Hand saw instead of chainsaw

  • Active since 1995, Hearth.com is THE place on the internet for free information and advice about wood stoves, pellet stoves and other energy saving equipment.

    We strive to provide opinions, articles, discussions and history related to Hearth Products and in a more general sense, energy issues.

    We promote the EFFICIENT, RESPONSIBLE, CLEAN and SAFE use of all fuels, whether renewable or fossil.
Status
Not open for further replies.
area_man

area_man

Burning Hunk
Feb 12, 2013
124
Oregon City, OR
I need to cut a bunch of limbs and a bit of trunk that I recently scrounged. Due to budgetary issues, I'm thinking about using a hand saw to do the job. The thickest pieces I have are 24" so I would probably need something fairly big to get it done.

I'm a noob, never worked with a saw other than to make a pinewood derby car (2nd place). I don't pretend to know anything. What should I look for? Is this a dumb idea? Part of the reason I got into scrounging was for the exercise, so it doesn't matter much to me if this is going to take a lot of hours to do the work. I just wonder if I'm going to dull a saw blade in a few hours and then have to sharpen for an hour before I can get back to cutting.

Thank you for any ideas.
 
Is $150 out of the question? $150 will buy a Stihl MS170 (almost) or a Poulan Wild Thing.
 
I have a bow saw that I would use on smaller stuff (3 inces).....but 24 inches ????....God Bless ya for having that kind of determination, I would't even attempt it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: raybonz and firefighterjake
Brutal for any more than a few cuts - to get enough wood to heat your home with this method would catipult you to "man of the year" on Hearth for sure.

X2 on Thistle's post - folding or scabbard style pruning saws are fast on small branches that are just too big for loppers. I use them all the time for bowhunting.
 
  • Like
Reactions: raybonz
24 inchs with a hand saw is going to cost more than a chainsaw. (If you in want to get through it)
 
To get a proper hand saw to cut 24" logs you would need another set of hands and something like:

saw1.gif

http://www.amazon.com/Putsch-Two-Man-Crosscut-Saw/dp/B0033B81TU/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1365696702&sr=8-1&keywords=log hand saw two man

At $130 it is almost as expensive as a small power saw....

KaptJaq
 
  • Like
Reactions: TreePointer, Backwoods Savage and ScotO
I have a 6' "misery whip" in the basement that I plan on cleaning up and hanging on one of the barn beams in our living room remodel. I'd like to sharpen it up and give it a go sometime (if I could sucker someone else into working the other end!)
 
  • Like
Reactions: Backwoods Savage
Thistle said:
One of my fav things is this - http://www.stihlusa.com/products/hand-tools/hand-pruning-saws/ps70/

Parents got me that w/ matching leather belt scabbard for birthday about 10yrs back.Lots of use,still quite sharp.On green stuff that's too big for my loppers its faster than firing up my wee Echo.
Click to expand...

I have one of those i carry on my snowmobile if i ever need to clear a trail or sapplings or branches, one time i got a ski stuck under a 8"ish diameter log and used it to cut the log out. worked ok, but cant imagine doing it for firewood on 24" logs!

like the other posters have said, save up and get an older saw off craigslist or something.

I justified the purchase of my brand new saw based on the amount of money i could save by scrounging firewood vs. buying cord wood. THEN factor in the savings of Burning FREE firewood vs. burning the oil furnace! saw paid for itself in NO TIME!
 
  • Like
Reactions: ScotO
I would put this in the "not very realistic" category. Sure it can be done, a hundred years ago, that is exactly how they did it. But they would dedicate weeks, often of a small crew to get the job done.

If the funds don't allow the purchase of a new saw, consider the used market. Just make sure it is a runner before you throw down the cash. My first 5 years of serious burning was from wood that was cut using a used homey240 that I bought for $20. It is a toy compared to my Stihl, but it would still outproduce a hand saw by leaps and bounds.

And there is plenty of exercise left in the wood burning cycle - even when using a chainsaw.;)
 
  • Like
Reactions: raybonz and Backwoods Savage
Growing up I cut a lot of wood with a bow saw.
You can work from both side & cut a pretty big diameter log. :)

I like the "knuckle saver" feature on this saw ;)
I didn't have this feature.

Bow-Saw.jpg
 
  • Like
Reactions: raybonz and TreePointer
area_man said:
I need to cut a bunch of limbs and a bit of trunk that I recently scrounged. Due to budgetary issues, I'm thinking about using a hand saw to do the job. The thickest pieces I have are 24" so I would probably need something fairly big to get it done.

I'm a noob, never worked with a saw other than to make a pinewood derby car (2nd place). I don't pretend to know anything. What should I look for? Is this a dumb idea? Part of the reason I got into scrounging was for the exercise, so it doesn't matter much to me if this is going to take a lot of hours to do the work. I just wonder if I'm going to dull a saw blade in a few hours and then have to sharpen for an hour before I can get back to cutting.

Thank you for any ideas.
Click to expand...

Then welcome to the world of wood cutting. Believe me, if you cut up just one cord of wood by hand, you will then know the true value of a chain saw! I used to use one like Kaptjaq pictured when cutting with a brother or father and we also had a one man saw which is just a little shorter. It took a long, long time to buck up much wood at all.

As for the cost, earlier this year I finally broke down and bought a Stihl 180. Bought it mainly for limbing but have found that I use it much more than the larger saw. It is super lightweight and has a 16" bar. There is no problem cutting a 24" diameter tree with a 16" bar and that is what is on the 180. If it is oak, then it will make the little saw work for sure but no doubt all your wood will not be that large and if you don't have several years worth of wood on hand, you should not be cutting oak anyway!

btw, I did cut some oak with the little 180 and although it was not as fast as the larger saw, it really surprised me how quickly it went through this oak. So there is no doubt about it, the little saw has now become my favorite.
 
  • Like
Reactions: raybonz
A bow saw definitely can be used on the smaller diameter wood. If your cutting is just occasional it is preferable to having some old mix sitting in a gas can or a saw with 1/2 a tank of old gas in it. As for the bigger stuff, you can get a 40" crosscut saw. I bought one a while ago. For a couple of cuts one can be fun to use. If the wood isn't petrified they cut well (no dry white oak). You get into a rhythm and they sing through a log. If all you want to do is go out and get some exercise it is viable. If you want to turn a grapple load of logs into firewood length pieces you are not going to enjoy it. As for maintenance, you'll spend time sharpening a crosscut saw, but chainsaws need maintenance too. You do need a special tool to set the kerf.
 
And just wait until that hand saw needs sharpening....
 
area_man said:
I need to cut a bunch of limbs and a bit of trunk that I recently scrounged. Due to budgetary issues, I'm thinking about using a hand saw to do the job. The thickest pieces I have are 24" so I would probably need something fairly big to get it done.

I'm a noob, never worked with a saw other than to make a pinewood derby car (2nd place). I don't pretend to know anything. What should I look for? Is this a dumb idea? Part of the reason I got into scrounging was for the exercise, so it doesn't matter much to me if this is going to take a lot of hours to do the work. I just wonder if I'm going to dull a saw blade in a few hours and then have to sharpen for an hour before I can get back to cutting.

Thank you for any ideas.
Click to expand...
http://www.vminnovations.com/search...sort=titleaz&gclid=CIzzjJuWxrYCFUWK4AodMEMAxQ
 
bogydave said:
Growing up I cut a lot of wood with a bow saw.
You can work from both side & cut a pretty big diameter log. :)

I like the "knuckle saver" feature on this saw ;)
I didn't have this feature.

View attachment 99304
Click to expand...
That explains why you have no knuckles! All this time I thought it was from dragging your knuckles on the ground lol :)

Ray
 
Maybe Arthritis too ;) I'd guess several cords cut with it. I have the saw, used for christmas trees now . Strange how Dad got a chainsaw & riding mower when I left for the military :zip:
 
  • Like
Reactions: nate379, Thistle and raybonz
bogydave said:
Maybe Arthritis too ;) I'd guess several cords cut with it. I have the saw, used for christmas trees now . Strange how Dad got a chainsaw & riding mower when I left for the military :zip:
Click to expand...
I know what you mean Dave! I left for the Navy and the entire bathroom gets renovated! My only option was a bath in a ball & claw tub!
 
raybonz said:
I know what you mean Dave! I left for the Navy and the entire bathroom gets renovated! My only option was a bath in a ball & claw tub!
Click to expand...

You had a tub.
Round galvanized metal wash tub & Mom heated water on the coal stove to give us a bath .
Memories :)
 
  • Like
Reactions: raybonz
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads

E
please recommend a chainsaw filing system
Replies
69
Views
8K
The Gear
andym
A
J
New stove, liner, and a chimney fire
Replies
19
Views
4K
The Hearth Room - Wood Stoves and Fireplaces
Ashful
Ashful
A
Husky 350 compression getting low
Replies
5
Views
2K
The Gear
Nealm66
Nealm66
N
Chain dull in two hours?
Replies
89
Views
9K
The Gear
TreePointer
TreePointer
C
Is a Stihl 251 c-be my best option?
Replies
31
Views
10K
The Gear
Roundgunner
Roundgunner
Top Bottom
Back