Empyre Eleite 200 first months /review

  • Active since 1995, Hearth.com is THE place on the internet for free information and advice about wood stoves, pellet stoves and other energy saving equipment.

    We strive to provide opinions, articles, discussions and history related to Hearth Products and in a more general sense, energy issues.

    We promote the EFFICIENT, RESPONSIBLE, CLEAN and SAFE use of all fuels, whether renewable or fossil.
  • Hope everyone has a wonderful and warm Thanksgiving!
  • Super Cedar firestarters 30% discount Use code Hearth2024 Click here
Status
Not open for further replies.

yz125canada

New Member
Dec 27, 2014
5
Canada
Some background :

My self and my wife built a new home this summer, we made the decision to burn wood right from the get go. Originally we were going to go with a wood oil or wood electric combo forced air furnace. That is what we had been using and it was working great. After looking around at some options and wanting radiant heat in the basement we decided a boiler was the best option. After researching boilers I got hooked on gasification.

I ordered an empyre eliete 200 in June and did not receive it until mid November after some seriously high electricity bills from running construction heaters I received the boiler and fired it up.

Originally the house was designed to have the boiler and wood storage inside in the basement. thankfully we put the boiler out in a shed. Quite possibly the best decision we made. Not only is the mess outside but to smoke stays outside too.

So right away when I received the boiler I did an inspection of the fire box and the secondary burn chamber. First thing I noticed was some broken fire bricks. The second thing I noticed was the weld quality of the seams of the fire box. The welds look like bubble gum. ( befor you ask I am qualified to tell you that the weld quality is terrible on my boiler)

After my inspection and an ever increasing hydro bill I had to fire the boiler which is connected to my radiant floor loop and an air handler. I purchased the profab eso which has a danfoss tempering valve to keep the boiler at 140 f or above befor sending water to the main loop. From the eso I ran a 1 1/4 main loop to the house and set up a manifold to pull from. 3 speed circ pumps and a variable speed air handler. Our home is 3000 square feet all in 3 levels open concept. Insulated with 5 1/2 inches of wall tite Eco purple spray foam top to bottom an ICF basement and 6 inches of blue foam under the pad with 1 inch of thermal break from the footings.

The Review

After my first month and a half of headaches I am starting to get the hang of this stove. Everyone talks about bridging or when the fire fails to burn in the secondary burn chamber or the logs hang up in the fire box and burn a chunk out of the center. It seems to happen a lot. I checked my wood its at 20- 25% moisture I cut it 26 inches long for the 28 inch fire box, I palace every log in the fire box with care and love. Then I go to work and come home to a cold boiler twice a week at least. I can tell you it's all about planning and placement making sure the logs will fall down to the nozzles to allow then to get turned into usable heat. All and all this is not a stove you can just fire some wood into and walk away from.

Cleaning and pro former( that white dust in a box pro fab sent me with my boiler) so I can't stand putting the pro former into the stove twice a day, simply because no one will tell me what it is and how it works. But I have been doing it. Not sure if it helps or not. As stated in the manual I clean the ash once a week and the heat x tubes biweekly. To do the heat x tubes you get down on hands and knees and run a brush through each tube four or five times. All in all its not that bad a bit dirty and I know I would be cursing if it was inside my new home and I had to do it. But out side in the shed I some how always end up with soot everywhere. Takes about 20 minuets to do the job right

Smoke free loading my but. So unless you open the door over a five minute span it smokes like crazy. Again I can't say how happy I am that I did not put the boiler in my house. And once it is open when you slide the wood in the baffle at the door kicks in and the smoke rolls out. The best time I have found to load is when the boiler is in the middle of a burn cycle and everything is hot embers in the fire box.

Burn time. When the wood does not hang up I load it twice a day with about 5 or 6 logs. To give you an idea of wood volume used I burn a pile 6 foot 6 inches long by 3 feet high by 4 feet wide every two weeks or one pick up load. You guys can figure out how many chords/ cubic meters that is on your own. We are burning seasoned jack pine not split.

Creosote. Well it's a monster in that department just drips in the primary chamber and the secondary is caked with a black flaky layer. Chimney is evenly coated with the black fluffy stuff.

Water temps and btu output

So I am running at 175 on the controller and it will fall about 5 degrees befor restarting the blower. If both my floor and air handler call for heat at once the temps will drop right off to the low 150 's. Befor the stove can get relight and start to recover. Probably a good reason to add storage but the "dealer says". "These stoves do not require it"

Future plans

Install the electric back up elements in the stove which I ordered in June that have not showed up yet. Add storage for heat. Build a monster wood shed and stack wood according to size to simplify loading. As well hook up my domestic hot water.

All in all I will keep the stove and deal with the gremlins for now.
 
Why set to only 175F? Running hot will help the bridging.
 
You will also get less bridging with smaller splits, and drier wood.

Loading smaller loads (to suit the heat load) will also help with the creosote buildup & smoke spillage.

Storage may not be 'required', but it sure will clean up the operation of it and should also reduce wood consumption some from reduced smouldering losses.

Good luck!
 
Probably a good reason to add storage but the "dealer says". "These stoves do not require it"
Most dealers will say "These stoves do not require it" but the rest of the sentence that they failed to say is "but they will perform twice as good with it". Either they are uninformed or they are starting to believe their own propaganda that they dispense to potential customers to make them believe they can get into wood heating on the cheap.
 
Yeah... That's the conundrum without storage. I'd bet you'll see somewhat less baby sitting going to 180. Ours is set to 195F. You will see how well it will run when you get to outdoor temps so low it can't idle and must run wide open to meet demand. If the wood is seasoned your bridging problems will about disappear. That's when the lights will come on about storage. Wonder why 180 is the limit, non-pressurized system? For 5 years I tried to extend burn times and minimize idling by running it choked. Lots of baby sitting, creosote, and bridging. Now I have somewhere to put that energy when she's running hard and hot. You'll learn so much during your first season! Cheers.
 
Sorry to say you joined hearth far too late, there is a ton of information on here regarding the poor performance, design and customer service from profab.
 
The Proformer (anti-creosote) treatment package says it is non-toxic and contains sillica crystailline, quartz; CAS # 14808-60-7.

http://www.cssand.com/MSDS.pdf

Well that tells me it is crushed rock and sand. It boils at 4046 deg F. It melts at 3100 deg F. It does not burn or flash. I really don't see how that is suppsed to help the fire, boiler, or chimney system. I think it's snake oil in a bucket.

IIRC, my Elite 100 has a 100 cfm blower fan. That is not enough flow and the directions do not tell you to add much product to the fire, so it's not like the stuff is sandblasing the HX tubes or anything.

My boiler is used & refurbished. The prior owner was using the Proformer stuff and gave me a little that was left over. He also gave me a jug of "Imperial creosote conditioner" which states that it: "may be effective against scale and soot in wood burning systems if used according to the instructions. Removal or reduction of scale and soot can help reduce the threat of a chimney fire and increase heating efficiency."

Burn dry seasond wood hot and don't let it idle / smolder (use storage) and these concerns mostly go away.

This Imperial stuff says it contains trisodium phosphate:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trisodium_phosphate

(broken link removed to http://www.vinvicta.com.au/information/TrisodiumPhosphateMSDS.pdf)

It is a good cleaner & degreaser. It is basic, a 1% solution has a pH of 12.1. I guess when you have a fresh load of wood in the fire and throw this on it is supposed to mix with the moisture baking out of the (less than dry) wood and help to reduce the acidic attack.
 
Sorry to say you joined hearth far too late, there is a ton of information on here regarding the poor performance, design and customer service from profab.

There might also be some happy customers with no complaints.
 
this is the only good part of this thread "" Not only is the mess outside but to smoke stays outside too."" ....... I'll add that the "reanimated bugs" in the wood are outside to :) !!!
 
There might also be some happy customers with no complaints.

I don't think it is a terrible boiler it works well when it works. It's just not reliable yet.

The customer service direct from profab has been good for me. From my dealer it is lacking a bit. The delivery times and weld quality did disappoint me.

It would have been nice to know that storage is a must befor finishing the house and all the heating system.
 
Yeah... That's the conundrum without storage. I'd bet you'll see somewhat less baby sitting going to 180. Ours is set to 195F. You will see how well it will run when you get to outdoor temps so low it can't idle and must run wide open to meet demand. If the wood is seasoned your bridging problems will about disappear. That's when the lights will come on about storage. Wonder why 180 is the limit, non-pressurized system? For 5 years I tried to extend burn times and minimize idling by running it choked. Lots of baby sitting, creosote, and bridging. Now I have somewhere to put that energy when she's running hard and hot. You'll learn so much during your first season! Cheers.


A question about wood placement.

It seems that when I place a log in the coals right over the nozzles only that log will burn. It makes heat like crazy then dies off once that log is burnt but the ones above just turn to coals in the upper burn chamber. I always try to plan the load so that logs will fall onto the openings but they do hang up sometimes. Is there some manic advice to placing the wood just right?

The wood is at 21% moisture I tested a fresh split last night. It was cut 2 seasons ago for my old hunter wood electric. I don't think I can get any dryer wood in my area. It was covered since I cut it under a tarp. And it was dead standing jackpine befor I cut it.

Back to running at 180 F. The controller came with the boiler and it only gives a 10 degree F range. Profab has it locked out.
 
I have not heard of a "hack" that allows setting the upper limit higher than 180. The controller has a built in 10 deg diff, so if set to 180 it will kick back in when it drops from 170 to 169. I'm sure the 180 limit is due to it being an atmospheric unit.

The wiring is not all that complicated when you get into it. There is a temp probe, a manually reset overheat snap disc and a temp controller that turns the fan on & off. If one really wanted to, one could probably re-wire the unit to function with something like a Johnson Controls A419, that has a higher range, adjustable diff & a plethora of other features.

http://www.supplyhouse.com/Johnson-...age-Digital-Temperature-Control-120-240v-SPDT
 
well i wish you the best of luck with your stove. i had two empyer elites in two years. the second stove was so bad that in the end they gave me a 50% refund. Ben the main engineer even came down, spent 3 hours traring my stove apart and could not find any problems. make sure you get everything in writing because they tend to change their mind to better them.
 
I think we're talking about two different models here, the elite are indoor boilers that seem to have all the issues.
I have not heard too many problems with the outdoor models.
 
Yz, I don't know anything about the Empyre or ProFab, but I know it's the best boiler you own right now. You'll learn how to get the most out of it. I use very dry kindling and small splits and load smallest to largest to get a healthy coal bed. For me smaller splits reduce likelihood of bridging. When I have the time I only fill about 1/4 full and let that load get hot, then fill the rest after 20 minutes or so. I find myself often the tightening bottom splits with my poker to close up blow thrus in a new fire. Just last nite I got the dreaded FUEL light (shut down due to low output) but storage kept the house warm until re-firing this morning. Hang tough, much to learn.
 
I guess, it is written "Profab Empyre Elite II 200" It is a outdoor but in CT big government wont allow a outdoor boiler so I have it in a shed. I would have anyway but really don't like a bunch of know nothing - do nothing parasites telling me how to live. I got the permit for a heated shed with electric service.


[Hearth.com] Empyre Eleite 200 first months /review

[Hearth.com] Empyre Eleite 200 first months /review

[Hearth.com] Empyre Eleite 200 first months /review

[Hearth.com] Empyre Eleite 200 first months /review

I wish I had made the shed bigger.
 
I think we're talking about two different models here, the elite are indoor boilers that seem to have all the issues.
I have not heard too many problems with the outdoor models.

There are 4 models, 2 indoor & 2 outdoor (XT's), in the small and larger size. The fire boxes, controls, etc are identical, at least that is what my local dealer told me when I was researching them. The only difference is that the outdoor models (may) have more insulation and are housed inside the extra (tin box) weather enclosure.

The cfm of the fan may be different, not sure on that. The 100's have 2 slots in the nozzle, the 200's have 3 slots.
 
I wish it had a remote temperature display so I knew if it was cooling down. I try to time it so it runs out and has just a bit of coals left so it burns off the creosote but still hot enough that I don't have to relight it.
 
I guess, it is written "Profab Empyre Elite II 200" It is a outdoor but in CT big government wont allow a outdoor boiler so I have it in a shed. I would have anyway but really don't like a bunch of know nothing - do nothing parasites telling me how to live. I got the permit for a heated shed with electric service.

I had those plans in a shed and almost went with it, even had an agreement on a demonstrator Profab Empyre Elite II 200 for $5,500. Then I saw the Eko for $4,100 delivered to the door and made the switch. Put the saved dollars into storage and moved the whole thing into the shop.
 
My 100 has an extra 1/2" threaded port in the upper rear, next to the fan, factory temp probe & overheat snap disc. You could install a probe there but that would require a lot of wiring (or wireless setup) to get indication in the house.

Yours is outdoor, so the pump runs 24/7 right? How about installing a temp probe on the hot water feed coming into the house to set off an alarm or light. Something to the tune of run the boiler 170-180 but have the alarm kick on at 150 or 140.
 
My 100 has an extra 1/2" threaded port in the upper rear, next to the fan, factory temp probe & overheat snap disc. You could install a probe there but that would require a lot of wiring (or wireless setup) to get indication in the house.

Yours is outdoor, so the pump runs 24/7 right? How about installing a temp probe on the hot water feed coming into the house to set off an alarm or light. Something to the tune of run the boiler 170-180 but have the alarm kick on at 150 or 140.


Can any one recommend a Aqua stat that would be able to shut down circ pumps if the boiler water were to fall below a pre set limit. For example if I do hook up my domestic hot water I would not want my boiler to drag down the DHW system. Using a plat heat exchanger and a pump.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.