wood id please

  • Active since 1995, Hearth.com is THE place on the internet for free information and advice about wood stoves, pellet stoves and other energy saving equipment.

    We strive to provide opinions, articles, discussions and history related to Hearth Products and in a more general sense, energy issues.

    We promote the EFFICIENT, RESPONSIBLE, CLEAN and SAFE use of all fuels, whether renewable or fossil.
Status
Not open for further replies.

zanp

New Member
Dec 4, 2007
88
Asheville NC
Just took down this tree. anyone know what it is based on the bark and wood color?
 

Attachments

  • DSC_0930.jpg
    DSC_0930.jpg
    82.9 KB · Views: 574
  • DSC_0931.jpg
    DSC_0931.jpg
    98.3 KB · Views: 586
  • DSC_0934.jpg
    DSC_0934.jpg
    101.6 KB · Views: 546
I think that is Chestnut Oak. Thick, furrowed bark, heartwood looks like Whtie oak, thick white sapwood.
 
Very nice, Zap!

The problem with bark IDs is that bark can vary considerably among trees, and along a particular tree itself. If you are looking at the whole tree, it may not be that hard, but when someone shows you a split or two, you don't even know from where in the tree it came from. Many of these photo IDs are pretty tough. If I know the wood, I am always sure once it is in my hands, usually just by looking at the wood grain. Weight and smell enter in as well... kinda hard to get those qualities across in a photo.
 
Battenkiller said:
Very nice, Zap!

The problem with bark IDs is that bark can vary considerably among trees, and along a particular tree itself. If you are looking at the whole tree, it may not be that hard, but when someone shows you a split or two, you don't even know from where in the tree it came from. Many of these photo IDs are pretty tough. If I know the wood, I am always sure once it is in my hands, usually just by looking at the wood grain. Weight and smell enter in as well... kinda hard to get those qualities across in a photo.

This site is much better.

http://www.duke.edu/~cwcook/trees/#trees

Zap
 
When I looked at the bark, reminded me of a big sassafrass, but I've no idea what interior wood on sassafrass looks like!
 
NH_Wood said:
When I looked at the bark, reminded me of a big sassafrass, but I've no idea what interior wood on sassafrass looks like!
I thought Sassafras at first, but I think the bark is too furrowed to be Sassafras, I will go with Chestnut Oak. By the way that would be a small Sassafras tree in this part of the woods, 18"-24" dbh is very common around here, hollow and twisted, but common.
 
webby3650 said:
NH_Wood said:
When I looked at the bark, reminded me of a big sassafrass, but I've no idea what interior wood on sassafrass looks like!
I thought Sassafras at first, but I think the bark is too furrowed to be Sassafras, I will go with Chestnut Oak. By the way that would be a small Sassafras tree in this part of the woods, 18"-24" dbh is very common around here, hollow and twisted, but common.

Neat - most of the sassafras I've seen are smaller, but pretty rare here!
 
It certainly is hard to be certain with the photo only, but even though it looks like chestnut oak, and it might be, I think is is sourwood. Resembles both sassafras and chestnut oak. The wood of sourwood is much lighter than the oak and the grain is far different. If the grain of that wood looks like oak then it probably is chestnut oak. However if the grain is more white with the dark center and the grain is less pronounced, or smoother, the it is likely sourwood. Is that vague enough?
 
I thought sourwood also when I looked at those logs

he's down in NC, and I know they have sourwood down there, although they would also have chestnut oak.

I'm not sure that a chestnut oak that small in DBH would have bark that furrowed yet, but maybe.
 
Looks like a persimmon. Make some golf clubs.
 
cuznguido said:
It certainly is hard to be certain with the photo only, but even though it looks like chestnut oak, and it might be, I think is is sourwood. Resembles both sassafras and chestnut oak. The wood of sourwood is much lighter than the oak and the grain is far different. If the grain of that wood looks like oak then it probably is chestnut oak. However if the grain is more white with the dark center and the grain is less pronounced, or smoother, the it is likely sourwood. Is that vague enough?


I think it is sourwood based on what you said and the fact that sourwood is common in my area. The grain is not like Oak. It is smoother and it is white with a dark center. I guess I will know for sure when the leaves come out this spring on similar neighboring trees.

Does sourwood season in one year given the right conditions?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.