Flue Bug said:
The garage is unnattached and no flammables are kept in it (basically just a woodshop) All flammables and what not are located in the garage attached to the house.
ga·rage Pronunciation (g-räzh, -räj)
n.
1. A building or indoor space in which to park or keep a motor vehicle.
2. A commercial establishment where cars are repaired, serviced, or parked.
....He has the final word.
Actually, the discussion is quite useful and valid. There is no "HE" that has the final word. The whole reason for most fire codes is so that one does not endanger human life. Secondary reasons are property, etc. but that does not figure as highly as human life.
IMHO, the gentleman has an outbuilding....plain and simple. He also did not ask us how many various authorities he should see about his stove. He asked about the proper chimney and I think we led him in the right direction with both that and with the safety issue of attached garages or other places that house cars and flammables.
If, for some strange reason, my local inspector said that an outbuilding was a garage (and it was not) - I would first question him, then I would go right up the chain of command. Sometimes the state can help, others times an appeal board.
However, in this case I didn't even hear the gentleman ask about permits, etc. This is 150% his business. Many jurisdictions would not even require a permit for certain outbuilding mods.
I've seem good building inspectors and I've seen bad ones. One thing for sure about government, ask enough people and the answer is always NO. It's easier that way! Only once did I have to go to the board of appeals for the building official - it was for a oil/wood boiler. The appeals panel laughed that building inspector right out of the hearing and they told him not to stop at the bar on the way home!
Leave it up to the government and eventually all wood stoves will be illegal, as will chain saws and anything else that is dangerous and causes less oil to be burned.
I have figured out the perfect way to make certain everyone is 100% safe with their wood, gas and pellet stoves:
DON'T INSTALL ONE.....
Of course, then the electric and LP heaters will be burning down the houses and outbuildings.