Developing a fair price for a used stove - Jotul F3

  • Active since 1995, Hearth.com is THE place on the internet for free information and advice about wood stoves, pellet stoves and other energy saving equipment.

    We strive to provide opinions, articles, discussions and history related to Hearth Products and in a more general sense, energy issues.

    We promote the EFFICIENT, RESPONSIBLE, CLEAN and SAFE use of all fuels, whether renewable or fossil.

mainerr

Member
Feb 16, 2017
14
Maine
I am looking at a stove and trying to determine a fair price. I did some research to try and find IRS basis for depreciation (found nothing of the sort), and called a few local shops to get opinions. Overall it seems a bit of a crap shoot - it all depends on how beat up the stove is.

The stove in question is a matte black Jotul F3, it's 9 years old and lightly used. It comes with a short leg kit. I went out and inspected it. Sure enough, it's in great shape.

The owner is asking $1,000. This price seems a bit high to me, so I tried to rationalize why. I have searched Craigslist for most of the northeastern states and I have found pricing varying from $350 to $1,100. So it seems to be on the upper end of that spectrum - but it's local, it's in great condition, and it was operated by someone who knows stoves and how to take care of them.

Local shops want $1,700 for the stove new, and the leg kit will be a bit on top of that.

Any input on how I can develop a fair price for both parties?

Thanks,
Mainerr
 
I dont think $1000 is out of line at all but I would offer $800 and expect to pay $900. That is if it is as good as you say with no issues at all.
 
I don't think that price is out of line . . . but I think for the price of a new one I would offer $750 cash and see if he bites.
 
That stove sold for about $1200 locally 10 yrs. ago. East coast price should have been less. I bought the enameled version for $1349 in 2005.
 
That stove sold for about $1200 locally 10 yrs. ago. East coast price should have been less. I bought the enameled version for $1349 in 2005.


Hi begreen,

Yes, I too noticed that the price of my F500 seems to be considerably higher these days than when I bought it (new) in 2010.

Two local shops quoted me $1800 and $1700, plus about $100 for the short leg kit for the F3. Why do you think stove prices have gone up?

Thanks
 
For the record, we wound up at $850 which I think was a square deal. They were a nice local family and I wouldn't have been happy with lowballing them so I am glad the way it worked out.

Picked it up today and it's sitting in the fireplace ready for install. (thread about the install process: https://www.hearth.com/talk/threads/confusion-fireplace-liner-requirements.160839/#post-2160431)

IMG_20170218_151903.jpg
 
Last edited by a moderator:
For the record, we wound up at $850 which I think was a square deal. They were a nice local family and I wouldn't have been happy with lowballing them so I am glad the way it worked out.

Picked it up today and it's sitting in the fireplace ready for install.
sounds like a fair price for all
 
Seems like a fair price . . . more importantly . . . I'm most happy (when I'm buying or selling) when everyone leaves feeling as though they got a decent deal or made a decent sale vs. having one feel as if they've been cheated by buying too much or selling too low.
 
  • Like
Reactions: begreen and mainerr
Glad it worked out for you. The stove looks great there. European stove prices went up due to a declining dollar and inflation. Odd that they don't decline again when the dollar gets stronger.