1. Welcome Hearth.com Guests and Visitors - Please enjoy our forums!
    Hearth.com GOLD Sponsors who help bring the site content to you:
    Jotul Cast Iron Stoves
    Woodstock Soapstone Stoves
    Hearth and Home (QuadraFire and Harman Stoves)
  1. Scotty Overkill firewood hoarder

    joined: Sep 24, 2011
    6,823 posts
    central PA
    Just imagine, BBar, how many thousands of hours over the past several centuries have gone into maintenance and upkeep of that beautiful colonial home of yours.....boggles the mind when you think of it!

    Helpful Sponsor Ads!



  2. Berner New Member

    joined: Feb 1, 2012
    57 posts
    Eastern, MA

    Wow that's going to be one awesome looking room! Did you put anything between the metal lathe and durock? I've heard of people using black felt under the lathe. Keep the pictures coming they are inspiring me on all levels to rip up my fireplace.
  3. Scotty Overkill firewood hoarder

    joined: Sep 24, 2011
    6,823 posts
    central PA
    No, that wall has to be kept non-combustible per code up to 84" above the base of the unit. Felt paper would make it an illegal install. The key to keeping the mortar tight to the DUROCK is to dampen the cement board with a sprayer and water. Enter make it soaking wet, just moist. That allows the mortar to cure slowly.
  4. Gasifier Minister of Fire

    I have owned my home for 18 years now and am still not done with renovations. A lot has been accomplished. We just keep coming up with new ideas for projects. It is mostly done. But the basement remodel is going to be major. And won't be for a while, thankfully. We have some saving to do for that one. ;) Nice work Scotty.
    Scotty Overkill likes this.
  5. corey21 Minister of Fire

    joined: Oct 28, 2010
    2,208 posts
    Soutwest VA
    Very nice stone work.
    Scotty Overkill likes this.
  6. topknot New Member

    joined: Jul 9, 2012
    17 posts
    North Central Missouri
    Love that stone on your chase. Absolutely beautiful. I also admire your ingenuity on your hearth work.
    Scotty Overkill likes this.
  7. Blue2ndaries Minister of Fire

    joined: Oct 17, 2011
    605 posts
    Oregon
    Looking great Scotty! Curious if you are going to tight stack the stone or put in grout/joints?
  8. Scotty Overkill firewood hoarder

    joined: Sep 24, 2011
    6,823 posts
    central PA
    Blue, I'll be grouting the joints with a graphite tinted mortar. I'll use a thumb press method of smoothing the joints to give it the old world look.......no tools used for smoothing. I will probably wear out the thumbs and fingers on my glove but I really like that look so its worth it.

    Thanks for the compliments fellas!
    Blue2ndaries likes this.
  9. Berner New Member

    joined: Feb 1, 2012
    57 posts
    Eastern, MA

    That's what I figured. I usually like TOH but here they just seem dead wrong. http://www.thisoldhouse.com/toh/m/video/0,,20319431,00.html

    Also could one run the metal lathe up an existing brick fireplace or would you recommend putting durock up first?
  10. Scotty Overkill firewood hoarder

    joined: Sep 24, 2011
    6,823 posts
    central PA
    If the brick is tight and sound, you'd be fine with just the lath. I've used lath over OSB and plywood (with a barrier of tyvek or felt paper in those applications), and that works fine too. No need for Durock on top of that brick. You MUST put a scratchcoat of mortar on the lath. I ALWAYS put a scratchcoat on when I use lath.
  11. BrowningBAR Minister of Fire

    joined: Jul 22, 2008
    7,103 posts
    Doylestown, PA
    It already feels like I have put in several centuries of maintenance and upkeep on this house just from myself.
    Scotty Overkill likes this.
  12. Scotty Overkill firewood hoarder

    joined: Sep 24, 2011
    6,823 posts
    central PA
    Yes, but you've also added to the legacy of that home forever.....
  13. infinitymike Minister of Fire

    joined: Aug 23, 2011
    1,263 posts
    Long Island, NY
    Hey now. Save that for the other forum. ;)
    Scotty Overkill likes this.
  14. Tramontana Member

    joined: Oct 23, 2012
    196 posts
    Wheat Ridge, Colorado
    Okay, I am ignorant and have to ask...

    ...why set the stone from top down? Is it to keep mortar off of finished work (below) or some other reason?

    Looking GREAT to me!

    Cheers!
    Scotty Overkill likes this.
  15. Scotty Overkill firewood hoarder

    joined: Sep 24, 2011
    6,823 posts
    central PA
    ;)
    BINGO! That's the best way to do the stone, IMO. Some guys like to go from the bottom to the top, but some guys are not as sloppy with their mortar as I am either! ;) Actually, I'm pretty good with keeping the mortar off the stones, but from time to time you have a mishap. Also, doing it from the top down, if you have a stone slip, it doesn't take out five other ones below it.....
  16. Realstone Lord of Fire

    joined: Jan 20, 2012
    802 posts
    Southern ON
    Tramontana beat me to the question. I've never heard of a top down install, my curiosity is piqued. I have so many questions!
    Because you are going to code for a stove, you must be using only some sort of a portland mix instead of adhesive like PL. How do you get it to stick without dropping? I can see the advantage to that method though, making cuts and finishing off would be easier on the bottom than top. Are you using a plastisizer in your mix for workability and vertical hold? Never heard of the 'thumb press' tooling method. Can I coax you to get the missus to take a shot while you are thumbing? Are you using a tuckpointing bag to pipe in the mortar for the joints?
    I'll hold off on the rest of my Q's til later. And I can't forget to mention Scotty, it look fab! Very clean, nice spacing. The rule of thumb with random stone is balance (regarding stone size, colour and texture) without uniformity. You have achieved both, keep up the great work.
  17. Scotty Overkill firewood hoarder

    joined: Sep 24, 2011
    6,823 posts
    central PA
    thank you, sir! I love the top-down method. As for the mix, I use type "S" mixed with masonry sand, in a 3 to 1 mix. You can add lime to that mix if it isn't sticky enough but I don't have a problem with it sticking. One thing I noticed with hanging stone is that the fake stone, while lighter and much more porous, likes a wetter mix. Real stone likes a dryer mix, the natural stone is much denser than the man-made stuff. Cement isn't really what keeps the stone up, its vacuum. As the cement sets up, that's when the actual bonding takes place. I also have several spray bottles with water to use as I'm hanging the stone, I spritz water onto the substrate AND the stone to keep either from sucking the moisture out of the mortar too quickly. The thumb press works well for an old world look. Makes the mortar flow a little better throughout the work. That's how I did the rest of the stonework on my house (and there's a LOT of it). I use a grouting bag (or tuckpointing bag) to put the mortar in the joints. I'll see if Da Boss will take some pics of me grouting it tonight or tomorrow. I may grout the top half this evening if not tomorrow morning.....
    Realstone likes this.
  18. Scotty Overkill firewood hoarder

    joined: Sep 24, 2011
    6,823 posts
    central PA
    Got the stone installed down to the mantel standoffs, tomorrow I'll cut and install the keystone and ledger stones across the top of the fireplace, along with the stone registers........starting to look like a fireplace!!

    I love installing the stone....

    2012-12-04_23-50-15_876.jpg 2012-12-04_23-50-25_829.jpg
    milleo, zap, Billybonfire and 4 others like this.
  19. Realstone Lord of Fire

    joined: Jan 20, 2012
    802 posts
    Southern ON
    He sure does :)
    You're right, I find that after buttering the stone with mud, a small divot removed from the middle will create a vacuum 'pocket' if you will. It helps a bit. I also find using the fly-ash plastisizer helps with keeping it hung and it also helps to keep the mess down as it sticks to itself better.
    Scotty Overkill likes this.
  20. PapaDave Minister of Fire

    Re: latest pics.
    Wow.
    DexterDay and Scotty Overkill like this.
  21. Blue2ndaries Minister of Fire

    joined: Oct 17, 2011
    605 posts
    Oregon
    With the accent lighting, that hearth is looking downright KILLER! Another question. Is your floor slab on grade or post/beam/joist? If the latter, did you have to beef things up underneath to bear the load?
    Scotty Overkill likes this.
  22. Scotty Overkill firewood hoarder

    joined: Sep 24, 2011
    6,823 posts
    central PA
    Thanks Dave. I'm almost there, bud!!
  23. Scotty Overkill firewood hoarder

    joined: Sep 24, 2011
    6,823 posts
    central PA
    Its on the foundation, Blue. The whole chase has a new footer/foundation, and the facing wall that I'm stoning now is on the original foundation. There is a LOT of weight on that wall......
  24. Scotty Overkill firewood hoarder

    joined: Sep 24, 2011
    6,823 posts
    central PA
    made more progress this week, albeit slow (lots of stuff going on, busy busy BUSY!!) Anway some pics.....

    got a small fire going to help keep the room warm....

    2012-12-06_08-19-40_954.jpg

    Cut my keystone and ledger stones, and faced all of them. Yeah, it's work, but worth it in the end of the project. They really set the fireplace off!

    2012-12-06_10-45-17_412.jpg 2012-12-06_14-58-15_41.jpg

    Filling in around the top and sides of the fireplace...

    2012-12-06_16-39-11_123.jpg 2012-12-08_09-11-56_458.jpg

    Hoping to have all the stone (including the hearthstones which are all around 100 - 130 lbs each), grouting to come Monday evening.....
    milleo, Elusive, zap and 6 others like this.
  25. Cross Cut Saw Feeling the Heat

    :eek:
    Awesome, reminds me of some of the ski lodges tucked into the mountains at Vail, Colorado.
    In 80 years Great Grandson Overkill will be boasting about his sweet fireplace...

Share This Page