Yeah change that out for sure no way it will seal right. I really prefer the olympia one the safe-t-thimble works fine the olympia one is just much easier to installThe reason I have to change the clean out door is whoever built the chimney put in a fireplace ash door instead of a clean out door. I'll have to pull it and cut it out a little more to put in an actual clean out door. I do appreciate all the responses I've got from everyone. It's helped out a lot. Looks like the sat-t-thimble or the Olympia wall thimble are two options I'm going to look at for this. I'm gonna look into them both some more and see when I can have the chimney sweep come out. When I called the ther day it would be into December before he could make it out. So once he comes to check the chimney for safety I'll ask him about my plan. I'll be having them come back out after I do the install to do an installation inspection for insurance and make sure everything is good.