njtomatoguy said:
Disco,
also depends on the toilet itself. The first generation 1.6 gal toilet were just that, needed some tweaking. unglazed trapway, less surface area, etc. The decent quality 1.6 gal toilet will have a glazed trapway, larger water surface area, and larger flush valve opening.
They do work, and they do save water, but using my house as an example:
Built in 1954
Cast iron, lead joint inside the crawl space, clay thru the foundation to orangeburg, with a cast iron cleanout tee in the yard, clay to the main in the street. Once whatever you flush gets thru the toilet is where the problems begin. Roots penetrate weak joints, orangeburg is an asphalt infused paper type pipe, and natural settling and shifting of the ground can cause a "belly" in the line, where solids can collect, decomposing into muck. The muck line is no fun to clear, with cables poking thru the blockage, but not breaking it.
Another contributing factor is the garbage disposal. Most people do not run the water at the sink long enough for the waste from the disposer to clear the line, and older model disposers do not gring up the food particles small enough not to cause a problem.
Insinkerator did develop a 3 blade disposer, I have installed a couple, no complaints so far.
Basically, if you didn't eat it, don't flush it. Use a fast degrading paper such as scotts or marcal, and minimize use of a garbage disposal.
Just my opinion,
Bob
Orangeburg (cringing)...ouch. Can you say "nightmare"????
Funny thing about orangeburg though... it weeds the DIY'ers out real fast! Sewer clogged?? Go rent an auger???
The result??
Bring back the auger with a busted 'head' (try getting your money back on that one...lol) Call the rooter man' "Ohh you busted the head... you probably have orangeburg..." If they do come out at that point??? No guarantee the problem will clear (and you still gotta pay)...
Last phone call... usually to an 'excavator'... "Yeah Hi...Wanna come out and give me an estimate on replacing my sewer main??"
Yup...fun stuff.
When I bought my house I made a stipulation for the closing to the seller "You either put 3K in an escrow account or pay for an inspection to be done certifying the condition of the sewer main...if there is any orangeburg we're back to a 3K escrow"...
Today...here in G-vegas it costs 3K just to "open up the street" for water or sewer.
Contrast???
My sisters' house in Oklahoma had an orangeburg sewer main. She found out a hard lesson.
SHe was telling me all about buying a new house...I tried to give her some helpfull advice. Most importantly not to be impatient(see if you can figure out why below)...
I had driven down from Colorado for thanksgiving. They had just bought the house and were still moving in. The first thing she says "the drains are running kinda slow". Later that night I'm outside having a cigarette and I hear a strange noise and go to investigate. A 'stream' of cloudy water is shooting 3 feet in the air from the outside cleanout.
Okay now what do you do???
She called the city works...they sent out the Vactor truck...they blew the city main clear 100' upstream and 700 feet downstream...
Try finding a rental store open on thanksgiving day...anywhere. HTF did I get roped into this. Sis is handy but dangerous...brother in law??? He's a lawyer...need I say more???
Kinda funny driving around...found one. First tried a hand auger...back to the rental place. Got a power one. Tried to auger it (carefully)...SNAP.
I knew what was next and thought of how to break the news to sis. On the ride to the rental place I tried to tell my brother in law how to break the news... I knew what she was in for, the only "saving grace" was that the city sewer main ran under her front lawn so she wasn't gonna get her cheeks parted too badly. Worse came to worse I told her the following weekend I would take some leave and help her replace it. "How much do you think it's gonna cost??" I figured $350 if we did it...around $800 for a 'local to do it'...
Luckily she found a local to do it..for $795.00
So what happened???
Seems the owners of the house weren't too kind to the college students living in the house...suffice to say "get out"..okay...smart college students??? What do they do to "get even"??
Yup...Flushed a pair of sweat pants down the mighty old 7 gallon flush american standard toilet. Given the fact the sewer line was clogged with roots (sure the owner knew it as well as the tenants...why else would they have thought of how to 'sabotage' it...I knew it trying to 'auger' it...course I always keep things in perspective.)
Made a nice "housewarming" present for sis'...and a lousy time to visit...and on 'Thanksgiving to boot'....
I still laugh about it though "What do I do until I can get it fixed???" my sister asked. "Same thing as always...I'll just leave the plug off the cleanout in your yard...just don't throw any parties in the meantime...and I would start looking around for a good gas station when you really gotta go...otherwise you're gonna have a lot of 'compost' to rake up...look on the bright side though...you ain't gonna have to water the lawn for awhile...and your grass will be pretty green in the future..." :ahhh: