It was the gasket on the ash box door. Hadn't been replaced in 8 years. It was so flat that I thought it was a flat gasket. It was a 3/8" round gasket, same as the main door. Thanks to the good people at The Trading Post in New Milford Ct. who suggested changing every gasket, sealing all the joints on the exhaust pipes and a thorough cleaning. The odor was faint, but persistent.