I also was wondering what is the best way to remove the door pins? Best tools and tricks? Thanks
They should remove easily when greased regularly. Tap them out or just lift the door straight up. Once loose and serviced correctly they should remove by hand. That's in a perfect world where someone has maintained the stove....... If they don't remove easily, you probably would not be asking the question.
Open and close door to see if the hinge pin is rotating with the door. If so, it is stuck in door hinge ear and rotating in the hinge plate. Clean any portion that sticks through the bottom of hinge plate. Sandpaper, Scotch Bright, wire wheel, anything to remove rust down to a clean pin. Apply penetrating fluid of your choice to both ends of pin. PB Blaster, Kroil, Liquid Wrench, WD-40 is better than nothing, or even oil mixed with kero or diesel fuel. After soaking overnight, try tapping them out. If they don't start to move, rotating with pliers or vice grips usually breaks them loose. If the pin is long enough to grip on the bottom, grip by head and bottom of pin to rotate back and forth without damaging pin head. Rotating breaks them loose better than driving out with a punch or chisel under the head.
When removing pins from door, there is a possibility of damaging pin heads. Vice grips or pliers should be enough to break loose by rotating. When they start rotating, lubricate and work pin out rotating and pulling upward. All is not lost if the vice grips or pliers mar the heads putting grip marks in the head. They were 3/8 solid rivets. If they come out undamaged, clean rust off with wire brush or Scotch Bright, or lightly sanding.
To make new pins, use a 3/8 bolt with no threads under the head with shank long enough to cut threads off. Grind bolt head points off with a bench grinder. Chuck the bolt in hand drill. Running hand drill in reverse, run the head against the running bench grinder to form head. A little practice makes original looking rivet heads easily. Cut to length removing threads. Chamfer cut end slightly.
Apply high temperature grease or silver anti-seize to pins when installing. Grease annually. Hinge pins should remove with your fingers easily.
Also lubricate threads behind air intake damper. Open door, open damper, reach through intake opening in door to apply silver anti-seize or high temp grease to threads. This will prevent wear on the damper bolts and door hinges.