Failed combustor causing smoke smell in house?

  • Active since 1995, Hearth.com is THE place on the internet for free information and advice about wood stoves, pellet stoves and other energy saving equipment.

    We strive to provide opinions, articles, discussions and history related to Hearth Products and in a more general sense, energy issues.

    We promote the EFFICIENT, RESPONSIBLE, CLEAN and SAFE use of all fuels, whether renewable or fossil.
B

barnyardengineering

New Member
Jan 2, 2023
54
Rochester NY
I have a Vermont Castings Dutchwest 2461 that recently started putting a mild smoke smell into the house until it gets burning good.

During the last warm spell I pulled the lid and the combustor is crumbling. Ordered a new one but that won't be here for a few days.

Will replacing the combustor fix the issue?
 
You know what? I'm just going to live with it.

The stove suddenly started behaving completely differently. You put wood in and it catches fire now. If you waited too long to put wood in before, it would be hours before it started burning.

Sure you could open the bypass and the fire would roar to life, but if you left the bypass open it would get so hot the bypass would seize and you couldn't close it. When you did close it the fire would go out.
 
Of course now that the temps are falling off again, the stove is now filling the house with smoke again.

For three days it burned perfectly. All I did was put wood in. Drove me out of the house, but the outside temps were around 50.

It's now in the 30's. Put wood in. Stove goes out. Put wood in 2 hours ago. Barely burning. House full of smoke. Same wood as I've been burning the last 3 days. Dust dry. Been sitting on a trailer in a barn for over a year.

I hate this stove.
 
If that stove hasn't been fully rebuilt lately it can have air leaks from just about anywhere, that is why I recommended doing a rebuild.

Instructions on rebuild:

Dutchwest 2461 stove inner top assembly replacement

Hey folks, I bought this Dutchwest 2461 a couple of years from Craigslist for a steal, so I knew I was going to have some work to do on it at some point. Well, that some point has come. The damper adjuster fell off the damper the other day, and when I took the top off to put it back on, I...
www.hearth.com www.hearth.com

How to Disassemble my VC Dutchwest Stove to Replace the Inner Lid

I've had a 2461 catalytic stove since new, and the inner lid (basically the top of the firebox) has sagged from the heat. Amazingly, I found a replacement here: https://www.stove-parts-unlimited.com/vermont-castings-inner-top-for-dutchwest-large-2461-stoves-7001119a-p/7001119a.htm I am not...
www.hearth.com www.hearth.com
 
It has been rebuilt.

Why do you keep quoting those threads? Neither of them goes into any specific detail on "rebuilding." We did exactly what both of those threads were asking about two years ago. Had to completely tear down the stove to the floor and legs, chip out all the old cement, and reassemble. It took three of us all day. It was like putting together a giant house of cards. I'm by myself now, and it is cold. There is no way I can reassemble the stove myself if I wanted to, and I can't afford not having it burning for the 2-3 days it will take to do the job and wait for the cement to cure.
 
Last edited:
How does your chimney cap look? Could be clogged if your cat wasn’t up to par.
 
rudysmallfry said:
I hope you have a working CO detector in the house.
Click to expand...

So do I. I have a CO detector but no way to tell if it works. Guess if I don't wake up one morning, I'll know it doesn't work.

I just wish someone could give me some advice that I haven't already tried up to a dozen times. The stove was rebuilt two years ago. The chimney is clean. I can't do anything about the way it's piped or the draft the chimney makes.
 
mellow said:
Do you have some pictures of your setup you could post?
Click to expand...
20230108_093934.jpg
 
Maybe it’s that horizontal run of stove pipe? It may draft better with 2 ea 45 elbows with a short section of pipe between.
 
Is there any backpuffing occurring in the early stage of the burn?
 
Todd said:
Maybe it’s that horizontal run of stove pipe? It may draft better with 2 ea 45 elbows with a short section of pipe between.
Click to expand...
It's been like that for around 20 years. Don't know why it would suddenly be a problem like this.

By "problem" I mean it never filled the house with smoke before on a consistent basis like this, that I am aware of.

Just ran the sweeper through the chimney again. Got less than a ash shovel's worth of creosote out.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Todd
It sounds like there is leakage until the vacuum created by draft gets strong enough to pull air in to the fire through the leakage spot. If you have a very bright LED flashlight, try shining it along every seam and crevice of the stove body to see if it illuminates a wisp of smoke. Look especially carefully around the flue collar area and top.

Another clue might be seeing a disruption in the burn pattern where the air is being pulled in. With a cold stove, this area would probably show a trail of soot. Remove the top lid to look for any soot trails.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Poindexter
begreen said:
It sounds like there is leakage until the vacuum created by draft gets strong enough to pull air in to the fire through the leakage spot. If you have a very bright LED flashlight, try shining it along every seam and crevice of the stove body to see if it illuminates a wisp of smoke. Look especially carefully around the flue collar area and top.

Another clue might be seeing a disruption in the burn pattern where the air is being pulled in. With a cold stove, this area would probably show a trail of soot. Remove the top lid to look for any soot trails.
Click to expand...

Can't see any leaks or any trails of soot.

This stove does not have any "burn pattern." It's all over the place. I'm constantly chasing my tail trying to keep it burning. It's always been a struggle, for the entire time they've owned it.

Like today. It burned all day with barely any smoke smell in the house at all. I've done nothing but put 2-3 chunks in every 3 hours. Burned hot and steady all day. Unusual. Thought I had it licked.

Put 2 chunks in at 9PM, same as I'd done all day long. Stove still plenty hot when I did it. It's been losing ground ever since, getting colder and colder, and is now PUFFING out the air intakes and from under the lid.

Okay it's a draw problem. What can I do about it? There's nothing I can do about the chimney. It is what it is. It's 3-4 months just to get a contractor in to give me an estimate. Plus I can't be without the stove this time of year. The oil furnace is all but worthless as far as heat, and will cost $6+ and hour to run.
 
mellow said:
Have you installed the new cat and did you order new gasket for the cat as well?
Click to expand...
The cat is still in the mail. UPDATE: FedEX just left it on the porch.

I don't know when I'll be able to install it. Takes a day for the stove to cool off enough to handle the lid. I don't have a day this week warm enough to let the stove go out.

Gasket is NLA far as I can tell.
 
Last edited:
barnyardengineering said:
Can't see any leaks or any trails of soot.

This stove does not have any "burn pattern." It's all over the place. I'm constantly chasing my tail trying to keep it burning. It's always been a struggle, for the entire time they've owned it.

Like today. It burned all day with barely any smoke smell in the house at all. I've done nothing but put 2-3 chunks in every 3 hours. Burned hot and steady all day. Unusual. Thought I had it licked.

Put 2 chunks in at 9PM, same as I'd done all day long. Stove still plenty hot when I did it. It's been losing ground ever since, getting colder and colder, and is now PUFFING out the air intakes and from under the lid.

Okay it's a draw problem. What can I do about it? There's nothing I can do about the chimney. It is what it is. It's 3-4 months just to get a contractor in to give me an estimate. Plus I can't be without the stove this time of year. The oil furnace is all but worthless as far as heat, and will cost $6+ and hour to run.
Click to expand...
There are stoves that will breathe easier. Responded in the replacement thread.
 
barnyardengineering said:
Gasket is NLA far as I can tell.
Click to expand...
NLA = no longer available? If no gasket, this will be a failed experiment. Check to see if the cat is wrapped in one. If not, Interam gasket is sold separately for cats.
 
begreen said:
NLA = no longer available? If no gasket, this will be a failed experiment. Check to see if the cat is wrapped in one. If not, Interam gasket is sold separately for cats.
Click to expand...

No longer availalble, correct. It does not appear on the parts diagram, and I have been unable to find it listed in the hundreds of individual parts for this stove.

The new cat did not come with the gasket. None of the new cats have. Any time I've asked about the gasket for the cat, they wonder why I'm trying to wrap a cat with gasket material and threaten to call animal control. That's a joke, saying in a roundabout way that they have no idea what I am asking for. Idiots.

We used the original gasket until it disintegrated several years ago. With or without has not made any noticeable difference.

Where do I get this "Interam" material?
 
  • Like
Reactions: barnyardengineering
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

B
Dutchwest 2461 smoke smell and failed combustor
Replies
29
Views
3K
Vermont Castings
Prometeo
Prometeo
K
Sparks & smoke suddenly came out from air intake
Replies
16
Views
947
The Hearth Room - Wood Stoves and Fireplaces
bholler
B
G
New 316 Liner Issues in old clay liner.
Replies
6
Views
2K
The Hearth Room - Wood Stoves and Fireplaces
begreen
begreen
M
New Harman P68 smoke smell
Replies
9
Views
2K
The Pellet Mill - Pellet and Multifuel Stoves
rickwai
rickwai
L
Combustor question, Dutchwest
Replies
3
Views
1K
The Hearth Room - Wood Stoves and Fireplaces
begreen
begreen
Top Bottom
Back