Clydesdale or Morgan in our old "homestead house"

  • Active since 1995, Hearth.com is THE place on the internet for free information and advice about wood stoves, pellet stoves and other energy saving equipment.

    We strive to provide opinions, articles, discussions and history related to Hearth Products and in a more general sense, energy issues.

    We promote the EFFICIENT, RESPONSIBLE, CLEAN and SAFE use of all fuels, whether renewable or fossil.
Status
Not open for further replies.

kksalm

Member
Dec 21, 2007
83
Kenai Alaska
Our house has been added onto throughout the years and is far from an open floor plan. Most rooms I would say are isolated from one another. Counting the basement we've got about 3,000 square feet. We have a natural gas boiler and recently installed zone valves one for each floor. We don't heat the basement unless it drops below zero, we only heat the top floor when one of our kids happens to be home. Our fireplace is fortunately located in the middle of our living room and is big enough to accomadate the Heathstone Clydesdale. The kitchen adjoins the living room via a 28" door opening. The bathroom and our bedroom is around a corner with small door openings, there's a music room behind the wall that contains the fireplace. I want the Clydesdale for the bigger fire viewing area and the additional 200 pounds of thermal mass. My wife is worried about being forced out of the living room by the excessive heat of the bigger (than the Morgan) wood stove and has asked if we'd be able to build "little fires" in the Clydesdale to avoid overheating the living room. We prefer the radiant heat from a wood stove but neither of us likes to be too hot. Any suggestions, comments or advice will be much appreciated.
Best regards from Kenai, Alaska.
 
Go bigger is pretty much the norm around here. Yes, you can build smaller fires with 1/2 or 3/4 loads and you will appreciate the extra capacity when it gets colder. Fireplace in a central location will help as well.
 
It sounds like the livingroom is somewhat isolated with a small opening to the kitchen and hallway. Is that correct? If it is, how large is the living room?

The reason for the questions is a stove is an area heater, so it is best to consider the actual area being heated first. It can be a bit oversized, but not exceptionally so. For example, if this is a <700 sq ft area, with 8 ft ceilings and the house is well insulated, I would opt for the Morgan or something in the 2 cu ft range. If you want larger, maybe check out a Blaze King Princess which should burn better with half loads at a low burn rate.

Would you be opposed to assisting the heat get to other areas in the house with a strategically placed fan or two? If not, then include those spaces in the overall area. They may not get as warm, but will benefit from the wood heat.
 
The Clydesdale would be your best bet. If you really had the stove cranking you could just keep the blower on low or even turn it off and the heat output from an insert is reduced drastically, but not completely. A stove you can't turn it down when its cranking. A stove will really heat a room, but an insert with a blower moves the heat around the room. Our Clydesdale is in our living room and with the blower on medium-high you can feel the cold air moving across the floor towards the insert. The insert sucks in the cold air at in the bottom of the stove and blows it out the top very hot. I can heat my whole first floor (apprx 1000 sqft) with the Clydesdale because of the this movement of air. However with a stove you'll find the room with the stove can be down right hot, but the kitchen or the next room over can be 20 degrees colder due to the radiant heating of a stove.

With the layout of your house it sounds like you'll still need a fan here or there to help facilitate moving the hot air around, but the last thing you want is to get the Morgan and find that its too small for the job at hand. Better to go big and worse case keep the blower on low or make small hot fires. Also with the blower on low the noise is nearly noticeable.

Just my opinion, but I'd opt for the Clydesdale and you'll be fine.
 
i would go with the Clyde. you can certainly control the fire to keep from being forced out of the room. the other thing (very important) is you should install transfer fans!!!! they make a HUGE difference in heating larger spaces. i installed a couple and have ceiling fans. couple that with open layout and central location of the stove and i can heat over 4000 sqft. good luck, both are grat stoves.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.