Any opinions on foam roofing vs tar and gravel for flat roofs

  • Active since 1995, Hearth.com is THE place on the internet for free information and advice about wood stoves, pellet stoves and other energy saving equipment.

    We strive to provide opinions, articles, discussions and history related to Hearth Products and in a more general sense, energy issues.

    We promote the EFFICIENT, RESPONSIBLE, CLEAN and SAFE use of all fuels, whether renewable or fossil.
Status
Not open for further replies.

HeatsTwice

Minister of Fire
Jan 7, 2008
592
Santa Rosa, California
I've got to replace 940 square feet of flat roof with either spray on foam roofing or tar and gravel. Foam roofing is about $100 per square foot but the literature indicates its is of superior quality compared to tar and gravel.

Any thoughts?
 
Foam is garbage, it has to be top coated and will degrade in time. And the top coat can easily be penetrated. You don't want that foam saturated with water and all that weight on your roof.
Tar and gravel I assume you mean tar with slag embedded on top. If you get a leak in that stuff, good luck finding and scrapping the slag off to repair it.

What are the dimensions of the roof?
I personally would go with EPDM (Rubber), as it is easy to put down, and easy to repair if need be. The field rubber will outlast you.
 
Dimensions roof 1: 46x12
Dimensions roof 2: 20x20

But doesn't application of feild rubber require removal of existing roof?

Thanks for the reply.
 
HeatsTwice said:
Dimensions roof 1: 46x12
Dimensions roof 2: 20x20

But doesn't application of feild rubber require removal of existing roof?

Thanks for the reply.

How many roof layers are on there now? If only 1 most states allow 2 roofs before having to rip off.
To do in rubber, you could just screw down 1/2 fiberboard and fully adhere the rubber to the fiberboard.
What is on the roof now?

The other alternative is to frame out a pitch roof with lumber and shingle it.
 
After looking at all the leaks that happened over the years and doing maintenance every year, I went the frame over route. Dropping plates down and standing trusses up on a flat roof is not a bad job.
 
Rubber membrane roofs. I didn't know anything else was even being installed at this point. The stuff is a big cost saver inside of 5 years, just keep the lawn chairs off it.
 
Hogwildz said:
HeatsTwice said:
Dimensions roof 1: 46x12
Dimensions roof 2: 20x20

But doesn't application of feild rubber require removal of existing roof?

Thanks for the reply.

How many roof layers are on there now? If only 1 most states allow 2 roofs before having to rip off.
To do in rubber, you could just screw down 1/2 fiberboard and fully adhere the rubber to the fiberboard.
What is on the roof now?

The other alternative is to frame out a pitch roof with lumber and shingle it.

Here are some pictures of the two roofs. They should be sloped properly to drain off standing water. Roof 1 (see photo captions on bottom of each photo) is tar and gravel. Only one layer but I put snow seal on it two years ago which sealed many leaks - for a while.

Roof two is a membrane type application. I don't know the name for it. But obviously it has to be resloped to the only scupper or a drain added.

http://picasaweb.google.com/lh/sred...1sRgCN6foOyg-NHGAQ&invite=CNrFkv4F&feat=email


Any thoughts?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.