Comfortbilt HP22 VS Harman P61 I need help.

  • Active since 1995, Hearth.com is THE place on the internet for free information and advice about wood stoves, pellet stoves and other energy saving equipment.

    We strive to provide opinions, articles, discussions and history related to Hearth Products and in a more general sense, energy issues.

    We promote the EFFICIENT, RESPONSIBLE, CLEAN and SAFE use of all fuels, whether renewable or fossil.

Joe.G

Burning Hunk
Jan 21, 2018
122
NY
Hi I have a Volgerzang 5790 now and I am having some issues with it and can't seem to figure it out I have used it as a sole heat source for 12 years. I am thinking of replacing it with a HP 22 or the P61. I need it to heat about 2600 SQ heat which current stove does without issue.
I know Harman is the gold standard but is it worth double of the HP22? Would they both heat the same or better than the 5790?

Thanks
 
I wouldn't "through in the towel" with your present stove so quick. Seeing it has done the job for 12 years.

Quick search there seems to be parts available for it:


As for your options: Made in China, HP22 or Made in USA Harman. The choice is obvious to me. I have two Harman's, P68 bought new @ 19 years, and a P38 bought used @ 15 years. Never let me down, parts available and I can fix.

I know It's your only source of heat and winter is here, so you don't have time to waste.

Tom
 
  • Like
Reactions: Joe.G and Washed-Up
If you tell us what the problem is with your stove, we, as a group, may be able to help you.
Repairing a known stove is a lot less expensive than buying a new Harman . Here is what is said about the
HP 22 as a total unit. Harman makes a good overpriced stove . Search the forum, and you will find more
running problems with a Harman than any other stove. They can be hard to set to what you want and
seem overcomplicated to me. The HP22




[Hearth.com] Comfortbilt HP22 VS Harman P61 I need help.

ComfortBilt HP22 pellet stoves are assembled in Ningbo, China, using parts sourced from Europe, North America, and South America, followed by a 24-point inspection upon arrival. [1]

Manufacturing & Inspection Details
    • Sourced Components: Uses parts from North America (including the U.S.), Europe (such as France and Germany), and South America. [1, 2]
    • Quality Check: ComfortBilt's inspection team performs a 24-point inspection checking motors, switches, ignition, and airflow performance before distribution. [1]
    • Certifications: The HP22 is EPA and CSA certified. [1]
More technical specs and manuals are available on the ComfortBilt HP22 Resource Center, and product listings appear on The Home Depot and ComfortBilt. [1, 2, 3]
 
  • Like
Reactions: Washed-Up
Current stove has been fighting me with a low flame on low and either going out or really getting the glass full of creosote, I have replaced room blower, Auger shaft,auger motor ( Tired a 1 RPM and 1.5 RPM ) ,auger bushing. Stove is spotless. I tried different pellets. Last night I replaced the door gasket and combustion motor. it seems to be burning a little better, still a low flame but not going out and only getting a little black on the lower edges of the glass.
Burning issues started end of last season. I have spent a lot of time messing with the stove this season and just getting tired of doing so. Hopefully I am on the right track at the moment.