Insinkerator top spout broke and replacement part had no brass nut and ferrule for water line connection!

  • Active since 1995, Hearth.com is THE place on the internet for free information and advice about wood stoves, pellet stoves and other energy saving equipment.

    We strive to provide opinions, articles, discussions and history related to Hearth Products and in a more general sense, energy issues.

    We promote the EFFICIENT, RESPONSIBLE, CLEAN and SAFE use of all fuels, whether renewable or fossil.

Don2222

Minister of Fire
Feb 1, 2010
9,117
Salem NH
Hello
The Insinkerator hot water dispenser is very handy and lasted a long time. I own the original classic design. Recently the top handle broke. Therefore I ordered the new part thru Carroll parts 800-654-3545
Got the new parts and went to install it. The replacement installation is easier because the shutoff spigot to the cold water line is already there. However the new replacement part which is the new Contour style is very similar and mounts the same way but the brass water line is a little thicker. Therefore even though I spent some time very carefully cutting the copper water line and banging off the old brass nut and ferrule it does not fit the new copper water line!
Therefore I called the Insinkerator answer line and they said those parts do not come with the new replacement top!!
The lady said there are no specific part numbers for these parts and they can be purchased fromCarroll Parts or a plumbing supply store.
Does anyone know if Lowes or Home Depot has them or do I have to go to a hardware store or special plumbing supply store?
Pic 1 - water connection
Pic 2 - water connection diagram
Pic 3 - Hot Water tank
Pic 4 - Replacement top- Part # 45057A - $122 with shipping!
Pic 5 - sawing copper tube to bang off old ferrule and remove old brass water line nut
Pic 6 - Old ferrule and brass nut that does not fit new copper line in Pic 4 !!

19C4C357-551E-45A9-81CA-B15ABD85B5CB.jpeg 8CE0638E-1CB5-4498-8506-53A48B0581BF.jpeg FF947ED1-6B0C-4B60-B499-FD27C247A7F7.jpeg F9ED88E0-9D71-4BAF-ABBC-EBD2E6C64051.jpeg 12C795EC-7205-4C9E-9F6A-BBA046B09EE7.jpeg A5BDA655-02A3-4A04-B316-A7DE97054E40.jpeg
 
Last edited:
I tried to use the old ferrule and aha I found it has been compressed and not reusable!
Even more reason to include one in the replacement parts?? !!
I did find a new one for $2.75 at Home Depot!

4D3BE960-82D4-4135-A0EC-27BC1756FBEB.jpeg 54F14F48-ED91-4C12-8B8C-2686AA139136.jpeg
 
Last edited:
Yes, those are consumables. I used swagelock a lot for things like this.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Don2222
Hello
Just got the new spout installed.
The problem with the old one was that when you turned the top handle to turn on the hot water after a while was the whole body would also turn!
The body has a 1/4 x 20 thread post on the bottom with a horse shoe type clip to hold it with a 1/4” wing nut to the sink. Therefore the simple fix is to add a 1/4” C-Lock washer and regular washer to hold it in properly!
Another two parts that should be in the parts of both a new unit and the replacement top.
:)

See pics

AA2E4480-FAFE-47A6-B758-E0F5E21D6531.jpeg 61CD4F0C-FCAE-4697-B60F-B78CE32BBC14.jpeg E1FB0018-4C57-4A79-98A3-7B9C937152CD.jpeg
 
The struggle was not over yet!
The tank practically fell off the back wall under the sink because the screws were stripped and did not go into the studs. So I got my wall anchor kit and used the red anchors with screws that worked perfectly! Then I purchased at Home Depot a pack of 10 black ring washers 3/8” ID and 1/2” OD which looked like it would fit. Wow - No way would they fit! Back to Home Depot and saw a 10 pack of 5/16” ID x 1/2” OD - No Way
So the only way to get the right one which I found to be 5/16” IF x 7/16” OD and a wall of 1/16” is to purchase a huge assorted pack for $12.97 !!!
That washer should come with the replacement parts??
Pic 1&2 - Anchor Set
Pic 3 - Water tank properly screwed into wall
Pic 4&5 - Huge black ring washer set
Pic 6 - correct black ring washer installed!!
Pic 7 - Blue water connection does not leak!!
Pic 8 - Ring washer set receipt
Pic 9 - Had to add Teflon tape to connect the new copper tubing water connection brass nut and ferrule!
Pic 10 - Instant hot water is Back! It works!


F47964E2-3316-4923-8D44-EEB529A8A98F.jpeg B4CD33D4-6658-4926-85C6-689E1251EC0D.jpeg A6ADF695-2D35-4EC3-89A3-53114B2665D2.jpeg 4A8E8BBA-9631-44A7-896F-9368DEE22FE9.jpeg AD388D4F-0C85-492A-98FF-6331094ECEC7.jpeg D62D9657-D6E1-4474-923A-752FD63AF756.jpeg CA5383E4-97BC-4147-8CE8-5F6171CA2227.png C9438C0C-DFE1-402D-81B8-15FF45308890.jpeg 8AC727F2-469F-48CB-B995-70B118ED94CA.jpeg 2C896274-D014-4C9D-8E19-C5623F30446A.jpeg
 
Last edited:
The Broken Piece with top broken off

1D2C3950-68F2-405D-9185-FBDE9ECB3D29.jpeg 2A38AE9E-D97E-4A93-9A70-A27219CAD551.jpeg DE3D683A-E31A-4832-BC09-65D12C22D8D7.jpeg
 
Those red anchors are not good for drywall. Google drywall anchors. Those anchors are for brick, block, or concrete. And if you're screwing into the studs (best indeed), no need.to use anchors. Just long enough screws.
 
The struggle was not over yet!
The tank practically fell off the back wall under the sink because the screws were stripped and did not go into the studs. So I got my wall anchor kit and used the red anchors with screws that worked perfectly! Then I purchased at Home Depot a pack of 10 black ring washers 3/8” ID and 1/2” OD which looked like it would fit. Wow - No way would they fit! Back to Home Depot and saw a 10 pack of 5/16” ID x 1/2” OD - No Way
So the only way to get the right one which I found to be 5/16” IF x 7/16” OD and a wall of 1/16” is to purchase a huge assorted pack for $12.97 !!!
That washer should come with the replacement parts??
Pic 1&2 - Anchor Set
Pic 3 - Water tank properly screwed into wall
Pic 4&5 - Huge black ring washer set
Pic 6 - correct black ring washer installed!!
Pic 7 - Blue water connection does not leak!!
Pic 8 - Ring washer set receipt
Pic 9 - Had to add Teflon tape to connect the new copper tubing water connection brass nut and ferrule!
Pic 10 - Instant hot water is Back! It works!


View attachment 299766 View attachment 299767 View attachment 299768 View attachment 299769 View attachment 299770 View attachment 299771 View attachment 299773 View attachment 299774 View attachment 299780 View attachment 299781

Couple things with your water line connection. The tube insert is unnecessary for copper line, and teflon tape is also unnecessary for a compression fitting.

Neither are terrible but if you had a leak its likely because the insert stopped you from fully sealing the ferrule.
 
  • Like
Reactions: stoveliker
Couple things with your water line connection. The tube insert is unnecessary for copper line, and teflon tape is also unnecessary for a compression fitting.

Neither are terrible but if you had a leak its likely because the insert stopped you from fully sealing the ferrule.
Yes thanks for letting me know. The insert is for plastic lines, but it is not leaking but if it does I will take out the insert.
Those pieces should come with the replacement part with directions.
 
Hello
In Summary I wanted to say that I believe Insinkerator had addressed the problems I have found a few years ago!
These appliances are now very well made and last for many years!
I am very happy with it and use it almost every day!