Ever seen a totally open fireplace?

[Heatman]

I’m in the process of making an offer on a house, and this place is cool in a 70s funky kind of way. Has anybody seen a totally open fireplace like this? Is something like this even safe and viable?

I saw photos of the house from 20 years ago, and at some point there was a wood-burning stove there, but it looks like this chimney was built as a real wood-burning fireplace. Then again I don’t really know anything about fireplaces.

Has anybody seen a design like this before?

I’m tempted to buy one of those double sided wood stoves and install it.

 

[bholler]

View attachment 265860

I’m in the process of making an offer on a house, and this place is cool in a 70s funky kind of way. Has anybody seen a totally open fireplace like this? Is something like this even safe and viable?

I saw photos of the house from 20 years ago, and at some point there was a wood-burning stove there, but it looks like this chimney was built as a real wood-burning fireplace. Then again I don’t really know anything about fireplaces.

Has anybody seen a design like this before?

I’m tempted to buy one of those double sided wood stoves and install it.

I have seen them and they rarely work

 

[Heatman]

I have seen them and they rarely work

I'm guessing the reasons for this are fairly obvious, but would you mind elaborating on what the main reasons for this are, and if they can be updated or modified that would enable it to be a functional fireplace?

 

[bholler]

I'm guessing the reasons for this are fairly obvious, but would you mind elaborating on what the main reasons for this are, and if they can be updated or modified that would enable it to be a functional fireplace?

There typically is nowhere near enough volume in the flue for the volume of air allowed in by being open on 4 sides.

 

[Heatman]

There typically is nowhere near enough volume in the flue for the volume of air allowed in by being open on 4 sides.

Thanks for the feedback. One more question if you don’t mind. You can see that a wood stove was installed at one point in the house's prior history. Do you think it would be viable to reinstall a new double sided wood stove?

I would hate to have this huge centerpiece fireplace that’s purely decorative.

 

[bholler]

Thanks for the feedback. One more question if you don’t mind. You can see that a wood stove was installed at one point in the house's prior history. Do you think it would be viable to reinstall a new double sided wood stove?

I would hate to have this huge centerpiece fireplace that’s purely decorative.

View attachment 265872

if you can find a double-sided stove sure

 

[begreen]

Supreme makes one. It has mixed reviews, with complaints about smoke spillage.

Supreme - VISION

supremem.com

and some local commentary

Any Supreme Vision owners or installers?

We have a sun room that opens into the living room. The wife asked for a wood stove to separate the two and give the sun room a little kick in the winter. Looks like the only double sided stove is the Supreme Vision. Anyone have comments on it? Never seen a stainless stove. Don't need it as a...

www.hearth.com

There is also this stove, though I know nothing about it. Not sure where one would buy it, but it may be worth asking them.

Aaron Cast Iron Stove - Invicta

Designed with two front sides, it's easy to find the perfect spot for your new Aaron fireplace. This stove is ideal for large logs and offers a stunning panoramic view of its flames. Simply place it on a raw material such as stone or on one of its benches (sold separately). Bench available in 2...

www.invicta.fr

 

[Heatman]

Supreme makes one. It has mixed reviews, with complaints about smoke spillage.

Supreme - VISION

supremem.com

and some local commentary

Any Supreme Vision owners or installers?

We have a sun room that opens into the living room. The wife asked for a wood stove to separate the two and give the sun room a little kick in the winter. Looks like the only double sided stove is the Supreme Vision. Anyone have comments on it? Never seen a stainless stove. Don't need it as a...

www.hearth.com

There is also this stove, though I know nothing about it. Not sure where one would buy it, but it may be worth asking them.

Aaron Cast Iron Stove - Invicta

Designed with two front sides, it's easy to find the perfect spot for your new Aaron fireplace. This stove is ideal for large logs and offers a stunning panoramic view of its flames. Simply place it on a raw material such as stone or on one of its benches (sold separately). Bench available in 2...

www.invicta.fr

Thanks, I'll look into these 2 units.

I'm obviously total beginner when it comes to fireplaces, but I could in theory modify the existing fireplaces by walling off 2-3 sides to make it viable? I'll of course be consulting with local experts if/when I close on the house, but I'm hoping to have some kind of an idea of what I might be in for.

Anyone else have experience with an open indoor fireplace?

 

[Dustin]

Thanks, I'll look into these 2 units.

I'm obviously total beginner when it comes to fireplaces, but I could in theory modify the existing fireplaces by walling off 2-3 sides to make it viable? I'll of course be consulting with local experts if/when I close on the house, but I'm hoping to have some kind of an idea of what I might be in for.

Anyone else have experience with an open indoor fireplace?

Not that open, but in my first house I had two “regular” open fireplaces. I was young and under the impression is was going to heat my house with open fireplaces.

Absolutely worthless for anything other than “hey that looks neat”

is your plan to heat? If it is, put a stove in it. If the plan is to just have it be pretty, I would put in a double sided gas fireplace of some kind

 

[Mech e]

I love it. Who cares if it is practical, it looks cool. Maybe have some glass panels fabricated that could be attached to the verticals to maintain the look. Custom hinges to allow swing out on two sides for access and cleaning.

Slim fitting ankle high slacks seem to be back in style. Get a pair of those to wear around the house and you are good to go.

 

[Heatman]

Not that open, but in my first house I had two “regular” open fireplaces. I was young and under the impression is was going to heat my house with open fireplaces.

Absolutely worthless for anything other than “hey that looks neat”

is your plan to heat? If it is, put a stove in it. If the plan is to just have it be pretty, I would put in a double sided gas fireplace of some kind

can't I go for hot AND pretty?
I think a double sided wood stove would actually be quite cool, although pretty expensive.

I love it. Who cares if it is practical, it looks cool. Maybe have some glass panels fabricated that could be attached to the verticals to maintain the look. Custom hinges to allow swing out on two sides for access and cleaning.

Slim fitting ankle high slacks seem to be back in style. Get a pair of those to wear around the house and you are good to go.

I'm totally going to be listening to Steely Dan on vinyl next to the fireplace, if I can get it working.

 

[EbS-P]

I think a round fire pit burner would look great with the crushed glass, if you have a functioning damper. Other option if you don’t want Gas is an alchohol burner. I arranged 3 smaller ones of this brand and was very happy for several years. https://www.ignisproducts.com/ethanol-fireplace-burners.html/. They claim vent free operation but I don’t think that’s a great idea. The burners are roughly 5,000 BTUs per foot of length. Ethanol is relatively expensive but my wood stove install cost me $5,000 and $500 buys a lot of ethanol.

I don’t like the look of the woodstove as much as the more open appearance if you decision is aesthetically motivated. If you want heat woodstove is the way to go. Personally I would pick design over double sided.
The PE Neo came to mind. No clue if it will fit.

Not that open, but in my first house I had two “regular” open fireplaces. I was young and under the impression is was going to heat my house with open fireplaces.

Absolutely worthless for anything other than “hey that looks neat”

is your plan to heat? If it is, put a stove in it. If the plan is to just have it be pretty, I would put in a double sided gas fireplace of some kind

 

[Heatman]

I think a round fire pit burner would look great with the crushed glass, if you have a functioning damper. Other option if you don’t want Gas is an alchohol burner. I arranged 3 smaller ones of this brand and was very happy for several years. https://www.ignisproducts.com/ethanol-fireplace-burners.html/. They claim vent free operation but I don’t think that’s a great idea. The burners are roughly 5,000 BTUs per foot of length. Ethanol is relatively expensive but my wood stove install cost me $5,000 and $500 buys a lot of ethanol.

I don’t like the look of the woodstove as much as the more open appearance if you decision is aesthetically motivated. If you want heat woodstove is the way to go. Personally I would pick design over double sided.
The PE Neo came to mind. No clue if it will fit.

Thanks, appreciate the feedback. I'm curious, is there a specific reason why you would steer away from a double sided stove?

 

[EbS-P]

Thanks, appreciate the feedback. I'm curious, is there a specific reason why you would steer away from a double sided stove?

No. The only thing I know about them is what I’ve read here on the forums. If I had come up with one is that loading the stove could be kinda awkward if the doors are very far back under the top edge. I don’t have good sense of the fireplaces dimensions and know nothing about the dimensions of a possible stove. With a traditional stove you could set it up In a way that the front of the stove was close a front top edge so you don’t have to crawl back under to get a log in the very back/front.

My last piece of completely unsolicited advice is really embrace what is there. We had lots of conversations about how to change our over 6’ wide pink sandstone fireplace. Tile it over, paint it ect. In the end we left it alone and made it center piece of the room just as it was in 1967. That fireplace with its four posts and clear sight line is really something eye catching.

 

[St. Coemgen]

Yes, there was a totally open fireplace in the original Pink Panther film (and I have seen the real thing (i.e. open fireplaces) in Switzerland as well).



As a replacement, there are custom and retail efficient sealed alternatives that can give four sided views of the fire. But such an option may not be permitted in your area due to local regulations.

Simply as an example:

Huelva

Output: 16kW Efficiency: 76% Heating capacity: 400m3 Metallic inside Manufactured in cast iron & sheet steel Weight: 159kg Outlet: 200mm Removable cast iron grill Height adjustable flue cover...

www.4sidedstove.com

Hope this helps.

 

[Easy Livin’ 3000]

I like it, aesthetically. I'd find a free standing stove (if one will fit) and throw it in there, with a chimney liner and block off plate to keep the heat in the house. Dress up the view from the back with perhaps a painted piece of sheet metal and other hearth appropriate decor. I'd see this as attractive feature on a house. I'm sure many others would feel differently.

I recommended this to a neighbor with a similar fireplace (only open on two sides), tons of free wood, and two boys to help with the wood work. Instead, he installed a pellet stove in the basement that requires purchasing pellets from 30 miles away. They usually have one or two smokey fires in the open fireplace each season for ambiance, then remember that it's dirty, smokey, and sucks more heat out of the house through the draft than it replaces with the radiant heat of the fire. The boys sit inside and play "video games" and watch tic toc videos.

 

[Heatman]

Yes, there was a totally open fireplace in the original Pink Panther film (and I have seen the real thing (i.e. open fireplaces) in Switzerland as well).



As a replacement, there are custom and retail efficient sealed alternatives that can give four sided views of the fire. But such an option may not be permitted in your area due to local regulations.

Simply as an example:

Huelva

Output: 16kW Efficiency: 76% Heating capacity: 400m3 Metallic inside Manufactured in cast iron & sheet steel Weight: 159kg Outlet: 200mm Removable cast iron grill Height adjustable flue cover...

www.4sidedstove.com

Hope this helps.

I like it, aesthetically. I'd find a free standing stove (if one will fit) and throw it in there, with a chimney liner and block off plate to keep the heat in the house. Dress up the view from the back with perhaps a painted piece of sheet metal and other hearth appropriate decor. I'd see this as attractive feature on a house. I'm sure many others would feel differently.

Thank you both for the feedback.
If I end up closing on the house (pending inspection), I'll bring in a fireplace expert to help determine if this could be used as a traditional fireplace with little to no modification, and if it can’t, I’ll seriously consider installing a woodstove.