Well we were going out the back of the fireplace with vent. That puts me right at or just under the max horizontal limit. So now I either need to put in a 4" vertcal for a few ft. Or just figure out a 4" liner and keep all enclosed. Nobody seems to like my through the fireplace install idea, including Harman. I have to cut a notch in the existing heatilator that lines my fireplace. Everyone, probably the inspector too likes the liner idea. My stepson can help do it either way. At least it ends up being a vertical exit this way.