Insulated, Underground PEX solutions between buildings....(yet again)

  • Active since 1995, Hearth.com is THE place on the internet for free information and advice about wood stoves, pellet stoves and other energy saving equipment.

    We strive to provide opinions, articles, discussions and history related to Hearth Products and in a more general sense, energy issues.

    We promote the EFFICIENT, RESPONSIBLE, CLEAN and SAFE use of all fuels, whether renewable or fossil.

DSSA

Member
Nov 29, 2017
79
Rockhill Twp. , PA
I've spent many hours in here digging through posts, doing searches (many links even within the site don't work correctly), etc.

I *THINK* I've seen most of the pertinent posts regarding this, but may have missed some.

I like to do my own research before asking, *BUT* I'm getting to that point where I feel the need to ask.

YES! I *get it*, closed-cell foam insulated, underground, insulated PEX is the best to use if you want to buy something, bury it, connect it, and only 'cry once'. Yet, at $15+ per foot, I'm looking at other, viable solutions from those that have 'rolled their own' so-to-speak....

I have an Eko40 boiler housed in the garage closest to our house (about a 75-ish foot run to the closest entry point to the house with where I want to position it the boiler to the best entry point of the house without creating chaos on that aspect). It will be feeding into a 1000 gallon, pressurized storage tank in the same garage before feeding to the house. I have the ability (Case 580C backhoe with 12" bucket) to trench across our driveway between the two buildings, but am unsure as to how deep I can trench the whole run, as we live basically on a pile of boulders (they make old VW vans seem small at times..).

I *WISH* I had the money to dig it out, just pay for the best 1 1/4" closed-cell-foam insulated PEX piping out there, but money *IS* an object, and this is an experiment on doing it as best I can, on a budget, and then knowing that this Eko40 may have a limited lifespan and I'll have to have everything running, showing a decent ROI, and then replacing it with a newer boiler. Time is 'a-tcking' on years left in my life to have it be a worthwhile investment and pay us back. We live in Southeastern, PA, so winters can be brutal when it decides to be, mild other years. I plan on heating the garage everything is housed in with this (via some diesel truck, aluminum radiators that I have around and some fans behind them, the house, and our DHW needs (batch burning year round from wood sourced mainly (for now) of of our heavily-wooded 10 acres (99% hardwood).

I'd like to dig it the trench once, run water feed from our well, an electric upgrade feed for said garage, and *TWO* runs of insulated PEX (one pipe with two 1 1/4" feeds for the heat feed (redundancy in case one PEX fails), and another with 2, 1 1/4" returns. I figure this will be enough to safeguard against failures until I'm under the ground with it and no longer have to worry about failures.

I've dug into building 3D printed spacers for pipe, buying PVC pipe, etc., putting the pipes in, and drilling some holes or filling from one end with urethane, closed-cell foam, Foam-in-Place ideas, etc. I've also tossed around buying the cheaper, (crappier) wrapped pipe, then sticking that whole pipe into larger, sealed PVC (or welded metal piping), etc., and/or making a sealed run from the garage (including coming completely up through the concrete foundations of both after jackhammering it open and then pouring new concrete again in those areas, but I'd like to avoid that. I don't mind *WORK* (right now). I can dig it with equipment owned (as mentioned above), weld, etc. I just feel that I'm missing something in the variables....

If I were in an area where a trench was easily dug (there may be some drilling, feather/wedge work, or some expanding rock breaker involved), OR I was just paying someone to do it and using 1 pipe with both feed and return in it, I would just suck it up, buy the $15+/foot stuff, drop it in, and hope for the best..

Any ideas/advice/experience is appreciated as I'd like to get this aspect done (or at least ordered) for now, dig the trench and do the work while the weather is decent, and have this boiler setup working before this coming (ever-quickly, it seems the older I get) before the cold hits us again.

Thank you all!
 
Other than you supplying the labor there is no shortcut or cheap way of getting a quality set of lines that you don't have to replace.
Cut out buying coffee at your favorite coffee house for a year instead
But don't try to skimp on your lines
 
As someone who has helped dig up and replace the previous bad choice, don't do it!
Buy once cry once is the way!
The time investment is about triple just doing it right the first time, and honestly, so is the money investment...because the whole time you are putting up with inferior performance, the price of the good stuff is tick tick ticking up.
I recommend even with using the good pipe, to put it in a sleeve so that no matter what, you don't have to dig it all up again...if there is a problem, it can be pulled out and addressed.
 
If I remember correctly, there was another person on another site who was losing enough heat through his crappy lines to heat a decent size house. As others have said; buy once, cry once.
 
Last edited:
Encasing the pipes in closed cell foam is simply the only way to get decent performance out of an underground/outdoor run.

Since you want two runs, I'd say foam-in-place is probably the cheapest option that will give you the performance you need.

Talk to a few foam insulation guys and explain what you want to do. It might be cheaper than you think.

Have your trench and pex unrolled ready to go. Line the trench with plastic. Put down a 4" layer of closed cell foam on the plastic, then have the foam guy wait while you lay 4 runs of pex side by side on top of the uncured foam. Then have him go over top of it with another layer of foam, and done.

As you said time is ticking to get a decent ROI, all the more reason not to waste time or money on a crappy setup.
 
Here is the math. It takes 1 BTU to raise 1 lb of water by 1°F, and 1 gallon of water weighs 8.35 lb. If you have a typical-sized house, you are running 10-15 gpm between the house and the boiler. Let's say you lose 3°F from the boiler to the house, and you are moving 10 gpm. That is 600 gallons per hour multiplied by 8.35 lbs, which is 5010 lbs.

That gives you 15,030 BTU/hr loss at a 3-degree drop, every hour! If you have a poorly insulated pipe, you could lose 10 or more degrees!

It is vital that you use good-quality underground insulated pipe!
 
Here is the math. It takes 1 BTU to raise 1 lb of water by 1°F, and 1 gallon of water weighs 8.35 lb. If you have a typical-sized house, you are running 10-15 gpm between the house and the boiler. Let's say you lose 3°F from the boiler to the house, and you are moving 10 gpm. That is 600 gallons per hour multiplied by 8.35 lbs, which is 5010 lbs.

That gives you 15,030 BTU/hr loss at a 3-degree drop, every hour! If you have a poorly insulated pipe, you could lose 10 or more degrees!

It is vital that you use good-quality underground insulated pipe!
Okay, so in late 2016--who are the actual players in the closed-cell-foam, burial PEX market other than building your own?
 
Other than you supplying the labor there is no shortcut or cheap way of getting a quality set of lines that you don't have to replace.
Cut out buying coffee at your favorite coffee house for a year instead
But don't try to skimp on your lines

I don't mind supplying labor. I also understand NOT buying the wrapped, crap-insulated, PEX runs at the cheapest price I can find.

Thermopex (Central Boiler) has long been the mainstay of 'Doing it right', but the pricing (especially with shipping) is getting crazy.

Do it myself, trench it (have a Case 580C on premises, and a frontloader on my Kubota L2050DT), to 'Roll my own with closed-cell, spray foam') or look at other suppliers? I'm not sure who else makes closed-cell, insulated, underground runs at this point.

In a perfect world, I would dig a trench, 90+ feet long, 10 feet wide, and pour a concrete run that I could crawl through in the future/pull new insulated piping through at will, but I'm trying to be reasonable.

Thanks!
 
I don't mind supplying labor. I also understand NOT buying the wrapped, crap-insulated, PEX runs at the cheapest price I can find.

Thermopex (Central Boiler) has long been the mainstay of 'Doing it right', but the pricing (especially with shipping) is getting crazy.

Do it myself, trench it (have a Case 580C on premises, and a frontloader on my Kubota L2050DT), to 'Roll my own with closed-cell, spray foam') or look at other suppliers? I'm not sure who else makes closed-cell, insulated, underground runs at this point.

In a perfect world, I would dig a trench, 90+ feet long, 10 feet wide, and pour a concrete run that I could crawl through in the future/pull new insulated piping through at will, but I'm trying to be reasonable.

Thanks!
Use this link to look up your local HeatMaster dealer...most stock the pipe and it's just like the thermopex, just black instead...that'll save you the shipping, and some have pretty competitive prices...I know there's a dealer in western PA that advertises it for $13/ft...dealer in Ohio advertises it for $15, but will sell for $13...at least so far...I hear prices are going up soon.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: sloeffle and jblnut
Use this link to look up your local HeatMaster dealer...most stock the pipe and it's just like the thermopex, just black instead...that'll save you the shipping, and some have pretty competitive prices...I know there's a dealer in western PA that advertises it for $13/ft...dealer in Ohio advertises it for $15, but will sell for $13...at least so far...I hear prices are going up soon.
I installed the Heatmaster 1-1/4” pipe in 2022 and see a whole 1 degree F drop in a 175’ run (350’ total pex pipe). I have two runs that long from the stove to the buildings and they’re the same. I also was trying to home brew a solution and every solution was over half the cost and three times the hassle of the premade pipe.

I have a neighbor that went the home brew route with his lines a number of years ago and did it like a lot of others have suggested on here over the years. Dig a trench, line with plastic, spray with closed cell foam, lay lines in, spray with more foam, cover with plastic and bury. His spray foam guy was willing to wait around while we laid the lines in but charged by the minute for wait time as he wasn’t making money spraying foam while he waited. All in he was 70% of the cost of the premade pipe and he loses 4f in 100’. Run the numbers on what that equates to in heat lose and you’ll be surprised.

I have seen this Heatmaster line sitting on top of the ground (quick temp install to replace bad lines by a different neighbor) with 180f water going through it and snow sitting on top of it. It’s the real deal.

I’m all in on doing anything I can myself but I forked over the $13/ft and moved on. I have 350’ of the stuff as well so it wasn’t a small purchase …… and I still did it because it makes sense.
 
I installed the Heatmaster 1-1/4” pipe in 2022 and see a whole 1 degree F drop in a 175’ run (350’ total pex pipe). I have two runs that long from the stove to the buildings and they’re the same. I also was trying to home brew a solution and every solution was over half the cost and three times the hassle of the premade pipe.

I have a neighbor that went the home brew route with his lines a number of years ago and did it like a lot of others have suggested on here over the years. Dig a trench, line with plastic, spray with closed cell foam, lay lines in, spray with more foam, cover with plastic and bury. His spray foam guy was willing to wait around while we laid the lines in but charged by the minute for wait time as he wasn’t making money spraying foam while he waited. All in he was 70% of the cost of the premade pipe and he loses 4f in 100’. Run the numbers on what that equates to in heat lose and you’ll be surprised.

I have seen this Heatmaster line sitting on top of the ground (quick temp install to replace bad lines by a different neighbor) with 180f water going through it and snow sitting on top of it. It’s the real deal.

I’m all in on doing anything I can myself but I forked over the $13/ft and moved on. I have 350’ of the stuff as well so it wasn’t a small purchase …… and I still did it because it makes sense.
If I could find closed-cell, insulated 1 1/4" at $13/foot, I'd buy it in a heartbeat.

I called a few places, sent inquiries, and am awaiting replies, but the first place was at around $32/foot landed locally for 1 1/4", and $17/ft for 1" picking up what they have in stock.
 
If I could find closed-cell, insulated 1 1/4" at $13/foot, I'd buy it in a heartbeat.
What part of PA are you in? I tried looking it up and kept getting several different answers for "rock hill"
 
Central Boilers website has 5 dealers within 45 miles of you. Heatmaster has 3 dealers within 100 miles of you. If it were me (and you maybe have already) I’d start there. Someone is bound to have some pipe or can get it in 🤷‍♂️
 
This is in seven valleys pa...looks to be about 100 miles...rehau is good stuff too, just smooth on the outside instead of rippled.
 

Attachments

  • [Hearth.com] Insulated, Underground PEX solutions between buildings....(yet again)
    Screenshot_20261105-071441.webp
    65.9 KB · Views: 22
  • Like
Reactions: DSSA and jblnut
This is in seven valleys pa...looks to be about 100 miles...rehau is good stuff too, just smooth on the outside instead of rippled.
For some reason, I couldn't get his Marketplace listing to come up, but I did text him this evening.

This may be what I was looking for. Another dealer wanted $32.60/ft for 1 1/4" Thermopex.

Thanks!
 
This may be what I was looking for. Another dealer wanted $32.60/ft for 1 1/4" Thermopex.
Hope it works out for you...at $32.60/ft they should be ashamed of themselves! (Were they special ordering it or something?)
 
For a 75' run 1" pipe is more than adequate, why do you feel the need to use 1.25" pipe? You generally only need 1.25 pipe when your runs are over 150' or so and you need to push some serious GPMs (BTUs). Even then you can get away with 1" pipe if you don't need to push a lot of BTUs.

The price jumps significantly when going from 1" to 1.25". If you really need pipe larger than 1" it might be worth looking into Logstor pipe (I think). There's a brand of line that's metric, but standard fittings will work with it and it's a little more reasonably price, well it was, just like everything else.
 
Hope it works out for you...at $32.60/ft they should be ashamed of themselves! (Were they special ordering it or something?)
I picked it up today and have it landed. The guy (Joe) was very nice, and responsive. Picked it up with no surprises or issues.

It is the stiffer, smooth cased version, which will take a little more digging for clean entry/exit from the buildings. He had the convoluted pipe on hand as well, but he told me that he went to the smooth version when it was 1/2 the price of the convoluted jacket type, but now, for some reason it has switched and the smooth-jacketed has now increased.

Happy with the purchase at this point, despite the $90 in fuel and 6 hours of the day spent picking it up.

Thank you again--much appreciated!
 
For a 75' run 1" pipe is more than adequate, why do you feel the need to use 1.25" pipe? You generally only need 1.25 pipe when your runs are over 150' or so and you need to push some serious GPMs (BTUs). Even then you can get away with 1" pipe if you don't need to push a lot of BTUs.

The price jumps significantly when going from 1" to 1.25". If you really need pipe larger than 1" it might be worth looking into Logstor pipe (I think). There's a brand of line that's metric, but standard fittings will work with it and it's a little more reasonably price, well it was, just like everything else.
I bought the 1 1/4" today at $14.50/ft.

The 75' is minimum distance from building to building, not including the curves to get into said buildings from the trench, etc.

The house is a crap-insulated (to today's standards) 3600 sq/ft. 'California Ranch' style house with a full basement (same size), and I'll also be heating my 3200 sq/ft lower garage (also 1986 construction, but insulated as well), our DHW, and a hot tub (each being fed off Amtrol AM WH-7P Boilermates).

The Eko 40 I have is a little undersized for the job, but it's what I have for now. I have an insulated 1100 gallon, pressurized heat reserve tank out in the lower garage as well. I'm looking at adding solar hot water heaters on the garage roof to supplement, and will be replacing the oil-fired furnace out there with a used, smaller, oil-fired boiler to be able to kick it on should we have to leave the property for a length of time during cold weather.

Our property is also located on what is essentially a 800' 'mountain' or 'hill' that was formed where a glacier stopped pushing the crap in front of it (it was named "Rockhill Township" for a very good reason), so this trench kind of needs to be a one-and-done scenario for that. I have a Case 580C that I purchased, thinking "Oh...this will take care of things up here..." and it absolutely hates me as I push it to/past its limits every time I have to dig, and a lot of times, I have to split rocks several times and be creative to even make-do then (we have some boulders here that are the size of VW buses..

I would have loved to have gone to 1 1/2" just to be REALLY safe, but 1 1/4" was what I could find--I'm not working with infinite funds.
 
  • Like
Reactions: sloeffle
I picked it up today and have it landed. The guy (Joe) was very nice, and responsive. Picked it up with no surprises or issues.

It is the stiffer, smooth cased version, which will take a little more digging for clean entry/exit from the buildings. He had the convoluted pipe on hand as well, but he told me that he went to the smooth version when it was 1/2 the price of the convoluted jacket type, but now, for some reason it has switched and the smooth-jacketed has now increased.

Happy with the purchase at this point, despite the $90 in fuel and 6 hours of the day spent picking it up.

Thank you again--much appreciated!
You're welcome, glad to hear it worked out! $14.50 for 1.25" sounds like a good deal!
Our closest HeatMaster dealer advertises the "HeatMaster" brand 1" pipe for $15/ft, but will sell it for $13 if you chat him up a lil...or buy a few other things from him.
Pretty likable "good ole boy" his is...
 
  • Like
Reactions: sloeffle
Agreed, that's a good deal. I think I paid around that for 1" pipe from Heatmaster four of five years ago. Definitely sounds like you'll be pushing a lot of BTU's so 1.25" line is probably a little better. It's crazy how going .25" bigger you can almost double the volume of water. That circulator won't be cheap to buy or run.