Re-shingling my roof soon. Need some advice for the flue.

  • Active since 1995, Hearth.com is THE place on the internet for free information and advice about wood stoves, pellet stoves and other energy saving equipment.

    We strive to provide opinions, articles, discussions and history related to Hearth Products and in a more general sense, energy issues.

    We promote the EFFICIENT, RESPONSIBLE, CLEAN and SAFE use of all fuels, whether renewable or fossil.
Status
Not open for further replies.

jrz126

New Member
Nov 13, 2008
8
Erie, PA
I'm going to be re-shingling my roof in a couple weeks. The flue is in pretty bad shape.
E32nd023.jpg

This is the only decent close-up pic I have of it. It was like this when I bought the house 6 months ago.

50005066000602-1.jpg


What all will I need to buy to replace it?

I'd like to replace just the part coming out of the roof with something skinnier if possible? Its on the front side of the house so I'd like to make less noticable.
 
You need to start with what specific model of stove/insert you will be using with this, then buy the flue size the manufacturer recommends, you are probably going to want to replace the inside flue at the same time as the outside chimney. They do sell these parts at the big box stores (Lowes & Home Depot) or local stove shops, or you can order online. Lowes used to have a nice little online tool that you could run to create a detailed list of everything you need to buy based on your specific situation, but for some reason they either moved or got rid of it. Any stove shop should be able to help you though, you'll need to calculate the correct total length using the formula recommended in our stove owners manual or the 10-2-3 rule, and you will need to buy the roof flange that is appropriate for the slope of your roof.
 
flashing is completely done for, chimney looks pretty nasy, too. what is hooked up to it?
 
The chimney look all used up . It looks like a old triple wall flue from the cool 60s . You could have a new roof collar made at a metal fab shop.
I would change out the hole thing . down to the stove
 
The flue manufacturer is "martin stamping and stove co" and the woodstove in the basement is a "Better'N Bens"
http://i297.photobucket.com/albums/mm207/jrz126_86ss/house/E32nd030.jpg

I guess its a "slammer stove".

I tried looking up the manufacturer and it looks like they went out of buisness awhile ago. So its probably impossible to replace just the top section.

What is the roof collar? is that just the flashing? I'd like to keep my costs down, so maybe I'll just try to replace that?
Or should I just bite the bullet and replace the whole chimney? Any idea how much that would cost?

Thanks,
Jeff
 
wellbuilt home said:
The chimney look all used up . It looks like a old triple wall flue from the cool 60s . You could have a new roof collar made at a metal fab shop.
I would change out the hole thing . down to the stove
pre-made flashings are much cheaper....

but i agree, get rid of the entire sytem!!
 
That chimney distracts from an otherwise lovely home. I'd deal with it before the roof...I suppose something durable that looks like a real brick chimney would look good up there.
 
the chimney tooks like a prefab, and there is a lot of brick fireplace there... you must have a prefab fp with some veneer of bricks around it. I would rip out the chimney, as it looks scary... especially with the better n' bens insert you got there (those things are rippin soot machines). the whole fp should probably go too, and get a hearth style install going with some metalbestos. I would bet money that there is no piped in connection with that stove, and you have no protected floorspace in front of it.. it has propbaly been that way for a while, and i am suprised you are insured with that going on. most companies will grandfather some of that in for the original owner, but i would not bank on them helping you out if something goes south and there is a chimney (or any other) fire. should you ask them to send an adjustor (or one shows up) they may give that a real hard look.
 
You might be a little far north for this, but I would look into reflective shingles. They look like regular shingles but there are designed to reflect the radiation from the sun. This lowers summer cooling bills.
 
Seems like the system is at end of life. It has paid for itself long ago. Now, for safety, efficiency and leak-free peace of mind, it looks like it's time to replace the whole shebang. If done well, expect another 20-30 yrs. out of it.
 
No way should you try to shingle around that flashing with a new roof. Looks like they brushed tar around the pipe at some point. That base flashing is shot. Your roof doesn't look THAT bad. I would replace that chimney now before this winter's use and hold off on shingling in a year or two until your funds build back up. A new shiny ss chimney with a probably smaller diameter pipe would give more curb appeal than that mess also. But only you know what your financial situation is. Do you want to continue using a wood stove and burn wood. If you have no real interest or don't plan on burning much wood take that chimney and stove out. Then you would have a nice curb appeal roof. Get dimensional (architectural) shingles also. Well worth the little extra money they cost. By the way, on second look that valley doesn't look too good. Get a closed cut valley also. They look better and are just as good. Tony
 
Status
Not open for further replies.