To provide a humble, but dissenting, opinion. I'm on week 2 of burning in a Drolet Baltic (3.1 cf), and couldn't be happier, with this stove. $1000 got me a well designed, if basic stove. It's extremely easy to control, and has full shielding, a useful bypass feature, and an excellent air wash to keep the glass clean. Got a seven hour burn, on a 3/4 load of pine, this morning, keeping my 1,500 square ft., 1923 story-and-a-half at 69-74 degrees, with an outside temp of -2* F.
It's not a beauty, and in fact, it's basic and minimalist aesthetic is part of its charm, for me. It has no fancy automated air controls, but it's so darned easy to use that my wife, who's never touched a wood stove, figured it out by trial and error over the course of a weekend. I regularly burn at 600* F, stovetop (just coming down from such a burn, now), and the 5/16" flat top has no discernible warping. To each his own, and I like the heavier, prettier, and more complicated stoves, too. But, for a basic, capable, and easy to use unit, I don't think one could ask for better. Knowing my nature, this will likely end up as my 'starter stove', but I wouldn't be afraid of keeping it for many years, if needs be.
Again, just one guys opinion. Others my differ, but my own Drolet has surpassed expectations.