I tried the dollar bill test and failed miserably and my chimney always seem to smoke a bit..Well I decided to replace the catalytic pass yesterday and it turned out to be more work than I anticipated.. To replace this gasket you must remove the bypass damper and to do this you have to remove the top of the stove.. I did find several other places smoke was bypassing the cat and also where fresh air was leaking into the cat chamber.. The whole job took about 4-5 hrs. total but the result was worth it as my chimney is now smoke free plus the cat heats up faster.. Here are the pics to illustrate what the cat bypass gasket channel looks like once cleaned out..