Hi all,
I've been following this forum for a while, but this is my first post. I have an old heat exchanger insert in an unsafe chimney in the basement of my 1955 house (see attached pics). I'd like to get back to burning wood, and looking to go the insert route, as part of the basement upgrade.
Unlike many, my goals are more for recreation and ambiance; I want to stick with a wood-burner as I enjoy wood fires. But, living in the city = buying wood, so not looking for this to be a primary source of heat.
Attached you will see pictures of what is currently there. The fireplace itself measures 33.5" wide x 24" high by about 18" deep.
The room itself is about 350 SF which is open to the rest of the basement (~1000 unfinished SF) and there is a stairway that can offload some heat too.
Chimney goes past the 2nd story, so estimating 25 feet of draft to work with from the basement.
Having read this forum I've gotten a bit of a short list together of possible inserts, but now that it's 2020 and the rules have changed, looking for further advice.
Short list currently:
-Lopi Flush Wood Hybrid-Fyre (medium size)
(I had pondered the Revere too, but no longer an option; I like the view better out of the flush options, but the stove-based inserts seem like they would do OK without a blower. The new Answer looks nice, but might would look tiny in that space)
-Jotul's inserts; not sure if the Rockport would fit, but the Kennebec would.
-Napoleon Oakdale EPI3c (like the glass size, but seem to hear less about them on this forum)
-Osburn Matrix (but nearest dealer is 50 miles away; not sure that it offers anything over more available brands)
-Anyone with experience with the Stuv insert? It seems to have a nice view but maybe a little more delicate
-Anyone with experience on the new QuadraFire Expedition II / VC Montpelier II (looking at the EPA site, they're classified as the same unit)? The previous VC Montpelier looked appealing on the surface, but with some of the commentary on this thread I had second thoughts.
Do folks have others they would recommend?
Of note, I'm not looking for a super long burn time, or for a catalytic system (would rather watch the reburn on a non-cat or hybrid stove)
Here's the current appearance, in all its 1970s glory. The doors together are about 13" x 30" but with those thick metal trims around each bi-fold section, the view is OK but not awesome.
Thanks in advance for any thoughts! I've already learned a bunch reading through others' posts.
I've been following this forum for a while, but this is my first post. I have an old heat exchanger insert in an unsafe chimney in the basement of my 1955 house (see attached pics). I'd like to get back to burning wood, and looking to go the insert route, as part of the basement upgrade.
Unlike many, my goals are more for recreation and ambiance; I want to stick with a wood-burner as I enjoy wood fires. But, living in the city = buying wood, so not looking for this to be a primary source of heat.
Attached you will see pictures of what is currently there. The fireplace itself measures 33.5" wide x 24" high by about 18" deep.
The room itself is about 350 SF which is open to the rest of the basement (~1000 unfinished SF) and there is a stairway that can offload some heat too.
Chimney goes past the 2nd story, so estimating 25 feet of draft to work with from the basement.
Having read this forum I've gotten a bit of a short list together of possible inserts, but now that it's 2020 and the rules have changed, looking for further advice.
Short list currently:
-Lopi Flush Wood Hybrid-Fyre (medium size)
(I had pondered the Revere too, but no longer an option; I like the view better out of the flush options, but the stove-based inserts seem like they would do OK without a blower. The new Answer looks nice, but might would look tiny in that space)
-Jotul's inserts; not sure if the Rockport would fit, but the Kennebec would.
-Napoleon Oakdale EPI3c (like the glass size, but seem to hear less about them on this forum)
-Osburn Matrix (but nearest dealer is 50 miles away; not sure that it offers anything over more available brands)
-Anyone with experience with the Stuv insert? It seems to have a nice view but maybe a little more delicate
-Anyone with experience on the new QuadraFire Expedition II / VC Montpelier II (looking at the EPA site, they're classified as the same unit)? The previous VC Montpelier looked appealing on the surface, but with some of the commentary on this thread I had second thoughts.
Do folks have others they would recommend?
Of note, I'm not looking for a super long burn time, or for a catalytic system (would rather watch the reburn on a non-cat or hybrid stove)
Here's the current appearance, in all its 1970s glory. The doors together are about 13" x 30" but with those thick metal trims around each bi-fold section, the view is OK but not awesome.
Thanks in advance for any thoughts! I've already learned a bunch reading through others' posts.
