anyone have a good tv antenna that you would like to recommend and you live out in the country? I was looking at RCA ANT1650 Flat Digital Amplified Indoor TV Antenna. Seems to have good reviews, but I am not 100% sold on it. any suggestions
chrisasst said:anyone have a good tv antenna that you would like to recommend and you live out in the country? I was looking at RCA ANT1650 Flat Digital Amplified Indoor TV Antenna. Seems to have good reviews, but I am not 100% sold on it. any suggestions
dvellone said:As important as the antenna if you're a ways from the broadcasting station is a good quality amplifier (read: not radio shack)
jdemaris said:dvellone said:As important as the antenna if you're a ways from the broadcasting station is a good quality amplifier (read: not radio shack)
Not entirely true. Yes a good amp is needed in fringe areas. Not true that all Radio Shack amps are bad or inferior.
I've tested every major brand high-gain amp sold in the USA as well as two, very exspensive ultra-low-noise British amps.
That included the dual-input Channel Master and the highest dB Winegard.
The 30dB gain Radio Shack amp actually made by Antenna Craft worked as well as the other leading models. Even better for some channels since it has an ajustable gain control.
Being in the Adirondacks has nothing to do with it. The terrain varies all over the park as it does in other areas.
jdemaris said:dvellone said:As important as the antenna if you're a ways from the broadcasting station is a good quality amplifier (read: not radio shack)
Not entirely true. Yes a good amp is needed in fringe areas. Not true that all Radio Shack amps are bad or inferior.
I've tested every major brand high-gain amp sold in the USA as well as two, very exspensive ultra-low-noise British amps.
That included the dual-input Channel Master and the highest dB Winegard.
The 30dB gain Radio Shack amp actually made by Antenna Craft worked as well as the other leading models. Even better for some channels since it has an ajustable gain control.
Being in the Adirondacks has nothing to do with it. The terrain varies all over the park as it does in other areas.
dvellone said:Being in the Adirondacks has a great impact on reception. Between the heavy forest cover and mountains there is much to inhibit reception
As far as radio shack amps go I'll stick with my opinion. My brother was an electrical engineer for Phillips and they used to run tests on amps .
colebrookman said:We use the Winegard platinum series antenna with their amp and we've had good results. We also have a rotor which, at least for us, is needed. WE get 40 or more channels by turning the antenna but usually go back to 10 or less favorites. My neighbor a half mile away has the same antenna but gets different channels. Go figure. Be safe.
Ed
Do you have a digital tuner in your TV, or are you running an analog TV through a converter box? The converter boxes generally have excellent tuners...chrisasst said:anyone have one of these
Terk HDTVa Indoor Amplified High-Definition Antenna for Off-Air HDTV Reception
Woody Stover said:Do you have a digital tuner in your TV, or are you running an analog TV through a converter box? The converter boxes generally have excellent tuners...chrisasst said:anyone have one of these
Terk HDTVa Indoor Amplified High-Definition Antenna for Off-Air HDTV Reception
Running a TVFool for Cortland, NY shows two stations that would be easy to get with an indoor antenna and amp. All stations available to you are 2-edge diffraction (signal must crest two ridges to get to you.) Tough location.
This is the best small antenna I've found (it's really an outdoor unit, but it's small enough to use indoors.) It's essentially a UHF antenna, but does OK on VHF. You'd have to make a little stand to mount it on. You only have one VHF station, CBS in Binghampton, the rest are UHF and basically North of you. This antenna is bi-directional and picks up off the back of the antenna, which might enable you to get the couple of stations toward Syracuse, and the CBS in Binghampton without adjusting the antenna.
Go here, type in your address, and map it. The default antenna height is 10'. Try 15 and 20' and see if the noise margins improve. That will tell you weather it's worth going to the trouble to try for more stations with an outdoor set-up (better signal, but you have to worry about lightning protection, etc.) Then click on "Make radar plot" and post a screen shot. Failing that, you can copy and paste the numbers here. (Or if you're comfortable with it, PM me your addy and I'll check it out for you.)
http://tvfool.com/?option=com_wrapper&Itemid=90
If you go this route, get the genuine Antennas Direct DB2, not a knock-off:
http://www.solidsignal.com/pview.asp?mc=03&p=DB2&d=Antennas-Direct-DB2-UHF-HDTV-Antenna-(DB2)&c=TV Antennas&sku;=
Here's the pre-amp I use:
http://www.solidsignal.com/pview.asp?mc=03&p=AP8275&d=Winegard-AP8275-Chromstar-2000-Series-VHFUHF-Pre-Amplifier-(AP8275)&c=Pre-Amplifiers&sku;=
I have a DB4 also, and didn't notice any difference indoors. Actually, I think the DB2 did a little better. That RCA antenna doesn't have a preamp...not enough gain to pull in anything, based on the numbers for Cortland. Those numbers are for a location that looks like it's the main intersection in the middle of town. The problem with that location is that it is at less than 1200 ft. elevation and is surrounded by 1500 ft. hills. That's why I'd like to see the numbers at your actual location. Also, the NM numbers that they give are based on an outdoor antenna, and don't take into account nearby man-made obstructions, trees etc. If you have a lot of trees between your antenna and the station, you may have multipath trouble when it's windy.chrisasst said:Amazon has good reviews on this one. Do you think the next one up would be any better. ( Antennas Direct DB4 Multi-Directional HDTV Antenna ) for $11 more or not. I just tried an rca ant 111 and couldn't get anything..
chrisasst said:anyone have a good tv antenna that you would like to recommend and you live out in the country? I was looking at RCA ANT1650 Flat Digital Amplified Indoor TV Antenna. Seems to have good reviews, but I am not 100% sold on it. any suggestions
Woody Stover said:I have a DB4 also, and didn't notice any difference indoors. Actually, I think the DB2 did a little better. That RCA antenna doesn't have a preamp...not enough gain to pull in anything, based on the numbers for Cortland. Those numbers are for a location that looks like it's the main intersection in the middle of town. The problem with that location is that it is at less than 1200 ft. elevation and is surrounded by 1500 ft. hills. That's why I'd like to see the numbers at your actual location. Also, the NM numbers that they give are based on an outdoor antenna, and don't take into account nearby man-made obstructions, trees etc. If you have a lot of trees between your antenna and the station, you may have multipath trouble when it's windy.chrisasst said:Amazon has good reviews on this one. Do you think the next one up would be any better. ( Antennas Direct DB4 Multi-Directional HDTV Antenna ) for $11 more or not. I just tried an rca ant 111 and couldn't get anything..
Are you considering putting an antenna outside? If you want to try inside first, be aware that the construction of your home can affect reception, too. Aluminum siding, a masonry exterior, or roofing materials for an attic install, may cut signal strength. As you may have gathered from reading this thread, this stuff is way more involved than deciding which stove to buy.
If your numbers are similar to the Cortland numbers, I'd say that you'll be able to get the two strongest stations for sure with a DB2 and the preamp, inside a stick construction home. The stations I reliably get inside range from 61 NM LOS to 13 NM 1-edge.
On TVFool, you can pick the "hybrid" view, put the antenna on the exact location on your home, at the correct and have it draw lines to the transmitters to see if there are any obstructions that may affect the signal.
If you decide to go outside with a rotor, you should be able to do much better. Previous posters have mentioned some great antennas for fringe reception.
Good luck.I hope you report back with the results, whatever you decide to do.
chrisasst said:Here is a question, I do have a very old antenna already on top of my house. I hooked that up to my tv and got nothing. I am still learning about this stuff so, a) with out climbing the roof and look at it, the wires may have rusted, or b) Do the older antenna still work with the newer tv's ?
chrisasst said:Woody Stover said:chrisasst said:Amazon has good reviews on this one. Do you think the next one up would be any better. ( Antennas Direct DB4 Multi-Directional HDTV Antenna ) for $11 more or not.
Here is my address 4886 health camp rd, cortland ny 13045... I don't see the hybrid view on tvfool?
Also, question about a converter box, I have hdtv's that I am pretty sure have tuners in them, so I don't need a converter box correct?
You must have a digital tuner. If your TVs are HD units sold as 'televisions" and not as HD monitors, they must be digital. A coverter box actually loses the HD, since it converts the digital signal to analog.
If you're looking for a DB antenna, why not get a DB8? It' not very big and it's a great UHF antenna.
I took a peek at the signals for your area. If you have a clear shot at 180 degreees (going by a compass), you ought to get two VHF channels fine. Channel 7 CBS and channel 8 Fox. 7 will show up as 12.1 and 8 will show as 40.1. Those are the only two VHF channels you're apt to get. All the rest is UHF - e.g. 19, 24, 44, 25, 17, and 47 should pull in fairly easy unless you have a huge obstruction in the way. Those are the actual RF channel number, and NOT the "virtual" numbers they call themselves.
chrisasst said:Do you think the next one up would be any better. ( Antennas Direct DB4 Multi-Directional HDTV Antenna ) for $11 more or not.
The hybrid view and other buttons are on the google map in the upper right corner.chrisasst said:Here is my address...I don't see the hybrid view on tvfool?
Any of the DB antennas are designed to be used outside. Several of your strongest stations are up toward Syracuse in the same general area, so you may be able to get a good basic selection without a rotor. For indoors, you may be able to place the antenna in a window that faces toward the cluster of stations, or maybe the siding won't be an issue. Not sure if you have a second story, but an upstairs window facing the stations would be great. An attic install will lose some signal through roofing materials, but it may work. Indoors is always easier, no lightning worries, not subject to weather, but the signal is better with steel in the air.chrisasst said:Also I do have Aluminum siding so I may be fighting a loosing battle with an inside antenna then right? Can a DB2 be put outside?
Probably not, as jdemaris stated. In your manual, it will tell you if you have an ATSC (digital) tuner.chrisasst said:I have hdtv's that I am pretty sure have tuners in them, so I don't need a converter box correct?
We use essential cookies to make this site work, and optional cookies to enhance your experience.