A Survey, feedback please.

Then buy it. Mendota would by in my top 5 along with Regency, HNG and a few others.
If you like that model, just buy it and dont come back here until you have pics to prove you did so.

Time for both to cool it. Mikey, at 5 posts, your inexperience is evident and probably excusable, but you asked a question impossible to answer. Franks, at 3180 posts, a little more patience might be better, but maybe your day was less than you hoped for. Pax vobiscum aka peace be with you.

Hey it wasnt an attitude! I just want you to go get it fast so we can see some pics. You actually picked yourself a great fireplace before posting. Tell me you still didnt buy it?

Sorry to ruffle your feathers there buddy

JE, never confuse the number of posts with the ability to use common sense and good manners.

And also to you

Sounds like an Awesome set-up...I have a cheepo home depo model....Cant wait for updated pic's!

Your pricing seems very typical to what it normally would go for. If the price is similar between the two stores, research the stores. Check with the BBB and find out if they have NFI certified installers. Also, if they plan on using coated gas pipe (CSST) make sure the tech that will be DOING the work is certified. You need to be certified to install that stuff. Some shops will get one guy certified but then send any old person out to actually do the install. Since your not in a rush, take this time to research your hearth shops. The place you buy is just as important as the unit you buy.

Whoo hoo, Bobs still here!
See how rowdy I got when I heard you wouldnt be patrolling the gas room?

Mikey said:

Sorry for posting such a dumb question.

Next time I'll run my post through the "stupid post/question" filter before posting again. Who or where is that filter?

Thanks

Click to expand...

It was a fine question and you already had picked out some good options....

Mendota is top of the line. Heat and Glo has everything, from basic units (good!) to fancier stuff.

I think it comes down to budget, size, efficiency, etc.......not everyone needs 40K BTU and the most efficient.

Also, when it comes to posts....you are not allowed to be a smart alec until about post #150...not including Ash Can. You'll still get yelled at even at 2000 posts - Franks gets a slap every once in a while himself.

In short, we try to set a tone here which is friendly - and have largely succeeded. Hopefully it will continue. Posts which do not contain any information (helpful) should be carefully thought about before you hit the submit button...that goes for ALL members.

If you don't mind me asking...

I work at a Heat & Glo dealer, and I also know the dealers up in MN are top notch. So I was wondering what made you pick the Mendota over a Heat & Glo? I do not know very much about Mendota units, so really... I have no clue.

Did you pick a slim unit for space reasons? That DVX35 is less than 16" deep.

DAKSY said:

Franks said:

Whoo hoo, Bobs still here!
See how rowdy I got when I heard you wouldnt be patrolling the gas room?

Click to expand...

OK, Franks, I may hafta do more than lurk if my inactivity makes you cranky...
I will attempt visit & post AT LEAST once a day, & try to focus on the gas forum! ;-)

Click to expand...

Thanks Bob!

(See guys, I told you it would work)

jtp10181 said:

If you don't mind me asking...

I work at a Heat & Glo dealer, and I also know the dealers up in MN are top notch. So I was wondering what made you pick the Mendota over a Heat & Glo? I do not know very much about Mendota units, so really... I have no clue.

Did you pick a slim unit for space reasons? That DVX35 is less than 16" deep.

Click to expand...

I sold Heat N Glo on Long Island during the good ole 90s. Never had trouble with competition. Then one day we are at the HPBA Show and saw a comotion near the Mendota booth. When we went inside at saw their flame patterns, our stomachs sank. In fact, we made an immediate bid on a Mendota dealership, but the territory was taken. I sell neither brands right now (we sell Regency) but I still hear from customers that the Mendota has one of the best flame patterns they see during their shopping.

jtp10181 said:

If you don't mind me asking...

I work at a Heat & Glo dealer, and I also know the dealers up in MN are top notch. So I was wondering what made you pick the Mendota over a Heat & Glo? I do not know very much about Mendota units, so really... I have no clue.

Did you pick a slim unit for space reasons? That DVX35 is less than 16" deep.

Click to expand...

You are really comparing apples and oranges. HHT makes a decent gas fireplace at a decent price. Mendota makes a great gas fireplace however it is more expensive. Huge difference in construction. Mendota is all standing seem welded versus spot welded and snap locked. Thickness of material, just compare shipping weights. Mendota is extremely efficient. Take a look at P4 ratings. Best flame in the industry.

I really wouldn't consider the DXV-35 to be a slim unit. It is right in there with most other 36" gas direct vents.

I might be a little prejudiced

Brad