Is this an Elm?
- Thread starter DonTee
- Start date
-
Active since 1995, Hearth.com is THE place on the internet for free information and advice about wood stoves, pellet stoves and other energy saving equipment.
We strive to provide opinions, articles, discussions and history related to Hearth Products and in a more general sense, energy issues.
We promote the EFFICIENT, RESPONSIBLE, CLEAN and SAFE use of all fuels, whether renewable or fossil. -
Super Cedar firestarters 30% discount Use code Hearth2024 Click here
![[Hearth.com] Is this an Elm?](https://www.hearth.com/talk/data/attachments/296/296815-9124251160233b242230e4bc4602b692.jpg?hash=ueVBB1draQ "[Hearth.com] Is this an Elm?")
Hmm interesting. I saw another one in the woods, and there were some nuts around it. I didn’t look too closely, but I’ll have to go check it out again. They could be oak, beech, or hickory nuts I saw also.
CincyBurner
Minister of Fire
Three species of true chestnut (Castanea) commonly growing in U.S.
I'm going with American chestnut (Castanea dentata), especially if form of OP's specimen is straight and tall.
Once a grand, massive, tall, upright spreading tree whose mast fed forests of wildlife (deer and turkey) and man, the Endothia pathogen introduced to American forests in early 20th century decimated its chestnut populations, and reduced remaining American chestnut trees to stunted specimens often re-sprouting from the stump, and that have been relegated to a shrub/ small tree curiosity. Sad. Too bad. I would have loved to has seen US chestnut/ oak forests.
I'm going with American chestnut (Castanea dentata), especially if form of OP's specimen is straight and tall.
- Leaf too large for Alleghany chinkapin (C. pumila), and it's a shrub. It's a rare curiosity in PA and problably even rarer in upstate NY.
- Chinese chestnut (C. mollissima) more common in landscape areas. It has poor form - irregular habit/ multi-stem, grows up to 40'. Not as susceptible to chestnut blight (Endothia parasitica). Its leaves have a shinier top than American chestnut. The wet leaves from OP make it tough to tell.
- American chestnut (C. dentata) - Larger leaf, with regular dentitions, more strongly toothed than Chinese chestnut
Once a grand, massive, tall, upright spreading tree whose mast fed forests of wildlife (deer and turkey) and man, the Endothia pathogen introduced to American forests in early 20th century decimated its chestnut populations, and reduced remaining American chestnut trees to stunted specimens often re-sprouting from the stump, and that have been relegated to a shrub/ small tree curiosity. Sad. Too bad. I would have loved to has seen US chestnut/ oak forests.
I’ll have to look closer at the bark of this tree tomorrow. It’s right behind my house.
Honestly it might be one of the stump sprouted trees back there. I had to cut down some trees when we built the house 10 years ago. Some oak and maples stump sprouted. I honestly didn’t know that was possible until I saw it here. I looked it up and sure enough it’s common.
This particular tree would have been very small when I built the house ten years ago. Now it’s almost as tall as the house
Honestly it might be one of the stump sprouted trees back there. I had to cut down some trees when we built the house 10 years ago. Some oak and maples stump sprouted. I honestly didn’t know that was possible until I saw it here. I looked it up and sure enough it’s common.
This particular tree would have been very small when I built the house ten years ago. Now it’s almost as tall as the house
I have some acreage here that’s been in the family a long time. I try to manage the forest well, and don’t take out any mast trees unless they’re fallen or already dead. The only exceptions would be a tree that might fall on the house etc.
There’s a giant red oak tree that split in half about five years ago. Half ended up on the ground and the other half is still standing. I’ve been waiting for the other half to fall, but it hasn’t. It’s still alive and producing acorns, so I’m not going to cut it down.
There’s a giant red oak tree that split in half about five years ago. Half ended up on the ground and the other half is still standing. I’ve been waiting for the other half to fall, but it hasn’t. It’s still alive and producing acorns, so I’m not going to cut it down.
hickoryhoarder
Minister of Fire
Chestnut, yes.
Could be some other chestnut, but I'd say American.
I've seen quite a few American chestnut in PA and NY, but the ones I saw were always 15 years old or less.
Could be some other chestnut, but I'd say American.
I've seen quite a few American chestnut in PA and NY, but the ones I saw were always 15 years old or less.
Last edited:
So the chestnut nut has the little furry looking (I want to call it a sack for lack of a better term. Lol) casing it grows in? How old is the tree when it starts producing nuts?
The American chestnut tree generally begins to produce nuts at around 8-10 years old. The chestnuts grow in clusters of spiny green husks, each containing about three nuts. They mature in late September or early October and begin to fall to the ground when they are ready to harvest.
With the point of your phone an app called Seek identifies an amazing number of plants and trees. Coincidentally I first saw it used to Identify a giant elm in Castine Maine, from a leaf on the ground. Found out that Castine makes preserving its many Elms a priority. 300 elms were saved from being wiped out there from Dutch elm disease by the development of a vaccine by a U Maine professor.
