Neighbor has (had) a standing dead tree that we believe to be oak. Looks like this. Seems to be still solid and makes that nice hollow sound when you clink two pieces together. Is this stuff still good?
standing dead tree... is this good wood?
- Thread starter jeffesonm
- Start date
-
Active since 1995, Hearth.com is THE place on the internet for free information and advice about wood stoves, pellet stoves and other energy saving equipment.
We strive to provide opinions, articles, discussions and history related to Hearth Products and in a more general sense, energy issues.
We promote the EFFICIENT, RESPONSIBLE, CLEAN and SAFE use of all fuels, whether renewable or fossil.
- Status
Ashful
Minister of Fire
Beautiful. By good, you mean ready to burn now? I'd be surprised, but maybe. Got a moisture meter?
If not good now, it will be soon enough. Those are some mighty short rounds, unless the picture makes them look shorter than they are.
If not good now, it will be soon enough. Those are some mighty short rounds, unless the picture makes them look shorter than they are.
That stuff, as good as it looks, will not be ready to burn. You can try it, but I'll almost guarantee it will smolder. Oak has the bad habit of holding moisture for a very long time, if not split and stacked. Its just the structure of the cells in the tree. I'd say that tree has probably been dead for 10 years or so, I've cut ones that were standing dear for over 25 years and all the bark and sapwood (the punky layer on your wood right under the bark) were totally gone, and even it needed some time split and stacked to be ready. The best way to tell, if you are uncertain, is to get a moisture meter. I'd try not to burn anything over 20%, off you don't have to.
Sorry I meant good like not rotten, but will be good to burn one day. Sounds like the answer is yes, so I will hurry back and get the rest of the trunk!
My stove takes a 16" log loaded N/S so I've been trying to cut them no bigger than that. I have been eyeballing it and I think some ended up in the 12-14" range. Maybe I will just measure down the trunk of this big log.
I do not have a moisture meter... all the reviews of ones on Amazon seem to be so-so and I think I'm far enough ahead in my wood collecting where I can just make sure everything is 1-2 years old. This will be the first year with the stove though so hard to say.
My stove takes a 16" log loaded N/S so I've been trying to cut them no bigger than that. I have been eyeballing it and I think some ended up in the 12-14" range. Maybe I will just measure down the trunk of this big log.
I do not have a moisture meter... all the reviews of ones on Amazon seem to be so-so and I think I'm far enough ahead in my wood collecting where I can just make sure everything is 1-2 years old. This will be the first year with the stove though so hard to say.
bogydave
Minister of Fire
Good looking wood.
The white sap wood will get a little punky, that's normal,
Premium wood there, get all you can
The white sap wood will get a little punky, that's normal,
Premium wood there, get all you can
TimJ
Minister of Fire
Thistle
Minister of Fire
Thanks guys. I propose this thread be retitled "great score from neighbor nextdoor"
Truckload #2:
Truckload #2:
Gasifier
Minister of Fire
That sounds like a good title Jeff. Good for you man. Nice work. I picked up a moisture meter at Lowe' for like $25 bucks last year. I don't believe it is the most accurate one you will find, but it gives you a pretty good idea of the range you are in. Here is a link to it at Lowe's for current price and description.
http://www.lowes.com/pd_78059-56005...l=1¤tURL=?Ntt=moisture+meter&facetInfo=
Just for your reference. Do you have all your wood for this season put away or under cover?
http://www.lowes.com/pd_78059-56005...l=1¤tURL=?Ntt=moisture+meter&facetInfo=
Just for your reference. Do you have all your wood for this season put away or under cover?
Maybe I will pick that one up. The Amazon reviews are mixed and most of the bad ones seem to be about quality vs accuracy.
I do have probably 2-3 cords of well seasoned, 2-3 year old wood stacked and ready to go. I actually started hoarding firewood before I even had a house or a wood stove... some trees were taken down at the place I was renting and my landlord paid me to split them up so they weren't all over his yard.
Truck load #3:
I do have probably 2-3 cords of well seasoned, 2-3 year old wood stacked and ready to go. I actually started hoarding firewood before I even had a house or a wood stove... some trees were taken down at the place I was renting and my landlord paid me to split them up so they weren't all over his yard.
Truck load #3:
Gasifier
Minister of Fire
Backwoods Savage
Minister of Fire
Jeff, that is great wood! As for the MM, it sounds as if you have been getting along without one and you probably could save the dollars now. So long as you have the time to dry the wood, the MM is redundant. I've burned wood for several years now and never had one. Never bothered me either and I don't have problems with wood that is not dry.
I cut a lot of standing dead oak. Depending on how long it's been dead usually the upper 3rd or a little better is dry enough to burn (>20%). either let it sit or get a MM to know though.
Standingdead
Burning Hunk
I split and tested some standing dead ash and elm I cut in Feb, and left in rounds. Came in at 16-18%. I generally find that other than oak, 6-9 months time in the round is good enough for debarked standing dead.
Bed floor to rails is normally about 2 ft. Looks like most of your wood is cut 20-24"
Ashful
Minister of Fire
Nice score! As to cutting length, there was a thread this summer about different techniques to get consistent length. I used to just use the bar on my 20" saw as the gauge, but now prefer to just cut a scrap of lumber (lathe or firring strip) to 20" and carry that with me as a guide.
tcassavaugh
Minister of Fire
i don't think it looks so good......i should probably come take it off your hands 
. some of the best firewood i ever got was standing deadwood in an upstate n.y. bog/swamp in the dead of winter. been dead awhile and burned great. wish i could find more. hard to get into the wetlands here in southern maryland.
cass
. some of the best firewood i ever got was standing deadwood in an upstate n.y. bog/swamp in the dead of winter. been dead awhile and burned great. wish i could find more. hard to get into the wetlands here in southern maryland.cass
Wood Duck
Minister of Fire
Good catch... it actually came from three different trees. First pics are tree #1, truck loads 2/3 are tree #2, and the last load below is tree #3. It was getting dark so I just cut a few of the bigger branches off tree #3 and called it quits for the day. He's got a standing dead hickory that still needs to be taken down so hoping to go back for round two shortly.
Fire Breathing Dragon
Member
Nice score! Ummmm, those are some nice BTU's. Love me some oak rounds piled up in the truck on the way home. 
osagebow
Minister of Fire
Ashful
Minister of Fire
My saw is usually my indicator on what is good, and what is not. On downed oak, it's not uncommon to go thru 2"-3" rotten sapwood, and then hit good, solid heartwood. Like most species, oak's sapwood rots faster than its heartwood.
Some purposely knock off the rotten stuff when they're splitting, but I usually don't bother.
Some purposely knock off the rotten stuff when they're splitting, but I usually don't bother.
Me neither, helps the wood get going quicker, only problem is it a sponge when it gets rained on if your wood is outside uncovered, takes longer for the surface moisture to dry off.
- Status
