Smoking XXV year two

  • Active since 1995, Hearth.com is THE place on the internet for free information and advice about wood stoves, pellet stoves and other energy saving equipment.

    We strive to provide opinions, articles, discussions and history related to Hearth Products and in a more general sense, energy issues.

    We promote the EFFICIENT, RESPONSIBLE, CLEAN and SAFE use of all fuels, whether renewable or fossil.

mtnbiker727

Feeling the Heat
Mar 11, 2019
420
PA
So last fall/winter, I don't know when, we bought a used XXV off Marketplace. The seller claimed he got it from a previous Harman Tech who replaced all the parts with new. The stove didn't outright smoke, but every time we used it we could smell the smoke and it burned our throats and eyes. I cleaned thoroughly and found the stove was treated terribly in the past. I checked the door gasket and replaced the ash pan gasket, cleaned the combustion fan and replaced the combustion fan blade. I siliconed and resiliconed the vent multiple times before giving up on it as a loss.

This fall we still hadn't decided what to do, and after a lead on a good used P43 fell through, I decided to reach out to the seller. The seller apologized and said he didn't know the stove had issues, because he had never used it. He offered me some money back. So at this point I decided to dig even deeper into the stove. I ordered a new combustion fan and the metal plate it goes through.

Here's what I discovered when I removed the burn pot after I had a suspicion there was an issue with it.

Still to come is redoing the vent pipe (again), and replacing the combustion fan.
 

Attachments

  • [Hearth.com] Smoking XXV year two
    1000039977.webp
    365.5 KB · Views: 70
  • [Hearth.com] Smoking XXV year two
    1000039978.webp
    199.8 KB · Views: 71
  • Like
Reactions: Washed-Up
Hope you took some cash back, not good and was that gasket in on piece or as in the photo?
Looks like it was run on a super low setting…reminds me of the $200 P61A I refurbished….drippy creosote
 
  • Like
Reactions: NS P-68
Used and abused. I have seen some beat-up and poorly taken care of stoves in my years .
I would never sell a stove that I personally cleaned, repaired and tested. I hope you did get some cash back .
 
Hope you took some cash back, not good and was that gasket in on piece or as in the photo?
Looks like it was run on a super low setting…reminds me of the $200 P61A I refurbished….drippy creosote

That's how it came apart. and it took a lot of effort to get that mess scraped off of it.

I still have to shine up the rust on the burn pot and it has some minor pitting I'm going to try to fill in with extreme heat JB Weld.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Washed-Up
Use the tinfoil tape on your chimney joints in the house instead of fighting with silicone. Been leak free since i installed. Probably not that gasket that is causing smoke issues as pellets stoves usually bury very clean with little to no smoke unless on a startup cycle.. How close is your fresh air intake to the exhaust?
If your smelling smoke its either not burning efficient and smoke is trickling up though the heat exchanger, or you have a leak on the exhaust side of things. Know anyone with a fog machine or any place to purchase a smoke generator you can light and toss in the burn pot and close the door. Then you will visually see the leaks, empty your hopper out and turn it on so the fans are running and it should tell you pretty quick where the leak is
 
  • Like
Reactions: johneh
We're the nuts loose on the burn pot by chance? Looks like that burn pot gasket has been leaking for some time.
Leaking pipe probably doesn't help either...
Previous Harman tech..?
They were not loose. It took some WD40 and some cranking to get them off. It doesn't help that I needed an extension and a universal joint because the burn pot is in the way of hitting them straight on.

Oh yeah, the seller claimed he bought it from a harman tech who had replaced all the parts with shiny new ones.
 
Use the tinfoil tape on your chimney joints in the house instead of fighting with silicone. Been leak free since i installed. Probably not that gasket that is causing smoke issues as pellets stoves usually bury very clean with little to no smoke unless on a startup cycle.. How close is your fresh air intake to the exhaust?
If your smelling smoke its either not burning efficient and smoke is trickling up though the heat exchanger, or you have a leak on the exhaust side of things. Know anyone with a fog machine or any place to purchase a smoke generator you can light and toss in the burn pot and close the door. Then you will visually see the leaks, empty your hopper out and turn it on so the fans are running and it should tell you pretty quick where the leak is
I started out with my exhaust straight out the back, then after having smoke, I elevated it above the roofline, and the smoke situation didn't change. I spent a lot of time behind the stove with a flashlight looking for wisps of smoke on startup, but could never see anything. But the burning throat and eyes is pretty telling. No burning sensation in that room when the stove is off, but burning sensation when it is on.

I do not know anyone with a fog machine, but I had that thought. Maybe a smoke bomb made for flushing groundhogs out of their holes????

The interior of the stove is covered in thick black creosote. I just replaced the combustion fan motor and blade, but don't have the burnpot cleaned up yet, so I can't turn the stove on yet. Hopefully the combustion fan from 2008 was the main culprit this whole time...
 
I started out with my exhaust straight out the back, then after having smoke, I elevated it above the roofline, and the smoke situation didn't change. I spent a lot of time behind the stove with a flashlight looking for wisps of smoke on startup, but could never see anything. But the burning throat and eyes is pretty telling. No burning sensation in that room when the stove is off, but burning sensation when it is on.

I do not know anyone with a fog machine, but I had that thought. Maybe a smoke bomb made for flushing groundhogs out of their holes????

The interior of the stove is covered in thick black creosote. I just replaced the combustion fan motor and blade, but don't have the burnpot cleaned up yet, so I can't turn the stove on yet. Hopefully the combustion fan from 2008 was the main culprit this whole time...
THey make smoke bombs for this type of thing.. Should post some pic's of the rest of your setup..

Do you have smoke detectors and a CO detector in your home? One or the other should be going off if their is smoke in the house
 
The source of the leak is somewhere between the tail pice and where the pipe exits through the wall. From the front door to the combustion fan is under a vacuum. Smoke can not leak out, if a gasket was bad it would suck fresh air in. Post some pics of your piping set up and a pic of your pipe connected to the tail piece
 
  • Like
Reactions: ABusWrench
The source of the leak is somewhere between the tail pice and where the pipe exits through the wall. From the front door to the combustion fan is under a vacuum. Smoke can not leak out, if a gasket was bad it would suck fresh air in. Post some pics of your piping set up and a pic of your pipe connected to the tail piece
That's true in theory, but it doesn't actually work that way. Several years ago I had the wood burning smell in our house, and after quite a bit of work I figured out the door wasn't latching tightly enough. I adjusted the latch and the problem went away.
 
So an update: I installed the new combustion fan and the plate it goes through. I caulked the sides of the heat exchanger on the inside of the stove, because this is where I noticed the ash was not built up. I also reattached the Harman PVP appliance adapter and outside piping.

I turned it on for the first time tonight, and smoke was pouring out of the seam in the middle of the appliance adapter. I don't understand how the appliance adapter itself can leak! It's a factory piece that I didn't mess with! The piping is only inside the house for about 8 inches, so it's the stove, the appliance adapter, and the next piece of pipe, which is 2 feet long and goes out through the wall and outside to the termination cap.

So I put some of the stove cement on the seam in the middle of the appliance adapter, because I'm out of RTV silicon. Tomorrow I'm going to buy silicon tape and wrap it just to be sure.

I still don't know if I solved the problem or not. If I could pick up the stove, I would have thrown it out the window already.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ARC and Washed-Up
Is the seam on the top or bottom? I had to put mine on the bottom of mine so it didn’t leak, I siliconed it on outside on at stand though, hope you getter figured out…keep us posted
 
I wrapped the pipe in shark bite pipe wrap, which is rated up to 500 degrees and lit the stove. No more smoke out of the venting on startup.

BUT the burning smell in the room is just as strong as it ever was. I walked outside and smelled the vent pipe, and it's different from the smell inside the house.

It's been so long since I had a new stove, I don't remember what the curing paint smell smells like. But I would think I would remember the burning eyes and throat sensation that this stove is giving off... when I'm in there looking at the stove I can't wait to leave the room to get to fresh air.

I have an idea that the previous owner had the same problem, because I noticed clear silicone caulking in a few places, like the seam on the under side of the pellet hopper....

I wonder if I need to take the whole thing apart, and replace all the gaskets that connect the auger and the pellet hopper and whatever else? At what point do I cut my losses and send the stove to the scrap yard? I have about $2,700 in the stove including purchase price and new parts and many hours of work cleaning and trying to figure it out.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Washed-Up
Man this is an odd one…and seams in the hopper could leak…smoke maybe if heat exchangers are compromised…it’s tough to say
 
Man this is an odd one…and seams in the hopper could leak…smoke maybe if heat exchangers are compromised…it’s tough to say
I have wondered if it's the heat exchanger, and a crack that only opens when the stove warms up. But I have no way to prove this, and no way to remedy it if that's the case.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Washed-Up
Try a smoke pencil. Light it, put it into the stove.
Close the door and just watch for the smoke.
Smoke pencils are used to detect drafts around
windows and doors . No smell or taste from them.
Safe and harmless.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Washed-Up
Inside the stove, behind the ash box, have you correctly positioned the cover for the combustion fan? Also, open the hopper lid to see if the odor and smoke are coming from there.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Washed-Up
Inside the stove, behind the ash box, have you correctly positioned the cover for the combustion fan? Also, open the hopper lid to see if the odor and smoke are coming from there.
The combustion fan and cover are on the outside back of an XXV. I just replaced them with brand new parts. I will take it off and check to make sure it's on there correctly. It's not very easy to see when the stove is only 6 inches from the wall.

There is a vacuum hose inside the hopper of an XXV. The lid has to be tight or the vacuum switch won't let the stove start.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Washed-Up
Mine is a P68; I thought the XXV’s interior was the same as mine, behind the ash pan.
 
Could there be something in the heat exchanger that's causing that? Should be able to get a inspection camera in there.
 
THe suggestion has come up several times to get a smoke pencil/bomb and look for smoke exiting the unit.. Use tinfoil tape that is meant for heat ducting to seal up all joints inside the house especially any elbows. As far as cracks go for the heat exchanger i doubt that is the issue as my stove from factory you can see gaps and when the stove it burning properly their will be no smoke or fumes. Do you have your air intake set properly and not restricting so bad it does not have enough flow to burn properly and suck out the exhaust?

If you purchased the stove used im assuming it was worked prior to your purchase so any paint should already be burnt off unless the guy that "rebuilt it" repainted something and possibly used the wrong paint.

The only thing you should smell outside is a hot wood smell and their should be no smoke unless on startup just before the pellets ignite.

Maybe it would help if you posted pictures of your whole setup including exhaust, maybe a short vid of your stove working with the flame..

May be time to get on your hands and knees and sniff around as the smell should be more present at the source of the leak.
 
THe suggestion has come up several times to get a smoke pencil/bomb and look for smoke exiting the unit.. Use tinfoil tape that is meant for heat ducting to seal up all joints inside the house especially any elbows. As far as cracks go for the heat exchanger i doubt that is the issue as my stove from factory you can see gaps and when the stove it burning properly their will be no smoke or fumes. Do you have your air intake set properly and not restricting so bad it does not have enough flow to burn properly and suck out the exhaust?

If you purchased the stove used im assuming it was worked prior to your purchase so any paint should already be burnt off unless the guy that "rebuilt it" repainted something and possibly used the wrong paint.

The only thing you should smell outside is a hot wood smell and their should be no smoke unless on startup just before the pellets ignite.

Maybe it would help if you posted pictures of your whole setup including exhaust, maybe a short vid of your stove working with the flame..

May be time to get on your hands and knees and sniff around as the smell should be more present at the source of the leak.


I just got the stove all put back together and ran it for the first time after making a bunch of changes. I was hoping those changes would take care of the issue. Now that I confirmed they didn't, I will look at something like a smoke bomb.

The last owner of the stove never used the stove inside his house, so he has no idea what condition the stove was in, other than it lit and got hot while outside in his garage. He was unable to reach the person he bought it from after I complained to him about the smoke smell. Coincidence?

I have had a pellet stove for 9 seasons, I know what things should smell like. I have spent hours sniffing around this stove and laying on the ground behind it with a flashlight over the past 8 months. Thanks for all your love and support.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Washed-Up
Like i said post up a bunch of pics as someone might see something very obvious that you are over looking because you are frustrated.. Not sure how many hours you have ran it for yet or how many the stove has total on it but a possibility is its still trying to burn grease, oil, paint off from being built?

Not sure if the blowers were changed but one could be the wrong blower wrong speed and its causing the stove not to have a vacuum and creating pressure in the stove so things are seeping out where ever they can.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Washed-Up
The negative pressure (draft) from the air intake to the inlet to the combustion blower isn’t just theory, it’s the design for safety reasons to prevent smoke /CO from escaping from the stove from the various gaskets seals or even a cracked heat exchanger. The stoves are not sealed 100% airtight.
When the stove is new or the combustion fan is replaced the draft should be measured and the fan speed adjusted if necessary. Attached is the procedure, it’s also in the owners manual. You can buy the parts/pieces off of Amazon or eBay.
Instead of measuring at the plug you can also tee onto the line going to the pressure switch which is supposed to be a sat device to insure proper draft.
Hope this helps in finding out what’s going on.
 

Attachments

  • [Hearth.com] Smoking XXV year two
    IMG_0135.webp
    148.4 KB · Views: 2