guidance

  • Active since 1995, Hearth.com is THE place on the internet for free information and advice about wood stoves, pellet stoves and other energy saving equipment.

    We strive to provide opinions, articles, discussions and history related to Hearth Products and in a more general sense, energy issues.

    We promote the EFFICIENT, RESPONSIBLE, CLEAN and SAFE use of all fuels, whether renewable or fossil.
Status
Not open for further replies.
Dirge

Dirge

Member
Jan 24, 2015
22
PA
I hope this question isn't overly burdensome or subject to wide ranging opinions, but I'm wondering if folks here could provide me with some guidance in choosing a stove.

My situation is this - my home is heated by electric. We've had outages. So I need a back up heat source that doesn't require electric. I have a natural gas line run to my house. I have no chimney. So I'd like to buy a gas stove that I can direct vent out the side of my house. Oh, and I don't have $3,000 to spend on a new gas stove and piping :) I'd like to keep it around $1,000 or less total. So I've been trying to find a used stove in good condition.

I need the stove to be a direct vent model, natural gas (unless I can find the kit to convert from LP for an affordable price) and 24,000 BTU or more, and it would be a bonus if the temperature is adjustable and has a non-electric ignition.

So I've mostly been keeping an eye on Craiglist in my area for used stoves. And there have been several that I've been interested in, but they just haven't quite met the above criteria.

I'm looking for guidance on which models are safe bets or ones to stay away from, along with any issues I should be aware of.

Currently there are a few models on Craiglist that I'm considering:
Napoleon GDS50
Quadrafire (bay window, not sure if it's a Hudson Bay)
Heat-N-Glo Tiara II
Hearthstone Santa Fe

Are any of these worth pursuing or to be avoided?

I've seen several Vermont Castings Radiance stoves as well. Any thoughts on this stove?

One last thing - occasionally these stoves come with the direct vent piping, which would save me some money. But if I have to purchase the piping, can anyone tell me approximately how much I should figure for a 3' to 4' vertical run through a concrete block wall with a vent cap?

I really appreciate you taking the time to help steer me in the right direction!
 
Good luck with your with your search. I don't think you are going to be anywhere NEAR your budget.
I just priced a Direct Vent system, 4 x 6-5/8 in black.
26" vertical, 90 degree elbow, 12" thru the wall with a cover plate
& horizontal cap & those components price out at about $478.
I kinda doubt that you find will a stove that is in decent shape for $500.
Keep searching & if you find one in your budget, report back.
Give us the manufacturer, model & year built.
One of us may know about that particular model &
be able to evaluate it for you.

PS. Of the ones you listed above, I am familiar with, have sold, installed
& serviced the Hearthstone Santa Fe, & I have serviced the VC Radiance.
The Hearthstone is a nice unit. There are many people in here with that
VC model, & many of them have issues.
 
You're right Daksy, no doubt about it - I'm looking for a rare deal. But I have seen a few decent stoves on Craigslist that come with the pipe, fittings and cap within my budget. But they just haven't quite fit my situation. One was b-vent, another needed a costly conversion kit for NG, and another was a VC Radiance that I felt uncertain about.

Currently, there is an Enviro Ascot with all the piping, asking $700. But it's only 17k BTU and LP.

There are a few on my radar right now. Perhaps someone can tell me if any of them are worth pursuing.

- Heat-N-Glo Tiara II with vent piping, LP, asking $1250. I'd have to buy an NG conversion kit.

- Hearthstone Champlain - description says direct vent, pictures appear like it might be vented into a fireplace flue. Asking $500. I would need to buy vent piping.

- Jotul Allagash 300 DVII with piping, 5 year old, asking $1250. Only 26k BTU.

- Napoleon GDS50 - LP, asking $1500. I would need an NG conversion kit and vent piping.

- Hearthstone Santa Fe - 3 years old, asking $900. I would need to buy vent piping.

- Morso 200 NA with vent piping, set up for LP, asking $300. I would need to buy vent piping.

- Quadrafire - 4 years old, 40k BTU, not sure of model, looks to be vented into fireplace flue, asking $1250. I would need to buy vent piping.

Several of these have been advertised for awhile, so I'm sure the sellers are willing to take a lower offer.

If any of these are worth looking into more closely, can you please tell me what I should look for or what questions I should ask?

I appreciate the help. Reading this forum has aided my education about stoves and hearth products in general.
 
Last edited:
Where did you come up with the 24K BTU figure in your original post?
Is that based on square footage & the house's insulation, or is it just a
number that someone suggested to you?
 
It is admittedly an arbitrary figure based on what I have seen listed on manufacturer's websites for sq. ft. to btu ratio. I have no experience to draw from. My basement is presently unfinished, 1,100 sq. ft., and it is a daylight basement. I would also be happy for some of the residual heat from the stove to rise to the first floor and supplement the electric heat there.
 
Dirge said:
It is admittedly an arbitrary figure based on what I have seen listed on manufacturer's websites for sq. ft. to btu ratio. I have no experience to draw from. My basement is presently unfinished, 1,100 sq. ft., and it is a daylight basement. I would also be happy for some of the residual heat from the stove to rise to the first floor and supplement the electric heat there.
Click to expand...

In the unfinished (& I assume uninsulated) condition of your basement,
you're gonna need about 40 - 50 BTU/SF to heat it.
Unfinished concrete or block will suck the heat right out of there.
You may wanna go bigger, but then again, if money is a concern...
On ce your basement is finished, the heating demand will be lower,
but I don't know if you wanna sacrifice being warm NOW vs warm THEN.
Even so, I think I'd lean towards something in the 40K range.
75% efficiency will give you an output of 30K & that would probably work
in 1100 SF that's insulated.
 
The present need is only as a back up source of heat for situations when the power goes out for only a few hours. This would provide my family with heat to sit around the stove in the basement until the power came back on. If the power was out for more than half a day, we would leave.

But I would also like this stove to serve the future need of heating the basement once it is finished.

Of the models from Craigslist that I listed above that I'm considering, this is probably the current front runner, if you are interested to check the link:
http://lancaster.craigslist.org/for/4869212287.html

I would have to talk them down on the price a couple hundred dollars though.
 
Looks like a nice deal. It's 25600 BTU Output burning NG.
That heat about 500 - 550 SF in an uninsulated area
The Skytech remote is worth a couple hundred alone.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Dirge
I need to find out if it has a blower unit in it. And I'm scratching my head to think of a reason they would be selling a nice 3 year old stove. I'm not sure how to pose that question to them without sounding suspicious.
 
I spoke with the owner of the Hearthstone Santa Fe. It does not have a blower.

Is it important to have a blower on a gas stove or can you use a fan or other alternate method to move the heat?

Yikes! $298 is the best price I can find for this blower (93-57010). I'm afraid if a blower is important, that's going to put the cost for this stove beyond me :(
 
All the blower does is push the heat out into the room a little farther before it rises.
You can probably move the heat around just as well with ceiling or box fans.
Most folks get the BEST heat movement with fans blowing cooler air INTO the room
with the appliance, which helps to move heated air out.
I use ceiling fans on updraft mode in my house & they work very well...
 
  • Like
Reactions: Dirge and Fsappo
DAKSY said:
All the blower does is push the heat out into the room a little farther before it rises.
You can probably move the heat around just as well with ceiling or box fans.
Most folks get the BEST heat movement with fans blowing cooler air INTO the room
with the appliance, which helps to move heated air out.
I use ceiling fans on updraft mode in my house & they work very well...
Click to expand...
Thanks for that input Daksy. I didn't know how valuable having a blower on the gas stove was. Is it worthwhile to use one of those wood stove fans that sit on the top of the stove?

I think I'm going to make an offer on that Hearthstone Santa Fe. If accepted, I'll be seeking some help with ordering the correct piping, installing it, and running the gas line to the meter.

Fsappo - thanks for confirming that I'm making the right choice.
 
In regards to fans on gas stoves. At my previous job my desk sat across from 4 DV gas stoves. I'd say about 20' away, facing me. Hearthstones Sterling, Champlain and Santa Fe and a Regency H25. They all had fans. My boss would walk by when I had one or two going and would turn fan on high. I never attempted to explain or prove the science (If you knew him you would understand why)

I always "knew" that a fan on high in a gas stove did not make me feel any warmer. So I ran a test for a few days. Halfway between myself and the stoves was a post with a thermometer on it. Across the board on all 4 stoves:

No fan, temp in that area went up 3 or so degrees after the stove was on for 2 hours (large area) After the 2 hours, fan on low, 2 hours more, temp went up 1-2 degrees. Same thing next day after 2 hours but fan on high, temp went up 1-2 degrees. So what I assumed, with my simple test, proved to be correct. Kinda what we all know. After that game for a couple of weeks, I tried to see if the fan upped the temp at the thermostat faster. It did not (one stove, forgot which actually was slower.

I think that was because even at 10' away, the radiant heat, especially from the Sterling, is what gave the desired result quicker.

AnyHOO. If I was going to buy a gas stove, considering the blowers are usually 300-500 options, I wouldn't spend the money. I told my customers the same thing. If a gas stove came with a blower, I would use it all the time on the lowest setting.

My 2 cents and I build wood fires from the bottom up!
 
Thanks for all the input on fans and blowers. Very useful information!

I happen to have a brand new ceiling fan stowed in the basement that I bought for a bedroom without realizing it had a 6" downrod. I could use that in my basement with a gas stove. So where do you position a ceiling fan to maximize heat distribution to a room?
 
Good news. My offer was accepted!!

Now how is the best way to load, transport and unload a gas stove? Hand truck?

Tie down on the back of a pickup truck? Are there any parts that should be disassembled like the gas logs, etc?

Any other tips or advice to avoid damage or knocking things out of place while moving a gas stove?
 
An appliance handtruck with straps is the tool you need. Remove the logset.
The logs can be pretty fragile. Also remove the granite/soapstone tiles & the top grille.
I like to wrap the stove in a furniture pad before I strap the handtruck on.
Bungee the handtruck & stove to the truck tie-downs & you should be good to go
 
DAKSY said:
An appliance handtruck with straps is the tool you need. Remove the logset.
The logs can be pretty fragile. Also remove the granite/soapstone tiles & the top grille.
I like to wrap the stove in a furniture pad before I strap the handtruck on.
Bungee the handtruck & stove to the truck tie-downs & you should be good to go
Click to expand...
Good tips Daksy, thanks for that.

My wife has some furniture pad pieces with her sewing stuff, I'll have to see if she has any pieces that are large enough.

The fellow I'm buying it from said it has some stones and embers that give it a glow look that were removed when he replaced it. Should I put these in a cardboard box to transport them or something like that?

Onto to vent piping components. I'll have to get some measurements once I have the stove to determine the size of the piping needed. I'll probably build some sort of hearth pad out of 2x4 and ceramic tile, which will deduct from the vertical pipe length. In the meantime, I received an email from Ebay about this vent cap that has a reduced price. Is this cap suitable for my set up? - http://www.ebay.com/itm/SELKIRK-MET...-HORIZONTAL-CAP-P-CODE-1605804-/261643905638?

Thanks for all of the help everyone has provide me!
 
Remove the embers & lava rocks & put em in a ziploc bag.
Find another cap. That one is for 5x8 DV pipe. You need 4x6-5/8.
 
Thanks for setting me straight Daksy. I'll wait until I have the stove at my house and figure out exactly where it's going before I start looking for pipe and gas line materials.

If you guys are willing to keep putting up with my questions, I'll be looking for some guidance on choosing the right materials and tips for proper installation when I get to that stage.

Aside from buying online and local hearth sales shops, where can you buy direct vent piping?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads

S
Vermont Castings Radiance help
Replies
6
Views
575
It's a Gas!
Jmoney
J
xanadu1797
Radiance Hampton H35
Replies
1
Views
440
It's a Gas!
Lennox65
L
H
Heat N Glo direct vent 6000TRB won't light, control module discontinued
Replies
2
Views
275
It's a Gas!
Hosenemesis
H
P
Suggestions for small space gas heat Lopi vs. Jotul
Replies
8
Views
279
It's a Gas!
Pioneer-in-the-city-girl
P
mongobutpawningameoflife
What is the maximum chimney/flue angle?
Replies
12
Views
495
It's a Gas!
Brooks89
B
Top Bottom
Back