Propane vs pellet

rombi Posted By rombi, Oct 28, 2008 at 7:15 PM

Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.
  1. rombi


    Dec 17, 2007
    Green Bay Wi
    Here is my situation that I first posted/
    I built a new room and I was wondering if any of you HVAC guys could help me out. The new room has a full basement (unheated at the moment) under it that one day will be finished and heated. Hooking it up to our current forced air is going to be $2000 so I thought it is a good time to look at options like a pellet stove in the bsement. Are those floor vents safe? I mean in a fire I would think that they would be a bad thing. Do they make vents that have a fire hinge on them? Like when a fire starts it shuts the hole. The placement of the vent (vents) would be over the the pellet stove and it should hat our 225 sq. ft room and also the rest of the basement. I do not want to do this if there isn’t an approved vent. I grew up in a house that had a floor grate and it actually was pretty good for the bedroom above it. I live in WI and this room started cooling off already. Unheated our basement (part garage area) stays about 45 unless it -20 for a few days then it gets below freezing. A little electric wall heater will heat it up so I think a pellet stove will do great. If I keep the door open from the upstairs it will warm up down there in time.

    My new question is do you think it will be cheaper to go with a propane heater in the basement or a pellet. I know the pellet is more expensive up front. Our garage/basement is insulated pretty good minus the garage door. The room that the pellet or propane heater will be in is right under the new room and is the same size of course as the new room. I can block that room off so the heat will stay in there and go up through the vents. I looked at both today at Fleet Farm and the BTU’s were close 42,000 pellet vs 45,000 for the hanging propane price was around 1300 pellet and 430 propane.
  2. imacman


    Rombi, have you calculated what your fuel will cost per BTU? That might help you decide. And try to figure out how long it will take to make up the difference in the cost of the stove even if the pellets are cheaper per BTU.
  3. kinsmanstoves

    Minister of Fire

    Aug 29, 2007
    Ravenna, Ohio 44266
    Go with LP it leaves us more pellets.

  4. rap69ri

    Minister of Fire

    Feb 23, 2008
    Middle of RI
    LOL..he's far enough away from us that it shouldn't make a differnce...or will it!!!
  5. imacman


Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.

Share This Page