Ok here is an update.
1. Great idea gfreek to use the vinyl glove in the gas cap. That saved me the usual annoyance of draining the tank.
2. The Aluminum drive plate was squeeky clean, but I cleaned it again anyway.
3. The Friction disc was in great shape, no gouges and lots of meet.
5. No play in the flange/bearing suggested earlier
4. The friction disc slides easy from one side of the shaft to the other, it has plenty shiny oil from my last service interval.
6. The Aluminum drive plate seems to have some wobble in it. It wiggles a good 1/16" as measured by play on outer circumference. When I wiggle it up and down from the outer diameter, the plate wiggles on the shaft side to side. Its as thought the hex shaft that the plate rides on is worn (or the Drive plate itself).
The spring that pulls the drive plate down seems strong enough but I can duplicate the problem without the machine even turned on.
I placed the speed selector on a high speed setting, engaged the traction lever, tried to rotate a tire to put force on the aluminum plate, released the lever but the drive plate did not retract. I think the drive plate is getting hung up due to the play with respect to the shaft. I lubed the shaft with some silicon spray and that seems to help but the plate still fails to retract on the highest speeds.
The friction disc places the most "wobble movement" on the drive plate when the speed selector is set to a higher setting since the rubber contacts the outer circumference of the drive plate. It retracts just fine on the lowest 2 speed settings when the rubber contacts the center of the drive plate. I think the drive plate is getting hung up on the shaft since it's "cocked" at a slight angle on the shaft.
The shaft and drive plate are a bit pricey from Jackson Parts #21 and #23 ($71 and $50) but I think one of these parts is worn. I remember that plate being quite the pain to replace.
View attachment 291367