Ready to replace Vent-Free fireplace with Vented

When my house was built 12 years ago, a builder grade fireplace was installed with a B-Vent since the fireplace is not against an outside wall. This fireplace didn't provide any heat, and actually made the whole house much colder. We use propane heat.

Upon the suggestion of a co-worker, I installed a vent-free fireplace and re-tiled the surround. We have had it for about six years now, and have had to have it serviced three times. It sure does kick out the heat, but I just can't stand the smell. When I walk past it, even when it's off, I can smell gas, yet the carbon monoxide detector has never gone off.

The vent-free box and logs were relatively inexpensive, and I completed the whole project including a wireless remote for under $1,000. We have always loved the open look, which is why we shyed away from a closed glass unit, but now I am thinking we should opt for a closed unit to improve efficiency. Our fireplace gets heavy use, as it is turned on almost every night from Nov - Feb. The fireplace is installed in the living room when is 17' x 24' with 14' ceilings, and open to the dining room, kitchen, and breakfast room.

I am ready to replace the unit with a vented fireplace. I do not see anyway to install a vented fireplace out the side, as it would have to go thru another room to get to an outside wall, so I think I would have to use the existing B-Vent, up the roof.

My current vent-free unit is 36" W x 36" H x 20" D. As I recall, there was more depth available, but I am not sure it is another foot. The most important features to me in order of importance:
- Heating capacity
- Realistic Look
- Efficiency

I have been searching the web to find the best brands, and plan on beginning my visit to fireplace shops this weekend. Can you please offer some recommendations, or what I should be looking for?

http://www.valorfireplaces.com/ Valor makes awesome gas fireplaces. They have so many features and options to choose from. The output of some of them is comparable to a mediumn sized furnace so atleast you get something more than just a flame to look at.

Valor is a great one. Regency, Heat N Glo are also good. You can still install a direct vent fireplace up thru your roof, you may just need to enlarge the hole and pay attention to any restrictor plate requirements. There are plenty of 36" fireplaces with less than 20" depth. You could always do something nutty and visit a fireplace shop that would have units on display to look at, specs, advice and perhaps bless them with your business.

:rofl:

Well, I started my fireplace replacement search today. Quite a surprise, I went to what I believe is a reputable retailer, and they recommended that I not replace my fireplace with a vented fireplace but to replace my vent-free fireplace again. This came after I said I was looking for something that would provide good heat. He said that the newer vent-free fireplaces have made great improvements and they do not smell.

So, now I don't know what to think. Any suggestions?

yet again, Bob is right on!
if you plan on using it as a real heater, vented is the way to go

vent free units are illegal in many states... if your dealer is telling you to buy the same type of unit again, I'd walk away in a hurry as he is doing you, your family, or any pets a great disservice.
vent free units are dirty and they can and do cause health problems.

but..... if endless cleaning and lung trouble are your thing, by all means stay the course.. I am glad we moved the vent free unit to the garage where it belongs !

Thanks for sharing the link!

I have had both and vent free is the way to go more efficient and more heat. IF it stinks all the time there is something wrong

more death with a vent free too.

Are you comparing a vent free log set to a vented log set?
Vented log sets mainly for looks. Cost $500-$1200
Vent Free logs give heat but you should not use if there are elderly, young ones, or people with any kind of breathing issues. The can cause sooting in a home, moisture issues, and you shouldn't run them for more than 3 hours at a time. Cost $500-$1200.
Direct Vent Fireplaces if rated as heating appliances give lots of heat, can operate on a thermostat, are completely independent from your breathing air, and you burn all day and all night if you want. cost $1200 plus.