Old house new fire advice

  • Active since 1995, Hearth.com is THE place on the internet for free information and advice about wood stoves, pellet stoves and other energy saving equipment.

    We strive to provide opinions, articles, discussions and history related to Hearth Products and in a more general sense, energy issues.

    We promote the EFFICIENT, RESPONSIBLE, CLEAN and SAFE use of all fuels, whether renewable or fossil.

Usurper

New Member
Mar 6, 2023
33
Alabama. USA
Hi all,
I am looking for advice, my wife and i just moved to a new "fixer upper" and although at first we were going to not have a wood fire in this place, one cool ish day made us miss our old fire. i have attached some photos which i hope show what i am dealing with/trying to explain.
there was a big old wood burning stove there which i took out as the back where the vent/flue goes is all rotted. ( 1st 2 photos ).
the outside brick chimney appears to have a rotten collapsing liner, which maybe insulated ( photos 3 and 4 ) as there is a wooden hatch to gain access to it. we wish to install a fairly small free standing wood burning stove, so my question is what sort of flue/chimney pipe i should be looking at.
any guidance would be appreciated, and i apologize in advance for what maybe stupid questions.
thank you.
334904112_592340412470658_8913832931547774934_n.jpg
334952225_919477499098435_6857513338247052235_n.jpg
334918013_166402082869352_1414243731609822574_n.jpg
335047590_904551897530999_8378051955184319540_n.jpg
 
Looks like something homebuilt that may have put black stove pipe inside of an old metal chimney. Hard to tell, but what is clear is that it all needs to be torn out and replaced with a proper insulated liner.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Usurper
Looks like something homebuilt that may have put black stove pipe inside of an old metal chimney. Hard to tell, but what is clear is that it all needs to be torn out and replaced with a proper insulated liner.
That was my thinking once i got over the shock of seeing what i can see in the chinmey, i do not suppose you or anyone could point me in the right direction for the appropriate insulated liner please?
 
Rockford Chimney sells good products. Once the current mess is all removed the options should be clearer.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Usurper
I’d actually typed this out and not clicked post.
Very thankful for the reply as it seems like the solution.

i admit i am getting ahead of myself as we do not have a fire yet, but i am just trying to budget everything out
 
Start from scratch, including the stove. Assume nothing was done right, even the pass-through. You'll have a more satisfying and peaceful result knowing all is in order.
 
Start from scratch, including the stove. Assume nothing was done right, even the pass-through. You'll have a more satisfying and peaceful result knowing all is in order.
Yeah new stove and new chimney is the plan I just wanted to make sure I’m doing it right. I have no issues with some hard work as long as I am doing things correct :)
 
It's a fairly short chimney, so pick an easy breathing stove as a replacement.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Usurper
It's a fairly short chimney, so pick an easy breathing stove as a replacement.
Thank you, i am actually looking forward to starting this as soon as some more pressing issues are fixed. i think the top of the chimney cowl ( metal shroud thing ) is around 15ft from the opening where the back of the fire will be.
 
Thank you, i am actually looking forward to starting this as soon as some more pressing issues are fixed. i think the top of the chimney cowl ( metal shroud thing ) is around 15ft from the opening where the back of the fire will be.
That's not bad. I think you might need a prefab chimney in there. (It looks like that is what you had) but it's hard to tell without being onsite
 
Is the wood in top the last picture part of the door or is more integral framing to the chimney?
 
Because I have no idea what it means 😔
Haha ok. To me it looks like you currently have what's left of a metal multi layer chimney in a brick chase. If that chance is actually a full masonry chimney just without a liner you may be able to just install an insulated liner and brick that door shut. But we can't really see everything from your pics. And you won't be able to until you pull out what's there.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Usurper
And what is that other steel pipe(flue?) for? That's on it's last leg. Since you have combustibles near by you'll probably need a class A chimney system, i like Selkirk. If you don't know what you need to do you probably want to reach out to the local building inspector to see what he'll require. You're whole setup needs to meet the local building codes so if you dont know those, you need to learn them.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Usurper
Is there a furnace in the basement. That second pipe might be the furnace flue pipe
 
  • Like
Reactions: Usurper
My two cents, unless you love the look of the chimney, tie a cable to it and yank it off the side of the building. It would be helpful if you changed your signature to show what part of the country you are in as it may impact suggestions. It looks like an add on to me that had draft issues, therefore the ugly sheet metal extension piece. it looks like a one story building in that area so consider relocating the stove closer to the ridge pole up the roof and doing a straight up shot from the stove up through an attic and through the roof with proper roof transition, the manufacturers have some slick systesm that if installed to their instructions do not leak. Unless someone was a pro at flashing, it is likely that there are leaks between the chimney and the house as that is a tough place to flash as any rain coming down off the roof gets some velocity to it before it hits the bricks and eventually finds its way inside the wall. At a minimum consider a "cricket" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cricket_(roofing) on the roof to split the flow around the chimney. My guess is that brickwork behind the stove is covering some "sins" and rot. Odds are the place has minimal insulation so opening up the walls, cleaning up any rot and reinsulating is money well spent. Unless you love the look of that wall of brick you can look for a new stove with a rear heat shield with shallower rear clearance and take up less space.

BTW, please destroy that stove, if it is what I think it is, its just a sheetmetal combustion chamber that was way to thin when it came out of the box, dont let someone else burn their house down with it.
 
Do not just pull the chimney down. Removal may be the best option we just don't know at this point. But pulling it down has huge risks to the structure of the house
 
My two cents, unless you love the look of the chimney, tie a cable to it and yank it off the side of the building. It would be helpful if you changed your signature to show what part of the country you are in as it may impact suggestions. It looks like an add on to me that had draft issues, therefore the ugly sheet metal extension piece. it looks like a one story building in that area so consider relocating the stove closer to the ridge pole up the roof and doing a straight up shot from the stove up through an attic and through the roof with proper roof transition, the manufacturers have some slick systesm that if installed to their instructions do not leak. Unless someone was a pro at flashing, it is likely that there are leaks between the chimney and the house as that is a tough place to flash as any rain coming down off the roof gets some velocity to it before it hits the bricks and eventually finds its way inside the wall. At a minimum consider a "cricket" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cricket_(roofing) on the roof to split the flow around the chimney. My guess is that brickwork behind the stove is covering some "sins" and rot. Odds are the place has minimal insulation so opening up the walls, cleaning up any rot and reinsulating is money well spent. Unless you love the look of that wall of brick you can look for a new stove with a rear heat shield with shallower rear clearance and take up less space.

BTW, please destroy that stove, if it is what I think it is, its just a sheetmetal combustion chamber that was way to thin when it came out of the box, dont let someone else burn their house down with it.
It appears you were dead on the money, the fire surround was leaning forward so after putting out proverbial fires elsewhere in the house, today i got back to the fire and took down the brick, only to find there is literally NOTHING between the chimney and outside wood siding. water has been pouring in rotting the beam and sub floor. i am all kinds of fried mentally now, we moved into all sorts of issues we were not aware of that the inspector missed or happened post inspection. i do not know what to do from here to be perfectly honest.
336480665_1259821111639048_8354292520364499047_n.jpg
336596563_1632569540503051_2713258556574850333_n.jpg
336238277_1350718098819884_1016922141075017754_n.jpg
 
Last edited:
If the Inspector missed glaring defects you might have a case against them. I would check the inspection contract to see what it says. A call to a lawyer might be appropriate. At a minimum a bad Review about the missed Major Defect should be posted online.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Usurper
If the Inspector missed glaring defects you might have a case against them. I would check the inspection contract to see what it says. A call to a lawyer might be appropriate. At a minimum a bad Review about the missed Major Defect should be posted online.
He missed all sorts of things, he was recommended to us, but i am sure there is probably some small print that exonerates him. We are almost out of money already and now this chimney issue. :(


EDIT : contract states at the bottom.
"The home inspection is based on the observations made on the date of the inspection, and not a prediction of future conditions. The home inspection will not reveal every issue that exists or ever could exist, but only those material defects observed on the date of the inspection. "