permanent thread for rating and reviewing pellets

sorry but i haven't seen any bickering . i belong to way over a dozen forums and they are an exchange of different opinions . sorry if you feel that people will post opinions different than yours and be a bad thing

dang so we can or cannot bicker ?

"i need MWP for my bunghole!"

Where were you guys when Pellets, Pellets, Pellets was going on? That was a little intense.

It ain't bickering if you are providing our experiences and the two do not agree.

Case in point if one party is yelping about such and such being high ash and another party is praising the same such and such as being low ash you might want to ask a few dozen questions of both parties starting with what is the picture on the bag, this may lead you to discover one of those parties has 5 year old stock he got from a salvage place and the other has something made day before yesterday.

Just sayin'.

And yes BB likely you bicker as well .

ok this is getting way to civil ! i say we lite ignitors at dawn

I'd prefer something with a bit more expressiveness say flamethrowers at midnight?

What's the difference between bikering and bickering? Auto correct maybe...

Actually the bickering is sometimes rather fun! For some it depends on how thick your skin is.

Perhaps we could rated the pellets we have tried an a scale of 1 to 10 and the pellet list would adjust with the top rated pellets down. A second list would have to be alphabetical and from there our comments on the specific brands could be posted. Any bets on number 1? Barefoot premium?

With enough ratings and comments the occasional "way off review" would be minimized and a reasonable picture would emerge. If 1 person hates a pellet and 20 love it I would risk a purchase.

That would be regional. Bear Mountains would be number one here.

Of course its a good idea; but only from a starting point. There are so many variables, as already stated, year to year manuf pellets change, and even from the same manuf, but produced at different plants/locations can result in a completely different product. But the idea is good because competition is always healthy for the consumer price wise, and without 'outside interference', will usually allow the consistently better quality product to rise to the top.

lol , perfect answer . pleasure to meet you JT . actually i wasn't sure if you were serious or your replies were tongue in cheek .

cheers Woody

bump

Think this needs another bump!

IHATPROPANE, Where the heck is the thread where you compared a few brands? I need to see that again!

If we've got a sticky pinned at the top of our Pellet Mill home page pertaining to Pellet Pricing Reports (which are at best only relevant to particular periods of time in particular areas) wouldn't it make a load of sense to have a sticky which lets us chime-in with our personal experience and ratings on these pellets, which would in-turn apply to a much more broad spectrum of board members here?

Webbie, you out there???