Is Your Cold Air Return Vent Chilling You Out?

  • Active since 1995, Hearth.com is THE place on the internet for free information and advice about wood stoves, pellet stoves and other energy saving equipment.

    We strive to provide opinions, articles, discussions and history related to Hearth Products and in a more general sense, energy issues.

    We promote the EFFICIENT, RESPONSIBLE, CLEAN and SAFE use of all fuels, whether renewable or fossil.
  • Hope everyone has a wonderful and warm Thanksgiving!
  • Super Cedar firestarters 30% discount Use code Hearth2024 Click here
Status
Not open for further replies.

Nick Mystic

Minister of Fire
Feb 12, 2013
1,142
Western North Carolina
We have been having a stretch of below freezing temperatures here in western NC for a number of days now. Our home has a main level of about 1500 sq. ft. where our Jotul F600 is located in the living room. The lower level of the house is another 1200 sq. ft. where a Woodstock Classic is located. There is an open staircase between the two levels. For the most part we spend most of our time upstairs in the winter and do not heat the lower level where it will stay around 55 F while the upstairs will be around 72 F.

Last night my wife mentioned to me that she was covering up the floor register in her bathroom because she felt a cold draft coming in through it. We have a propane forced air heating system, but we don't use it; we heat exclusively with wood. The cold air return in the lower level is sealed off, but the large cold air return in the living room floor is open. After my wife made her comment I took my IR thermometer and did a check on our heating/AC registers. I recorded temperatures about 3 degrees cooler over the registers than the surrounding laminate floor. However, when I took a reading over the large cold air return in the living room floor it read 53 F! I put my hand over the vent and was surprised to feel a cold draft blowing up through the vent.

I had never bothered sealing this cold air return because I wrongly assumed any air flow would be going from upstairs where it is warm to the downstairs where it is cold. Since cold air sinks and hot air rises I figured the air current would be from warm to cold. However, the air was flowing in the opposite direction and the cold downstairs air was rising up into the heated part of the house. I covered the vent with some books for the time being until I can make a more elegant cover for the vent. So, if you have similarly open cold air return vents you might want to do a temperature check and see if you are getting cold air coming through them.
 
I apologize ahead of time for asking a somewhat dumb question, but is it possible you have the thermostat on the furnace set to On or Circulate for the fan? That would move air through the registers, though from what you explained you have cold air coming out of the return grate. That wouldn't happen with the furnace fan running.
 
No, the furnace is completely shut down. I turned the power off to the unit so I can't turn on the air circulating fan without going down to the furnace and turning the juice back on. One hypothesis might be that the wood stove is sucking air (no OAK) out of the living room and the slight vacuum is pulling air up through the path of least resistance, which would be the cold air return vent, which measures about 16" x 12".
 
That's a reasonable hypothesis. Is the ductwork sealed and insulated?
 
No, the furnace is completely shut down. I turned the power off to the unit so I can't turn on the air circulating fan without going down to the furnace and turning the juice back on. One hypothesis might be that the wood stove is sucking air (no OAK) out of the living room and the slight vacuum is pulling air up through the path of least resistance, which would be the cold air return vent, which measures about 16" x 12".

Nick, the stack effect could also be moving air up and out of the house, replacing it with air from the lower level.
 
Yes, all the duct work is sealed and insulated, but I don't think that makes much of a difference since the ducts are all running along the ceiling of the unheated lower level (floor of the upper level of the house), so they are sitting in 55 F temperatures 24/7. I was just a bit surprised at how noticeable the cold air draft was that was rising from the floor return. A stream of 53 F air coming through such a large vent had to be doing a lot of cooling to the living room.
 
How many cold air returns do you have in the house?

Curious because our furnace draws in air from the area around it and the heated air is distributed through ducts and floor registers in every room that runs under the house where it's cold. We didn't use the furnace for a few years and I realized there was cold air rising from out of the registers. In order to seal them, I lifted the registers out and duct taped the bottoms before setting them back in place. By the time I got down to the last couple, with the majority being covered giving the cold air limited ways to escape, it was a big surprise at just how much cold air was coming out of them.
 
Yes, all the duct work is sealed and insulated, but I don't think that makes much of a difference since the ducts are all running along the ceiling of the unheated lower level (floor of the upper level of the house), so they are sitting in 55 F temperatures 24/7. I was just a bit surprised at how noticeable the cold air draft was that was rising from the floor return. A stream of 53 F air coming through such a large vent had to be doing a lot of cooling to the living room.

Are there air supply registers in this unheated lower level? Air could be entering them, going backwards though the furnace and exiting the return.
 
I think my intention for this post has been misunderstood. I know the cold air coming up through my cold air return is coming from my unheated lower level. My intention was to alert other members that they too could have cold air infiltrating their heated space if they have a similar set up to mine so that they could check and then close off the cold air return if cold air was coming through it, as is my situation. Thanks for the brainstorming.
 
  • Like
Reactions: tarzan
I'm with you - we have a small rug that we put over our cold air return when the furnace is switched off, for the reason you note.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.