Ray,
I agonized for two yrs with the gasket falling off, the rutland cement that came with the first Tractor Supply Kit I purchased was clear, and would not last but a cpl weeks, it would actually "foam" out a couple days after replacing it and curing it, then it would turn brittle white and crumble.
I looked and found another rutland kit that had black adhesive, that was rated to a much higher temp than the original kit with the clear cement. I took off the door, took out the old gasket, and cleaned with a wire brush, used the new much thicker black adhesive, and replaced with a new gasket (not the OEM with the peel tape). And it lasted the last yr no problems. Look at the temp rating of whatever it is you buy, buy the highest temp possible. I think the black stuff was 2000 and the clear 500 ->1000 - don't quote me on that, but peruse the rutland site and you can find the specs of the different types of adhesive that they sell.
do yourself a favor, take off the door to redo the job. it was not that hard to do with the door laying on the floor. hardest part was remounting the door by myself - a second pair of hands would make it much easier to mount.
you will have to wait til the next burning season as both require curing with the stove burning.