Advice on insert vs stove to replace Superior zero clearance fireplace

[PAbeech]

They aren't so easy to pull out. Often they are built in with the facia needing to be removed.

I pulled out mine 2 years ago required some cutting with a Sawzall, wasn't that bad if you are capable

 

[bholler]

They aren't so easy to pull out. Often they are built in with the facia needing to be removed.

They actually are really easy. I don't do many and can still have them out in about an hour.

The problem is even with an insert in them you still have a crappy drafty zero clearance box and you can cover the vents.

 

[begreen]

This can be done, It depends on how the old one was installed, facia covering, access to the rear, hearth, etc. If the goal is to keep as much intact as possible, then easy rear access and a lot of careful measuring is where to start.

 

[hoot]

Problem is if you take one out you can what do you do then? Can you get a different ZC in with the existing structure/dimensions?
I solved the problem. Installing a Lopi Insert.

 

[PAbeech]

Problem is if you take one out you can what do you do then? Can you get a different ZC in with the existing structure/dimensions?
I solved the problem. Installing a Lopi Insert.

I put a pacific energy high efficiency zc unit in

 

[begreen]

There have been a few that came here for advice and made the switch. If the enclosure size, basic framing, and opening size is similar then it's possible though easier with rear access.

 

[hoot]

I'll document my install

 

[begreen]

That will be different than what @triceps is considering if a freestanding stove is to be vented via a liner thru the ZC. The main factor with what he has proposed is the lintel height.