St-Croix Hastings vs Quad Castile

Bru Posted By Bru, Oct 8, 2012 at 12:49 PM

  1. Bru

    Bru
    New Member 2.
    NULL
    

    Oct 8, 2012
    1
    0
    I currently have a Tradition T300P-2 that I have never been able to run right (soot, poor combustion despite cleaning and was not able to remove the comb blower for clean-up). Venting is going straight up for 13 ft then, 2x45 deg and then straight up again for another 7-8 ft. Total eq lenght is about 20-23 ft on a 3" diameter vent. I know the venting is not ideal, but was already there when I bought the house and would be difficult to replace.

    Looking at several reviews on the tradition, I found that I was not the only one having problems with this stove. Most of people had similar issues with that stove unfortunately. Sad, cause it really looks nice.

    I am now considering replacing the stove for a new one keeping the same old style design. Looking on the internet, I found the St-Croix Hastling and Quad Castile being good candidates for a replacement, but I wanted to know your opinion about the those stove (which one the best). What are pros and cons ? Heard that Castile is pretty noisy and is not as good as other Quad stoves...is that true ??

    Also, interested to know how easy is to access the mechanical components for repairs and how easy are they to clean. Do you think with my current venting design, I'll be able to run one of these stove correctly.

    I have a harman p61 in the basement and really like the mechnical aspect of it. Very easy to clean and repair.

    Thanks for your inputs, very appreciated.
     
  2. Don2222

    Don2222
    Minister of Fire 2.
    NULL
    

    Feb 1, 2010
    7,866
    469
    Loc:
    Salem NH
    Hello
    I worked on a St. Croix Hastings and Quadrafires. They are different. They Hasting like all St. Croix stoves has a Versa Grate and needs special care and lubrication each year to keep it going. It is an older design. The quadrafire is a great stove. The Quads have a jamb proof auger design that works quite well and needs no special care.

    Many stoves have noisy high pitched motors. One of my friends had one in his Enviro EF-2, while the high pitched wine did not bother me. (I can hear it) It drove my friend crazy! So I got a Fasco Generic exhaust blower replacement to upgrade his OEM blower. The new blower has Oil plugs so once a year a few drops of oil will make it last many, many years. The main issue was resolved. No Hi Pitched wine and my friend said he cannot even hear it!

    That is what I found. Please put where you are in your Avatar so we can better help you.
    Good Luck.
     
  3. Brune

    Brune
    Member 2.
    NULL
    

    Dec 12, 2010
    19
    0
    Loc:
    Sherbrooke, Canada
    Thanks for the quick reply, good info here !!
     
  4. Don2222

    Don2222
    Minister of Fire 2.
    NULL
    

    Feb 1, 2010
    7,866
    469
    Loc:
    Salem NH
    Hello

    Your welcome. I have a Quadrafire Santa Fe in my shed with a switch in the house that switches the T-Stat on. Works great, when I go out there after breakfast it is a comfy 70 Deg F.

    Click on pic to enlarge.
     

    Attached Files:

  5. Ironhorse74

    Ironhorse74
    Member 2.
    NULL
    

    Oct 24, 2009
    246
    12
    Loc:
    The Great Pacific North Wet
    The Hastings is 5000 btu more input than the Quad and is 82% efficient. I have never seen an efficiency number on a Quad. Like all St Croix stoves it is tight and a great heater. It also does not have a steel box hanging off the back of a cast iron stove.
     
  6. smwilliamson

    smwilliamson
    Minister of Fire 2.
    NULL
    

    Dec 28, 2009
    4,475
    773
    Loc:
    Southcoast, MA
    You need to remove the combustion motor and blast some air down the left and right passage ways on the heat exhangers while vacuuming from the motor port....maybe a realeign of your door hinge too. Will burn like new.
     
  7. smwilliamson

    smwilliamson
    Minister of Fire 2.
    NULL
    

    Dec 28, 2009
    4,475
    773
    Loc:
    Southcoast, MA
    I would choose the castile
     
  8. Fish On

    Fish On
    Feeling the Heat 2.
    NULL
    

    Oct 19, 2009
    390
    34
    Loc:
    The other Cape..
    all stoves make noise no matter what they are. there is a lot of moving parts. i have a castile and i love it. heats my whole house and looks great.

    that is why i bought mine for a insert it looks like it belongs there.

    and its not hard to work on just replaced my Auger motor and it was a breeze to do.

    not matter what you buy good luck!
     
  9. krooser

    krooser
    Minister of Fire 2.
    NULL
    

    Jan 2, 2008
    2,423
    77
    Loc:
    Waupaca, WI
    I have a 1997 St Croix that has been bulletproof... I have owned it 8 years and replaced one ignitor and learned to clean it. My vote is for a St. Croix... screw the looks but a stove for it's performance.
     

Share This Page