next week to replace the unit with a new one and pulling the twelve foot length of 6" liner to inspect the flex and solid SS material...

Any pointer I should look for during the new install?

Thanks for the help,
Bill

billjustbill said:
Eleven months ago, I had a Lopi Freedom Bay installed. It has sounds...

Before firing up this late start due to a late November first freeze, I brushed and cleaned the flue. The Whistling sound happened all year long. When the wind is at least 15mph or higher, it sounds like air is being drawn out of the house. In the cold, but no wind, it sounds exactly the same when it has a good and rolling fire going. When Lopi's top damper is closed the whistle is the loudest as the fire burns. It stops if the damper is pulled open. The sliding damper has NO affect on stopping the whistling sound anytime when the Wind is blowing.

Background:

The fireplace was built with the house in 1958. The chimney has brick and mortar inside, not smooth flue sections, and flat stone matching the house on the outside of it. It extends about 4ft higher than the top ridge of the roof. When the installer tried to get the 6" elbows and 3 to 4 ft of flex pipe attached to single wall solid pipe, he couldn't get ti through the old damper opening. When he couldn't, he hammered out 4 or 5 bricks in front of the old damper shelf to make room. All the flue pipe is Stainless and the flex section lays somewhat sidewise then curves up and attaches to the solid pipe as if it was pushed down because it was too long. The stove department manager said single wall pipe was fine as it heats up the dead air in the chimney to keep the flue hot enough from building up creosote. When I brushed the flue before this year's first burn, I got out enough coarse creosote flakes that would 3/4 fill a one pound coffee can.

The chimney opening has a 1/4" thick rectangular piece of flat steel with a 6" hole cut into it for the pipe. The plate and the pipe are sealed and waterproof so far. A stainless steel diamond-wire chimney cap has four nuts that allows removal of the top for brushing and cleaning. It is held on with TapCon screws into the domed cement of the chimney as the flue pipe extends into it about 3" with a clamping collar. The firebox and the whole chimney is open all the way up to the top sealer plate. There is no sealer plate at the bottom, nor is there any insulation around the flue or behind the wide metal trim around the insert.

The "Whoomp" sound happens when the insert is fired from a cold start and when fired from a bed of red embers. After a good rolling fire has started about 20 minutes, a deep "Whoomp" sound lasts about a second or two. The somewhat loud, deep "Whoomp" sound occurs again as the insert settles into a bed of red coals. It sounds like the flue is expanding, and then later contracts.

Should there be a sideways laying of the flex flue or should it run as straight as possible out the chimney top? The wood stove department's manager is coming back to hear and try to fix these sounds. What should I know and point out to him?

Your input and experience is appreciated.

Bill
 
Bump to get your input before 1 year old Lopi is replaced.

Thanks,
Bill
 
Status
Not open for further replies.