Wood Boilers and Creosote

  • Active since 1995, Hearth.com is THE place on the internet for free information and advice about wood stoves, pellet stoves and other energy saving equipment.

    We strive to provide opinions, articles, discussions and history related to Hearth Products and in a more general sense, energy issues.

    We promote the EFFICIENT, RESPONSIBLE, CLEAN and SAFE use of all fuels, whether renewable or fossil.
  • Super Cedar firestarters 30% discount Use code Hearth2024 Click here
Status
Not open for further replies.

jebatty

Minister of Fire
Hearth Supporter
Jan 1, 2008
5,796
Northern MN
The recent flurry of posts regarding creosote with wood boilers piqued my interest in attempting to explain why, starting with the basics.

"Traditional" Outdoor Wood Boiler (OWB) and Gasification Wood Boiler (GWB)-- considering the simplest of these quickly shows the genesis of the problem with the OWB and the solution to that problem accomplished in the GWB.

The simple OWB is a steel firebox surrounded by a tank of water. Air (oxygen) is supplied by an open draft or draft fan. The wood burns in the firebox, essentially an open fire in a steel box, heat is transferred through the steel walls to the surrounding water, and flue gases go up the stack. You cannot heat water higher than 212F, so as the hot unburned gases collide with the low temperature steel walls, the gases condense on the walls of the firebox and droplets of condensation also are emitted with other flue gases up the stack, again condensing on contact with other surfaces. This condensation is creosote, water and other unburned material. Also, the rough flash point for wood is around 500F, and efficient combustion of wood starts to occur around 800-900F, with combustion efficiency increasing as the temperature continues to rise to a maximum of about 1800-2000F. Some of this lower (800F and higher) range efficient burning can occur in the hottest part of the fire, but it won't occur in the bulk of the firebox because of the "cold" steel walls encasing the combustion process. Therefore, lots of unburned gases will be exhausted up the stack and a portion will condense to creosote as the gases contact the low temperature in the steel walls, stack, and even in the cooling exhaust stream. Hence, often major creosote issues, low efficiency, and lots of smoke (unburned wood). Burn efficiency may range down to about 30%.

The simple GWB also is a steel firebox, quite small compared to an OWB, mostly surrounded by water but not on the bottom nor on the top. Condensation and creosote formation does occur on the walls in contact with water, and this is limited because the fire burns off the excess which accumulates and falls back into the burning wood. But the bottom of the firebox is a firebrick material with an opening (nozzle) to a lower chamber of ceramic/firebrick (tunnel). Air (oxygen) is supplied with a downdraft fan, with air divided between the firebox and the lower chamber. The downdraft forces the burning and unburned gases into the lower chamber, these are mixed with additional air to further the combustion, and the gases are momentarily trapped in the tunnel where further combustion occurs. This further combustion heats the tunnel to very high temperatures (up to about 1800-2000F) which almost completely burns the gases forced into the chamber from the downdraft. Burn efficiency in the tunnel can approach 98-99%. The extremely hot gases (almost all steam and carbon dioxide with excess oxygen and nitrogen at this point) in the tunnel are then forced by the draft through multiple firetubes surrounded by water in the back of the boiler, heat is transferred to the water, and the remaining steam and carbon dioxide and other gases are exhausted up the stack. Little or no condensation can occur in the firetubes because of the extreme heat, nor in the stack because exhaust temperatures are well above 212F. What may condense, if anything, is water and possibly a portion of the 1-2% of unburned gases, but again because of the heat and forced draft these normally are exhausted up the stack without condensing or formation of creosote. Smoke output up the stack is almost eliminated, and what may be seen as smoke is steam condensing as it contacts the cool atmosphere.

That's the basics. In the OWB arena design has moved in the direction of GWB design in an effort to increase efficiency and reduce smoke and creosote. In the GWB arena design has moved into computer controlled combustion with oxygen maximized to allow complete combustion, variable speed draft fans, and careful control of oxygen flow into both the upper firebox and lower tunnel, all to reduce emissions and maximize efficiency.

This explanation does not consider idling/slumbering in either boiler, and does not consider the impact of burning poorly seasoned wood or poor burning practices in either boiler, or the impact of often burning green wood in an OWB. The short answer is that any of this can greatly exacerbate the problem, or create a problem which otherwise may not exist, and those are additional discussions.
 
Other than a very slight (and useless in this discussion) change in potential temperature (from 212 to 250F or so with 15PSI) this applies exactly the same to old-school indoor wood boilers. Given that most boilers are actually controlled down to more of a 195F or so top temperature, it's pretty much not a factor, it's just that they are of the "can be in the house" flavor, so there's nothing overly special about outdoor wood boilers when it comes to poor combustion chamber design leading to massive creosote.

Combustion air preheating is also part of good combustion design, frequently seen in your better gasifiers.
 
Good point. The comparison relating to the OWB was made mostly because that type of boiler raises the most questions relating to creosote formation and because the OWB still occupies a sizable share of new wood boiler purchases. Improvements in design and engineering have moved the OWB a little higher on the efficiency scale and a little lower on the creosote creation potential scale, but I have not seen anything yet that moves beyond the current high end gasification design and engineering of wood boilers.
 
so there's nothing overly special about outdoor wood boilers when it comes to poor combustion chamber design leading to massive creosote.

Very true. I could operate my old indoor boiler so it didn't accumulate THAT MUCH (relatively speaking) creosote - but in doing so would send most of my hard earned wood right up the chimney without much of the heat from it getting into the water. In order to get much of any heat transfer into the water, I had to limit draft the boiler saw (had a key damper in the pipe, along with a baro) which created all kinds of creosote. So I really was chasing my tail, and creosote, and wood, constantly. So glad those days are over.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mike van
Status
Not open for further replies.