Being in construction for 30 years, I've tried a lot of different boots.
Those are in my top list for arch comfort, but the stores that sold them near me don't carry them in an 8" tall size.
The 6" height irritated the back of my upper ankle area.
When it comes to boots I'm not one to order on line.
I gotta try them on.
The best I ever wore were Herman Survivors, they were waterproof, super warm, and super comfortable.
I would buy them every Black Friday at a Walmart in CT near my sisters house.
But they stopped making them and I cant find them any where.
So, Ive been wearing these now,
http://shop.timberland.com/product/index.jsp?c=1106592&productId=4208156&prodFindSrc=paramNav
They are great, comfortable, waterproof, warm for the winter but not to warm for the summer.
I pretty much wear them 7 days a week, year round.
Just last weekend, for the first time in who knows how long, I threw on sneakers while working around the house, and wouldn't ya know it I stepped on a nail out in the back 40
If they made them in black, I'd get a pair just for going out.
I'm sure my wife would love that